Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Graham can't win pay debate with Bucs

History shows that despite deserving more, running back Earnest Graham, seen here leaping into the end zone last season, won’t convince the Bucs to throw money at him by skipping workouts.


History shows that despite deserving more, running back Earnest Graham, seen here leaping into the end zone last season, won’t convince the Bucs to throw money at him by skipping workouts.

TAMPA — Jon Gruden and Warrick Dunn walked away from a workout together on Thursday, the sound of their laughter carrying across the field. It made you wonder if, somewhere, Earnest Graham was listening.

The Buccaneers are more than halfway through voluntary offseason workouts, and Graham remains conspicuously absent. It is not yet a holdout. It is not yet a showdown.

But it is getting worrisome. For both the Bucs, and for Graham.

"He's a key member of our team," Gruden said. "I hope Earnest gets in here soon."

Let's begin by acknowledging Graham deserves a raise. It's hard to begrudge him that.

His $605,000 salary for 2008 does not match his expanded role in Tampa Bay's offense. And, after five years of knocking around the league, this may be his best and only chance to cash in on a bigger contract.

So, yes, Earnest Graham is right.

But that doesn't mean he will win.

There's a difference between valuable and indispensable, and there is no way Graham will negotiate his way across that divide. At least not in this contract debate.

The truth is, running backs in this league come and go. Tiki Barber retired, and the Giants plugged in Brandon Jacobs and won a Super Bowl. The Packers lost Ahman Green and found Ryan Grant. The Broncos recently had four different 1,000-yard rushers in a five-year span. Heck, the Bucs went through Cadillac Williams and Michael Pittman before turning desperately to Graham last season.

The point is there are a handful of truly elite backs, and then there is everyone else. Maybe Graham, 28, deserves more than the typical NFL back, but he is not going to get sackfuls of cash thrown in his locker.

The Bucs, rightfully so, have already lined up alternatives. They re-signed Michael Bennett in February. They picked up Dunn a few weeks later. Both are scheduled to make more money than Graham this season.

Again, that can't make Graham happy. And the Bucs should be willing to bump his salary somewhere between Bennett's $1.25-million three-year average salary and Dunn's $3-million two-year average.

But Graham has to realize a huge signing bonus and a long-term commitment for a running back with three 100-yard games to his name just isn't a wise business decision. Particularly for a player already under contract.

What's surprising about this impasse is Graham has always understood his role in this game. When he went undrafted out of Florida, he did not sit on the sideline pouting. He did not cry about the injustice.

Graham figured out the key to his survival was adapting and adjusting. He learned to play special teams. He learned how to be an effective blocker. He swallowed his pride enough to play in the shadows of others.

I suppose he figures his time has come and, in a way, it has. But he also has to be careful not to overplay his hand. If the Keenan McCardell, Jake Plummer and Chris Simms situations have taught us anything, it is that the Bucs are not afraid to play hardball when it comes to their assets.

By and large, contract disputes are easily classified. You have your greedy players, or you have your cheap owners, and it isn't terribly hard to see which one is rushing toward asinine. The troubling part of this particular disagreement is that neither side is blatantly at fault.

It really is difficult to criticize Graham for seeking the payday that has eluded him the past five years. But it is also difficult to imagine he has the leverage to pull off this gambit.

I wonder if Graham recalls the story of Errict Rhett.

He was a star at the University of Florida, just like Graham. He came to Tampa Bay and found himself woefully underpaid as the team's starting tailback, just like Graham. Agent Drew Rosenhaus suggested a renegotiation, just as he has done for Graham.

The Bucs offered to tear up Rhett's contract and pay him millions, but he wasn't satisfied. He skipped some voluntary offseason workouts, and then skipped training camp, too. The Bucs pulled their offer off the table and fined Rhett for every day of work he missed.

Seven games into the season, Rhett finally figured out his career was at risk and crawled back to the locker room. Between lost wages and the contract he never signed, Rhett lost at least $2-million and probably far more.

He also fell out of favor in Tampa Bay and was reduced to a backup role the next season.

His replacement?

A rookie named Warrick Dunn.

John Romano can be reached at

Graham can't win pay debate with Bucs 05/22/08 [Last modified: Friday, May 30, 2008 12:02pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. State baseball: Bishop McLaughlin bows out of Class 3A semifinals


    FORT MYERS — One inning into Bishop McLaughlin's Class 3A state semifinal against Fort Myers Canterbury, things could not have gone much better for the Hurricanes. They grabbed a quick one-run lead and Canterbury ace Sam Keating was forced out of the game with a nagging neck injury.

     Chris Berglund (18) of Bishop McLaughlin, at bat during second inning of the FHSAA class 3A semi-final on Friday May 26, 2017 at Hammond Stadium in Fort Myers, Fla. Canterbury, Fort Myers, defeated Bishop 7 to 4. Canterbury will play in the 3A championship tomorrow.
  2. Bucs WR DeSean Jackson knows only one direction: full speed ahead


    TAMPA — DeSean Jackson is the "1."

    Actually, Jackson, the Bucs' latest weapon for quarterback Jameis Winston, with his blazing speed and game-changing splash plays, wears No. 11 in games.

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers wide receiver DeSean Jackson participates in an "open OTA practice" at One Buc Place, the team's training facility, in Tampa, Fla., on Tuesday, May 23, 2017.
  3. Video preview: Rays open tough road trip facing Twins tonight


    After splitting a four-game series against the Angels to wrap up a winning homestand, the Rays tonight open a nine-game, 10-day roadtrip with the first game of the weekend series with the Twins:

  4. For starters: Rays, Archer take on surprising Twins to open road trip


    UPDATE, 5:45: And here is the Twins lineup:
    Dozier 2b
    Mauer 1b
    Sano 3b
    Kepler rf
    Vargas dh
    Polanco ss
    Rosario lf
    Buxton cf
    Castro c
    Santiago p

  5. Hard to believe NFL overtime change is about player safety


    If someone's house was engulfed in flames, would you hand him a fire extinguisher?

    Of course not.

    Fans await the beginning of overtime between the Patriots and Falcons in Super Bowl LI in February. [Associated Press]