Tuesday, April 24, 2018
Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Jones: Are Panthers the best ever with a Super Bowl win?

Let's say the Carolina Panthers win Sunday's Super Bowl 50.

Let's say quarterback Cam Newton throws over and runs through the Broncos defense.

Let's say Carolina's defense kicks Denver quarterback Peyton Manning into retirement.

Let's say the Panthers dominate the Broncos on offense, defense and special teams, and turn the biggest sporting event of the year into the biggest snoozer with a blowout victory.

If Carolina crushes Denver, wouldn't we then have to consider whether the Panthers are the greatest NFL team of all time?

No one is going to say that. Just isn't going to happen.

Oh, the parts about Cam going crazy and Peyton being shut down and the Panthers rolling to a dominating victory certainly seem realistic, if not predictable.

But putting the Panthers alongside some of the NFL's best-ever teams? They just aren't getting that kind of respect.

And it's hard to understand why.

They have what might be the best offensive player in the game with Newton. They have what might be the best defensive player in the game with linebacker Luke Kuechly. They have what could be the coach of the year in Ron Rivera. And if they win Sunday, they will finish with a 18-1 record. That alone — 18-1 — suggests they should be put up there with all the NFL's greatest teams.

That's rare stuff. Know who else went 18-1?

The '85 Bears, always included in greatest-ever talk. The '84 49ers with Joe Montana always make the list.

The '72 Dolphins were a perfect 17-0, and that puts them in the conversation.

By going 18-1, the Panthers would finish with a better record that any of the great Steelers Super Bowl-winning teams of the 1970s and any of the Bill Belichick-Tom Brady Patriots championship teams. (The 2007 Pats went 18-1 but did not win the Super Bowl.)

An 18-1 record would be better than that of other teams always thrown into the best-ever mix, such as the 1991 Redskins and the 1999 "Greatest Show on Turf" Rams and some of Vince Lombardi's Packers teams of the 1960s.

So why isn't anyone picking up a chisel and hammer to start carving the Panthers onto football's Mount Rushmore?

For starters, we tend to look at older teams more fondly than current ones.

In our memories, Montana never threw an interception, the Steel Curtain never allowed a touchdown, and the '85 Bears won every game 100-0. Don Shula, Joe Gibbs and Lombardi never made a bad decision. Jerry Rice never dropped a ball, and Kurt Warner threw like a thousand touchdown passes that one season.

We see the warts on the Panthers because we watch every play. The videotape in our minds of all the great teams of the past has the fumbles, interceptions and losses edited out. We've erased all the mistakes.

Plus, we have the benefit of looking back at the entire careers of the retired superstars from those classic teams. When we think of Montana, we don't take a snapshot of the 28-year-old quarterback who won the Super Bowl in January of 1985. We think of the Hall of Famer who won four Super Bowls.

Same with legendary figures such as Bears running back Walter Payton and Steelers quarterback Terry Bradshaw, and even Brady.

Players such as Newton and Kuechly, both in their mid 20s, are still too young to give us any type of real perspective. Until they prove they can keep up the standard they've set for the next decade, we aren't ready to put them in the same class as Hall of Famers, though the old-timers weren't Hall of Famers when they won their Super Bowls.

The Steelers of the 1970s had nine Hall of Fame players and a Hall of Fame coach. The Panthers have, well, none because they are all still playing. It's like comparing apples to oranges, or in this case, like mythical icons to real people.

There's more.

Some argue that the Panthers played a soft schedule. That's partly true. They came out of the so-so NFC South. Still, the Panthers beat the defending NFC champion Seahawks twice. And they beat the Packers. And the Cardinals. They beat Drew Brees twice. And possible rookie of the year Jameis Winston twice. They went 6-0 against quarterbacks who have won Super Bowls. The schedule wasn't that bad.

Besides, you know who else played a ridiculously soft schedule? The '72 Dolphins. Yet no one ever brings that up.

That great Bears team in 1985? No other team in its division finished over .500. Same thing with the '99 Rams. Yet none of those teams ever gets knocked for having a soft schedule.

Could it be that we're not ready to give the Panthers the benefit of the doubt because this could be their one and only championship? The Bears have only one. The Rams didn't repeat; they haven't won another.

