Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Time is now for Tampa Bay Buccaneers to decide whether Jay Cutler is a franchise QB

TAMPA — If you are Mark Dominik or Raheem Morris, you do not debate the price.

You do not weigh the cost of losing draft picks or the possibility of giving up another player. You do not concern yourself with questions that are superfluous to this conversation.

If you are the men in charge of the direction of the Buccaneers, you ask only one question:

Is Jay Cutler a legitimate franchise quarterback?

And if the answer is yes, then you pay whatever it takes to get him.

Seems simple, except you have to answer that first question correctly. Because, if you don't, then you give up a first-round pick in 1984 for a quarterback (Jack Thompson) who will win three games in Tampa Bay. Or you give up a first-round pick in 1992 for a quarterback (Chris Chandler) who will never win a game as a starter in a Bucs uniform.

Think those are isolated examples of foolish trades?

Then you may not recall that the Rams gave up two first-round picks, a fifth-rounder and two players to get a quarterback (Jim Everett) who went 46-59 the next eight seasons.

And you might have forgotten that the Falcons gave up two No. 1s and a No. 3 for a guy (Jeff George) who lasted about as long as a daffodil. And you may have purged any thoughts of the Giants trading two No. 1s and two No. 2s for a Hall of Famer (Fran Tarkenton) who failed to reach the playoffs in his five seasons in New York.

"Just look through the history of franchise quarterbacks in the NFL. You can probably name most of them off the top of your head," Morris said. "Franchise guys, they don't come along much; they don't come along often."

Which is why the Bucs need to seriously consider mortgaging the future for Cutler.

Because a true franchise quarterback is the one player who can actually turn a team's fortunes. Denver acquired John Elway and rewrote history. Green Bay acquired Brett Favre and recaptured glory.

Franchise quarterbacks are rare, and available franchise quarterbacks are rarer still.

Sometimes you find one with a high draft pick, but you can never be certain whether you are getting Peyton Manning or Ryan Leaf. And every so often you hit the lottery and find one where no one else is looking, but that's usually wishful thinking.

The reality is, at any given time, 25 or more teams are trolling for the next one.

Which brings us back to Cutler.

Most everyone agrees he has the look of a franchise quarterback. He is big, he is tough, he has a wicked arm and a big-time swagger. His stats the past two seasons certainly have the look of a rising star's.

But a franchise quarterback has to be more. He has to be a leader. He has to put the team ahead of his ego. He has to care far more about impacting the standings than tasting the nightlife, and he has to show the maturity and responsibility of a man willing to carry a heavy burden.

In Cutler's case, these issues are in doubt. Maybe unfairly, maybe not. But it is up to Morris and Dominik to figure out whether the whispers around Cutler are misperceptions or warning signs.

And if they decide he is the real deal, they need to go after him with single-minded purpose. If that means trading their Nos. 1 and 3 picks in this draft, then do it. If that means the No. 1 pick and any one of about 40 guys on the roster, then do it. If that means a No. 1 pick this year, and another No. 1 in 2010, then swallow hard and do it.

Because here's the thing:

You can find other players elsewhere. The Bucs need a star on the defensive line, but a few of those guys come available every year in free agency. The Bucs could use more talent at linebacker, but that's not a difficult position to fill. If the Glazers are as committed as they say — and that's a mighty big "if" — the Bucs have space under the salary cap to get practically any player they need for next season.

But the one player you almost never find on the free agent market is a franchise quarterback.

So we have given them February to learn the ropes. And we have given them March to feel comfortable. Now all we ask of the new general manager and the new head coach is that they decide the future of this team in the next few weeks.

One way or another, we will look back to this month as a pivotal time in Buccaneers history. And it can play out any number of ways. Is Cutler a star or a chump? Did he come here or did he go elsewhere? Did Dominik and Morris read the situation correctly, or did they horribly misjudge Cutler's potential?

The clock is ticking, and their legacies are waiting to be written.

John Romano can be reached at

Time is now for Tampa Bay Buccaneers to decide whether Jay Cutler is a franchise QB 04/01/09 [Last modified: Thursday, April 2, 2009 6:34am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'Hard Knocks' effect: Jameis Winston jersey sales surging


    Two weeks into the national publicity of HBO's "Hard Knocks," Bucs quarterback Jameis Winston's No. 3 jerseys are selling well, as he made the biggest leap in this week's jersey report from Dick's Sporting Goods.

    Bucs quarterback Jameis Winston's No. 3 jerseys are selling well. [Getty Images]
  2. Tampa Bay Tech offense gains dimension with addition of RB Treshaun Ward


    TAMPA — The playbook was pretty simple at Tampa Bay Tech. Snap the ball to quarterback Michael Penix and let him throw all over the field.

    Jaquavious Johnson, left, and Treshaun Ward pose for a portrait during practice at Tampa Bay Tech High School in Tampa on Monday, August 21, 2017.
  3. HomeTeam 25: Volleyball rankings for Tampa Bay

    Volleyball Preps

    1. Plant

    Last season: 28-4

    This week: Thursday vs. Bloomingdale

    Plant High outside hitter Camryn Vogler (1) hits the ball over the net past St. Thomas Aquinas outside hitter Kirsten Klos (10) during the Class 8A state volleyball final between Plant High and St. Thomas Aquinas at West Port High School in Ocala, Fla., on Saturday, Nov. 12, 2016. St. Thomas beat Plant High 3-0.
  4. Bucs Cannon Fodder podcast: Key roster battles


    Greg Auman looks ahead to tonight's third episode of HBO's "Hard Knocks," and talks about key roster battles that could shift with the Bucs' third preseason game Saturday night against the Browns on our …

    Bucs running back Jacquizz Rodgers (32) is hit by middle linebacker Kwon Alexander (58) while running the ball during training camp. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]
  5. Rays series preview: Who are the Blue Jays?


    Last week, the Rays faced the Blue Jays in the Rogers Centre, dropping three of four. This week, they'll play three games at Tropicana Field. Here's the information you need to know about Toronto before the action kicks off.

    Third baseman Josh Donaldson hit four home runs in as many games against the Rays last week.