Make us your home page
Instagram

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

NFL's extra point rule robbed fans of Manning-Brady overtime showdown

Stephen Gostkowski's (3) missed extra point in the first quarter -- his first miss since 2006 -- eventually forced the New England Patriots to attempt their first two-point conversion of the season. The try was unsuccessful, and the Denver Broncos won the AFC championship 20-18. [Getty Images]

Stephen Gostkowski's (3) missed extra point in the first quarter -- his first miss since 2006 -- eventually forced the New England Patriots to attempt their first two-point conversion of the season. The try was unsuccessful, and the Denver Broncos won the AFC championship 20-18. [Getty Images]

The highly anticipated 17th meeting between Peyton Manning and Tom Brady had all the drama football fans could ask for.

And yet they were robbed of more. The AFC championship could have been — and should have been — decided in overtime.

Instead, Sunday's conference title game came down to a two-point conversion attempt with 12 seconds left in the fourth quarter. The Denver Broncos picked off Brady's potentially game-tying pass to seal a 20-18 victory over the New England Patriots and secure a trip to Super Bowl 50.

The Patriots were forced to go for two because kicker Stephen Gostkowski missed an extra point after a first quarter touchdown. Before Sunday, he had made 523 in a row and connected on all 60 tries in the playoffs.

"I just feel terrible," he said after the game. "These guys work a lot, all day, put their bodies and lives on the line. For me to come out here and us lose by a point and me miss the kick, it's a nightmare scenario."

In May, league owners voted 30-2 to approve a rule that moved the line of scrimmage on an extra point from the 2-yard line to the 15-yard line. Their sales pitch: The extra point had become automatic and therefore boring. Longer tries would add more intrigue.

In a cruel twist, the rule change came back to haunt one of its biggest proponents: Patriots coach Bill Belichick.

"I would be in favor of not seeing (the extra point) be an over 99 percent conversion rate," he said in a January 2014 news conference. "It's virtually automatic. That's just not the way the extra point was put into the game. It was an extra point that you actually had to execute and it was executed by players who were not specialists, they were position players. It was a lot harder for them to do."

Belichick got what he wanted. During the 2014 regular season, kickers attempted more than 1,200 extra points and converted 99.3 percent (nine misses). This season, kickers succeeded on 94.1 percent of their tries.

But is this what the NFL intended? The extra point change was supposed to add excitement. On Sunday, it eliminated it.

Sure, the Patriots lost for reasons other than Gostkowski's missed extra point. They couldn't slow the Broncos' pass rush, which hit Brady 20 times, the most any quarterback has been hit in any game this season. They allowed Manning to scramble for 12 yards on third-and-10 in the third quarter. They failed to convert two fourth downs inside the red zone late in the fourth quarter. Brady threw two interceptions (three if you count Bradley Roby's interception on the two-point conversion attempt).

It's also possible that even if Gostkowski hadn't missed the extra point that Belichick might have elected to go for two and the win anyway. Based on data from this season, it would have made sense. A two-point conversion attempt would have been a roughly 50/50 proposition (teams converted 48.4 percent in 2015), whereas the likelihood of converting the extra point (again, 94.1 percent success rate in 2015) and winning in overtime on the road (road teams were 8-13 in overtime in 2015) would have been much lower.

But as brilliant as Belichick is, even he is likely to kick the extra point in that scenario and take his chances in overtime. He has never attempted a go-ahead two-point conversion.

All of this is moot, of course, because of the missed kick. But imagine for a moment that the NFL never tinkered with the extra point. Imagine the courage it would take for a coach to keep his kicker on the sideline in the closing seconds of a 20-19 game with a Super Bowl appearance hanging in the balance.

That would have been entertaining.

At the very least, a game that no one (other than Broncos fans) wanted to see end wouldn't have. Manning. Brady. Possibly the final chapter in one of the sport's greatest rivalries. In overtime. It's a shame we didn't get to see it happen.

Contact Thomas Bassinger at tbassinger@tampabay.com. Follow @tometrics.

NFL's extra point rule robbed fans of Manning-Brady overtime showdown 01/25/16 [Last modified: Monday, January 25, 2016 6:40pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Pitching on no rest backfires for Erasmo Ramirez, Rays

    The Heater

    ARLINGTON, Texas — After battling through a 61/2-hour affair Sunday in Minnesota that was the second-longest game in franchise history, Rays officials were quick to decide that even though Erasmo Ramirez had just worked the 15th and final inning, they would stick with him to start Monday's game in Texas.

    Erasmo Ramirez, starting a day after closing a 15-inning marathon, struggles against the Rangers, comes out after throwing 43 pitches in 21/3 innings.
  2. Marc Topkin's takeaways from Monday's Rays-Rangers game

    The Heater

    The Rays had good reason to have faith in RHP Erasmo Ramirez starting Monday after closing Sunday based on his resiliency, versatility and efficiency. But, for whatever reason, he just didn't pitch well and got knocked out in the third.

  3. Rays journal: Dugout bench becomes bed for Logan Morrison at end of long night

    The Heater

    ARLINGTON, Texas — The Rays found creative ways to get through the physical and mental fatigue of the 6½ hours they spent playing — and ultimately winning — Sunday's game in Minnesota.

    Corey Dickerson drapes towels over an exhausted Logan Morrison in the dugout during the 15th inning of Sunday’s marathon victory.
  4. Rays at Rangers, 8:05 p.m. Tuesday, Arlington, Texas

    The Heater

    Tonight: at Rangers

    8:05, Globe Life Park, Arlington, Texas

    TV/radio: Fox Sports Sun, 620-AM, 680-AM (Spanish)

    SURPRISE, AZ - MARCH 2: Nick Martinez #22 of the Texas Rangers poses for a portrait during photo day at Surprise Stadium on March 2, 2015 in Surprise, Arizona. (Photo by Rob Tringali/Getty Images)
  5. What major sporting event could Tampa Bay land next?

    Lightning Strikes

    We are on quite a roll as a community. First, we had a Super Bowl drop from the storm clouds into our lap. It just reaffirms the fact that Tampa Bay is great at lap. And Monday it became official: Next year's NHL All-Star Game will be held at Amalie Arena. The best in the world will be here to shoot and score. And …

    MVP Wayne Gretzky is congratulated at the 1999 NHL All-Star game, the last time the event was in Tampa Bay. [DIRK SHADD   |   Times file]