Of course, we are getting ahead of ourselves. The Panthers haven't won yet, and even if they do win, maybe we should let them enjoy this one instead of worrying about where it ranks all time.

Still, 18-1.

That's a heck of a team. Among the best ever.

Let's say that.

     
 
Comments
Polly want a sacker: Bucs’ 4th-round draft pick to be delivered by parrot

Polly want a sacker: Bucs’ 4th-round draft pick to be delivered by parrot

Late-round NFL draft picks are often made on a wing and a prayer.The Bucs' fourth-round pick Saturday will be no different. The team announced Monday that as part of the NFL draft TV broadcast, the team's fourth-round pick will be delivered to an ann...
Published: 04/23/18
How Baker Mayfield can benefit the Bucs

How Baker Mayfield can benefit the Bucs

TAMPA — The buzz surrounding this year's NFL draft is a class of talented quarterbacks deep enough to challenge the record six taken in the first round in 1983, a group that included future Hall of Famers John Elway, Jim Kelly and Dan Marino.Th...
Published: 04/22/18
Ex-NFL kicker Jay Feely apologizes for ‘joke’ gun photo

Ex-NFL kicker Jay Feely apologizes for ‘joke’ gun photo

Former NFL kicker Jay Feely, who was born in Odessa and starred at Tampa Jesuit, has apologized for a photo he intended as a joke, showing him holding a gun as he poses with his daughter and her prom date."Wishing my beautiful daughter and her date a...
Published: 04/22/18
Shaquem Griffin: ‘I’m not just a feel-good story’

Shaquem Griffin: ‘I’m not just a feel-good story’

TAMPA — Shaquem Griffin wakes up knowing each day will be better than the last and barely able to wait until tomorrow."It's just a whirlwind,'' Griffin said.On Thursday, he will walk the red carpet with his family, including his twin brother, S...
Published: 04/21/18
Bucs not listening to outsiders, but expectations remain high for 2018

Bucs not listening to outsiders, but expectations remain high for 2018

TAMPA —Wait 'til this year seems to be the refrain at One Buc Place, even though the team was strangled by expectations in 2017. But a solid offseason that has already brought a rebuilt defensive line, new center and place-kicker has renewed th...
Published: 04/21/18
NFL draft confessions: The Bucs set the trap, and I took the cheese on Johnny Manziel

NFL draft confessions: The Bucs set the trap, and I took the cheese on Johnny Manziel

TAMPA — The NFL draft is one big game of Liar's Poker. Deal me out.Even the guys with a seat at the table don't know when someone is bluffing.Bucs general manager Jason Licht knows that the team's No. 7 overall pick this year will be affected b...
Published: 04/20/18
Bucs’ Jameis Winston, Mike Evans catch Miami Heat game from courtside

Bucs’ Jameis Winston, Mike Evans catch Miami Heat game from courtside

We've seen Jameis Winston and Mike Evans bonding this offseason, going to Texas A&M pro day together, among other events. The two Bucs stars and their significant others double-dated Thursday night, getting courtside seats to watch the Miami Heat in ...
Published: 04/20/18
Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Bucs have a tough start to their schedule

Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Bucs have a tough start to their schedule

The NFL did the Bucs no favors with their 2018 schedule, Rick Stroud says, making them open at New Orleans, followed by home games against Philadelphia and Pittsburgh Plus, linebacker Kendall Beckwith had surgery to repair a broken ankle, p...
Published: 04/20/18
Here’s the Bucs’ full 2018 schedule

Here’s the Bucs’ full 2018 schedule

TAMPA — How good can the Bucs be in 2018? Fans will get a good sense in the first three weeks, as Tampa Bay opens the year with three of its toughest games, all against reigning division champions. The Bucs open 2018 in New Orleans on Sept. 9 ...
Published: 04/19/18
Updated: 04/20/18
Bucs linebacker Kendell Beckwith fractured ankle in car accident

Bucs linebacker Kendell Beckwith fractured ankle in car accident

TAMPA – Bucs linebacker Kendell Beckwith had surgery to repair a broken ankle he suffered in a car accident in Louisiana last week, putting his status for the start of the season in question.Beckwith was passenger in car driven by former L...
Published: 04/19/18