Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

NFL players, owners disagree on 18-game season; Will it happen? Should it?

Roger Goodell says the league has fans in mind, but owners also cite money as a motivation in replacing two preseason games with two regular-season games.

Getty Images

Roger Goodell says the league has fans in mind, but owners also cite money as a motivation in replacing two preseason games with two regular-season games.

After a regular season featuring 17 weeks of thrills and a postseason capped by an entertaining Super Bowl with a record-breaking TV audience, it might seem a no-brainer to give America what it can't get enough of:

More NFL.

That's what the league says is behind its push to expand the regular season from 16 to 18 games. Though there are other issues, that one has become a major sticking point in the ongoing labor fight between owners and players and threatens to bring the world's most lucrative sports enterprise to a standstill.

Commissioner Roger Goodell seems intent on making the change. Players continue to band together in staunch opposition.

Will it happen? Should it happen?

There are few absolutes. In fact, the only thing that is clear is the sides' disparate points of view.

The league's owners have approached the issue by appealing to fans' disdain for meaningless preseason games. The current proposal would reduce the four-game preseason to two, replacing the final two preseason games with two additional regular-season contests.

"Repeatedly, the fans have said the quality of the preseason doesn't meet NFL standards," Goodell said during his Super Bowl address last week. "That is one of the basis on which we started to look at the 18-and-two concept, by taking two of those low-quality, noncompetitive (preseason) games and turn those into quality, competitive (regular season) games that the fans want to see.

"I feel an obligation to make sure we are doing the best we can to present the best football."

Goodell has targeted season-ticket holders in particular, because they are charged full price for preseason games.

The NFL Players Association, whose members are preparing to be locked out by owners when the collective bargaining agreement expires in three weeks on March 3, is steadfastly against the proposal. It contends more regular-season games will result in an increase in injuries and shortened careers.

They cite rising injury numbers. Union data said 352 players ended this season on injured reserve, including 13 Buccaneers (up from 250 overall in 2009). Among those players, a total of 3,278 games were missed, each player averaging 9.5 games on IR.

"You can't paint the picture any clearer than that," said George Atallah, NFLPA assistant executive director of external affairs.

While the total number of games (preseason and regular season) would remain at 20, the cumulative effect of playing more regular-season games will be absorbed mostly by prominent players. They play sparingly in the preseason when rosters can have as many as 80 players, spreading out the wear and tear. When the regular season begins, rosters are capped at 53 as starters play their requisite 40 or 50 snaps.

Over the years, the toll of two additional games could add up.

"We had 352 active players finish on injured reserve," said Browns linebacker Scott Fujita, a member of the union's influential executive committee. "That's a really, really high number. And the way 18 games so far has been proposed, with no consideration for players and post-career benefits, making sure players are taken care of over the long haul … it's disappointing.

"It feels like a slap in the face."

Fujita added that players currently receive five years of health coverage after their careers end, but, "When I talk to players who retired, eight, nine, 10 years ago, a lot of those guys didn't really have any issues in their first five years post-career. A lot of issues started … eight, nine, 10 years post-career when you've got to get another knee operation, or you've got to get a knee replacement or hip replacement. Those are the things that cost a whole lot of money."

Fewer preseason games also means marginal players trying to make the roster will have less of an opportunity to prove themselves to coaches.

But to a great extent, this fight hinges on the same issue holding up the labor negotiations: money.

For all the talk of giving fans what they want, owners openly acknowledge they want to expand the season because they think it will result in additional revenue. And players seem willing to discuss the expansion if they believe they are being adequately compensated — despite their health and safety concerns.

It's difficult to say how much an expanded regular season would impact revenues, but one expert says it might not create an automatic windfall.

"I don't think that's the case at all," said Scott Rosner, academic director of the Wharton Sports Business Academy at the University of Pennsylvania.

"You're not expanding your gate receipts (because the number of total games doesn't change). You can argue that, locally, you could see a marginal increase in concessions and in stadium sponsorships being worth more because the preseason games aren't well attended. But the real increases would come from national media. We're talking about television revenues seeing a proportional increase."

Rosner agreed that, in the short term, 18 regular-season games could make financial sense. But he urged caution in the long term: "One of the reasons the NFL is so successful is because they have the perfect formula — 16 games in 17 weeks. You're certainly concerned about diluting the product. You have to wonder whether there's going to be the same demand.

"It's certainly not a risk-free endeavor."

Given the sizable gulf between the sides, this also is an endeavor that's a long way from becoming reality.

NFL players, owners disagree on 18-game season; Will it happen? Should it? 02/10/11 [Last modified: Thursday, February 10, 2011 8:51pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Clearwater enjoys view from the top


    CLEARWATER — The offense still has a familiar feel. Short passes become big gains. Linemen drive their opponents in reverse, forcefully and repeatedly. Runs along the sideline continue to leave defenders breathlessly behind.

    The outcomes are similar, too.

    Clearwater’s Brandon Gary, from left, Jacob Day, Damon Dennis and Jarius Williams celebrate a turnover recovery deep in Countryside High territory during the second quarter of Monday’s game at Countryside. Clearwater won 35-14.
  2. Rick and Tom podcast: Lots of questions for college football teams in Florida


    In just three weeks, the state of college football in Florida went from high expectations to lots of questions at USF with slow starts, Florida with no offense and Florida State losing quarterback Deondre …

    Despite slow starts, quarterback Quinton Flowers and USF take a 3-0 record into tonight's game against Temple. [OCTAVIO JONES | Times]
  3. Young girl injured by 105 mph foul at Yankee Stadium renews call for more netting


    NEW YORK — A young girl at Yankee Stadium was injured by a 105 mph foul ball off the bat of Todd Frazier during Wednesday's game against Minnesota, leading some players to call for protective netting to be extended.

    Baseball fans reacts as a young girl is tended to before she is carried out of the seating area after being hit by a line drive in the fifth inning of a baseball game between the New York Yankees and Minnesota Twins, Wednesday, Sept. 20, 2017, at Yankee Stadium in New York. [Associated Press]
  4. Morning after: Takeaways from Lightning exhibition


    For the Lightning, there was a lot to like in Wednesday's 4-3 exhibition win in Carolina.

    The Lightning's Erik Cernak, left, congratulates Adam Erne (73) following Erne's goal against the Carolina Hurricanes.
  5. Cesar Puello slides home to score off of a bunt single by Peter Bourjos during the second inning.