Monday, October 22, 2018
FSU Seminoles

After Jalen Ramsey-Jimbo Fisher debate, who deserves credit for a player’s success?

As you might have seen, Texas A&M touted Jimbo Fisher's defensive backs development on Twitter earlier this week. One of those defensive backs, Jaguars star Jalen Ramsey, did not like it.

While the Twitterverse exploded over the apparent shot Ramsey took at his former coach, here's a more interesting debate.

Who gets credit for developing a player?

The first answer is obvious: The player. He's the one who puts in the work in the weight room, film room and on the field.

But beyond that?

No, Fisher probably didn't teach a lot of techniques to Ramsey. But he did identify him as a top talent (OK, that wasn't hard; Ramsey was a five-star recruit) and get him to sign at FSU. Fisher also chose the coaches who helped develop him. That counts, right?

To be clear, this isn't a Fisher-only story. Coaches all over the country promote their former players who do great things.

Last night in Tampa, new Gators coach Dan Mullen name-dropped Percy Harvin and Tim Tebow, whom he worked with as Florida's offensive coordinator. He deserves credit for developing them as the coordinator, right?

Mullen also mentioned a few players from the Super Bowl-champion Eagles. Defensive lineman Fletcher Cox committed to Mississippi State before Mullen arrived there, but Mullen was his college head coach. I'm not sure how many defensive line drills Mullen led, but he hired the coach who led them and put Cox in position to succeed. Does that count?

Mullen gave a shout out to kicker Caleb Sturgis, whom he recruited to UF. But Mullen wasn't Sturgis' special-teams coordinator, and I'm not sure how many kicking pointers Mullen was giving him. Does that count?

I think there are varying degrees of credit, and Mullen/Fisher can rightfully claim all of the examples above. To me, position coaches, coordinators and head coaches all play a role in players' development, so they should all be able to promote them while trying to land the next Jalen Ramsey or Fletcher Cox.

What do you think? Who (besides the player himself) should get credit for a player's development and future success?

Comments
Florida State climbing under Willie Taggart, but ĎNoles still have a long way to go

Florida State climbing under Willie Taggart, but ĎNoles still have a long way to go

TALLAHASSEE — Florida State's 38-17 comeback win over Wake Forest on Saturday was a nice way to start the second half of coach Willie Taggart's inaugural season.It was certainly better than how the first half went — with a 21-point home d...
Published: 10/20/18
FSU journal: Tackle for loss becomes moment to reflect

FSU journal: Tackle for loss becomes moment to reflect

TALLAHASSEE — Less than two weeks after Hurricane Michael destroyed his Panama City home, Florida State LB Janarius Robinson was just happy to be back on the field and able to contribute.He did more than that Saturday.Robinson recorded a career...
Published: 10/20/18
Matt Bakerís takeaways from Florida State-Wake Forest

Matt Bakerís takeaways from Florida State-Wake Forest

The best moment of the game was when LB Janarius Robinson corralled Wake Forest's Jamie Newman for a 6-yard loss, then took a knee after the play. It was his first big play since Hurricane Matthew destroyed his family's Panama City home.RELATED: ...
Published: 10/20/18
UConn is just awful, a positive at FSU and more state college football nuggets

UConn is just awful, a positive at FSU and more state college football nuggets

FSU bright spotAs rough as Florida State's 3-3 start has been, its run defense has been one of the best in the nation. The Seminoles are seventh nationally in yards per rush allowed (2.76) and held Northern Illinois to only six yards — the best...
Published: 10/19/18
College football Week 8 viewing guide

College football Week 8 viewing guide

Lamest time window: Late. The marquee games are spread out well, but the primetime spot will have the fewest national implications.Noon: Can Jim Harbaugh start reversing his 1-5 record against rivals when No. 6 Michigan travels to No. 24 Michigan Sta...
Published: 10/19/18
Florida State football midseason review: Seminolesí bowl streak in jeopardy

Florida State football midseason review: Seminolesí bowl streak in jeopardy

Few teams in the country have been as disappointing as Florida State.The Seminoles started the year in the top 20, with a loaded running backs corps and a new coach (Willie Taggart) known for offensive fireworks.Midway through the Year 1 of the Tagga...
Published: 10/16/18
How Florida State responds after Hurricane Michael will decide its season

How Florida State responds after Hurricane Michael will decide its season

For the second year in a row, Florida State is having to deal with the football fallout from a devastating hurricane.The Seminoles' failure to respond properly from Hurricane Irma helped lead to their lost 2017 season. How they handle the aftermath o...
Published: 10/15/18
Florida State offers Deion Sandersí son, 2019 recruit Shilo

Florida State offers Deion Sandersí son, 2019 recruit Shilo

Florida State is making some progress on the recruiting trail during its open date, including an offer to a notable legacy prospect.Shilo Sanders — the son of FSU and NFL legend Deion Sanders — announced Wednesday that the Semin...
Published: 10/10/18
How 2018 Alabama football compares to Florida Stateís 2013 title team

How 2018 Alabama football compares to Florida Stateís 2013 title team

As college football writers continue to search for new ways to describe No. 1 Alabama's dominance, a tweet from Warchant's Ira Schoffel caught my attention:2013 FSU was the best team I’ve ever covered and maybe the best I’ve ever seen. Th...
Published: 10/09/18
Matt Bakerís takeaways from Miami-FSU

Matt Bakerís takeaways from Miami-FSU

Finally healthy, LB DeCalon Brooks is starting to have a big impact for Florida State. The Gaither High alumnus earned ACC linebacker of the week honors last week with two tackles for a loss, and he forced a fumble and added a key fumble recovery Sat...
Updated one month ago