Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Tampa Bay Buccaneers roundtable: Grading Dirk Koetter's performance through three quarters of the season

Tampa Bay Buccaneers head coach Dirk Koetter watches the action in the first half against the Carolina Panthers in Charlotte, N.C., Monday, Oct. 10, 2016. [Associated Press]

Tampa Bay Buccaneers head coach Dirk Koetter watches the action in the first half against the Carolina Panthers in Charlotte, N.C., Monday, Oct. 10, 2016. [Associated Press]

In one month, Dirk Koetter has gone from coach on a warm-to-hot seat to Coach of the Year candidate. Four straight victories will do that for a guy. As part of our Bucs Quarterly Report, here's how the Tampa Bay Times' Bucs coverage team grades Koetter's performance:

Rick Stroud, @NFLStroud

The last time the Bucs won five in a row was the Super Bowl season of 2002. So if Tampa Bay beats New Orleans at Raymond James Stadium Sunday, consider what kind of a rare run they are on.

Clock management has improved. The defense identified communication as the issue and fixed it. Finally, going 5-1 on the road is an elite accomplishment but they need to even that at home. The ability to weather injuries to key players has been impressive. If the Bucs win 10 or make the playoffs, he should get coach of the year consideration. Grade: B

Tom Jones, @tomwjones

He has gone from possible hot seat to coach-of-the-year candidate.

What a change we've seen in the past month. At the halfway point of the season, we all graded Koetter's performance and it was full of Cs and even a D. His play-calling was brought into question. And he was coaching a team that seemed headed to yet another losing season.

Much of Tampa Bay's success in the past month can be attributed to Koetter. He has been steady in his play-calling and worked around some major injuries. He also seems to be working extremely well with defensive coordinator, Mike Smith, putting together game plans that have helped Tampa Bay knock off some of the NFL's best teams (See: Chiefs, Seahawks). Grade: B.

Martin Fennelly, @mjfennelly

The man has been coming on like a locomotive. To start the season, it was quite easy to think the man was in over his head, what with game management and leaving Jameis in at the end of that loss in Arizona.

Now look. We once thought Koetter was as focused as a clenched fist. Maybe we still do. But the man has this team playing loose and confident. These young Bucs aren't afraid to make mistakes. They just passed a major hurdle. After pulling off two big upsets, they flew across the country and didn't let down at all. That's preparation. That's coaching. Grade: B

Greg Auman, @gregauman

Most people saw the Bucs as a 7-9 or 8-8 team, taking a step forward but not necessarily making the playoffs. That still could be their final outcome, but for Koetter to push through the injuries the Bucs have faced, and to get them to improbable road win after road win — at Kansas City, especially — is a testament to him believing in his vision and his players.

He's also shown a smart trust in Mike Smith, whose defense was wildly disappointing just a month ago, giving up 1,087 yards in back-to-back losses to the Raiders and Falcons. But the defense clicked, started forcing takeaways at the same time that the offense stopping giving the ball away. This four-game win streak has been incredible for the Bucs, who haven't had a reason to be excited in December in quite some time.

Last year's 6-6 team had a fleeting moment of promise, but lost its last four games so badly it cost the head coach his job. This time, there's a more concrete positive momentum around the team, and if it continues, Koetter will deservedly draw national interest as a Coach of the Year candidate. Oakland's Jack Del Rio, who gave Koetter his first NFL job, is a more likely winner, but it doesn't take away from Koetter's impressive first season as an NFL head coach. Grade: A.

Thomas Bassinger, @tometrics

At the halfway point, I gave Koetter a D because I felt his game and clock management had cost the team opportunities. Winston's play at the time was erratic, and the defense was on pace to allow more points than it did last season.

If I were grading him on the last four games, he'd get an A. After the Thursday night loss to the Falcons, the Bucs could have crumbled, but Koetter — and Jameis Shakespeare Winston — have held the team, the family together. A turnaround seemed unlikely halfway through the season, but Tampa Bay is in the hunt for its first playoff berth since 2007.

Koetter realized Winston needed better pass protection, and he made the requisite adjustments. Grade: B-minus.

Ernest Hooper, @hoop4you

It's an old song Bucs fans have heard far too often. A promising season spirals out of control and the team limps home while the faithful begin looking at Mel Kiper's Big Board.

I found myself falling into the same trap, convinced the Bucs were headed for doom after woeful efforts against the Falcons and Bears. But Koetter found a way to right the ship during the 11-day break and now the team is contending. The Bucs should insist the league continue to play Thursday games. Grade: B

Tampa Bay Buccaneers roundtable: Grading Dirk Koetter's performance through three quarters of the season 12/07/16 [Last modified: Tuesday, December 6, 2016 5:43pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. HomeTeam 25: Volleyball rankings for Tampa Bay

    Volleyball Preps

    1. Plant

    Last season: 28-4

    This week: Thursday vs. Bloomingdale

    Plant High outside hitter Camryn Vogler (1) hits the ball over the net past St. Thomas Aquinas outside hitter Kirsten Klos (10) during the Class 8A state volleyball final between Plant High and St. Thomas Aquinas at West Port High School in Ocala, Fla., on Saturday, Nov. 12, 2016. St. Thomas beat Plant High 3-0.
  2. Bucs Cannon Fodder podcast: Key roster battles


    Greg Auman looks ahead to tonight's third episode of HBO's "Hard Knocks," and talks about key roster battles that could shift with the Bucs' third preseason game Saturday night against the Browns on our …

    Bucs running back Jacquizz Rodgers (32) is hit by middle linebacker Kwon Alexander (58) while running the ball during training camp. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]
  3. Rays series preview: Who are the Blue Jays?


    Last week, the Rays faced the Blue Jays in the Rogers Centre, dropping three of four. This week, they'll play three games at Tropicana Field. Here's the information you need to know about Toronto before the action kicks off.

    Third baseman Josh Donaldson hit four home runs in as many games against the Rays last week.
  4. And the most-searched NFL player in Florida is ...


    The Bucs just faced the Jacksonville Jaguars in preseason, and open their 2017 season at the Miami Dolphins. So with the state's NFL competition ahead of and just behind the Bucs, who do you think is the NFL player most searched on Google by Floridians?

    Fans react with excitement moments after the Bucs announce their first-round pick at the team's 2016 NFL draft party. [LOREN ELLIOTT | Times]
  5. 5 miles and a lot of emotion between Sickles, Alonso


    TAMPA — From one campus to another, the distance between Sickles and Alonso high schools is 5.4 miles.

    New Alonso coach Reggie Crume spent three years at Palm Harbor University, so he knows a little something about neighborhood rivalries. (Douglas R. Clifford, Times)