Tuesday, September 25, 2018
Tampa Bay Lightning

Does the Lightning's retirement of Marty St. Louis' number mean all is forgiven?

TAMPA — The Lightning's announcement that it will retire Marty St. Louis' No. 26 during a ceremony during a Jan. 13 game against Columbus stirred emotions among fans who resented how St. Louis left Tampa Bay.

The Times' Lightning coverage team of columnist Tom Jones, beat writer Joe Smith and columnist Martin Fennelly weigh in:

Does the retirement of Marty St. Louis' number mean all is forgiven? Should it?

Tom Jones: I've said from Day 1 that fans needed to get over feeling betrayed by St. Louis. No one could ever question St. Louis' dedication every single time he took the ice.

While full and exact details for St. Louis' trade request remain somewhat murky, I do believe St. Louis gave it his all while with Tampa Bay and I do believe his being initially left off the Canadian Olympic by Steve Yzerman was a valid reason to feel hurt.

The trade, which brought Tampa Bay Ryan Callahan and a first-round pick, turned out to be a good deal for the Lightning, so I'm not sure why fans felt sabotaged.

Ultimately, St. Louis has expressed his love for Tampa Bay and the Lightning organization. If you haven't forgiven him by now then you're holding on to unnecessary bitterness. Time to move on and embrace the greatest player in franchise history.

RELATED: Lightning to retire Marty St. Louis' No. 26

Joe Smith: From an organizational standpoint, yes, it seems all is forgiven. You can sense that from the fact owner Jeff Vinik and, he said, GM Steve Yzerman, were in full support of this move. Some fans may never get over the messy ending. Even St. Louis understands that.

But, as in most things in life, time heals. And St. Louis' jersey retirement, its resulting celebration, should be one way for the relationship between him and the fans to continue to mend. Eventually, St. Louis will be forgiven, and remembered for how much he brought the franchise, including the 2004 Stanley Cup.

Fennelly: As much as can be forgiven is forgiven —- and should be. I'm not saying lightning GM Steve Yzerman will be dabbing at his tears that night — but this is what respectful, professional organizations do. You rise above. You realize what matters.

History.

Did Marty in effect quit in mid-captaincy? Did he do it partly because of Olympic snubs ? ( By the way, he won gold in Sochi after being added to team Canada). I never totally got his decision.

He also was the mighty mite who led the Lightning to a Stanley Cup — period.

You respect the history.

RELATED: What they're saying about the Lightning's decision to retire Marty St. Louis' number.

Why didn't the Lightning retire Vinny Lecavalier's No. 4 first?

Smith: Lecavalier may have arrived first, the Lightning's No. 1 pick in 1998. And he's certainly one of the pillars, former faces, of the franchise. But St. Louis was arguably Tampa Bay's best player ever, it's all-time leading scorer, a borderline Hall of Famer.

St. Louis was also the first to retire, after the 2014-15 season. Lecavalier just retired after last season. Lecavalier will have his night, and No. 4 jersey retired, at some point. It was just St. Louis' turn.

PHOTO GALLERY: Marty St. Louis calls it a career after 16 seasons

Fennelly: I'd retire Vinny this year, too.

But if you were to carve you a Mount Rushmore for Tampa Sports history, Marty belongs on it — more than any Lightning player. Fans can be ambivalent to a point. But history is history. And Marty and his Hall of Fame motor made The lightning matter.

Marty goes first. I am down with that

Jones: No one could have argued that Vinny's No. 4 should have been retired first and it eventually will be retired. Lecavalier was the first real face of the Lightning franchise and remains, most likely, the most popular player among Lightning fans. It appears that the Lightning is retiring Marty's number first because he retired a year before Lecavalier.

Honestly, St. Louis was an overall better player and deserved to have his number retired first. But, you watch, Lecavalier will deservedly have his No. 4 retired next season.

Comments
Lightning journal: Vinik pushing for outdoor game

Lightning journal: Vinik pushing for outdoor game

As he sat back in his chair facing the stands in the middle of the two benches, Lightning owner Jeff Vinik could not help but remember the first time he sat there.A young Steven Stamkos sat next to him as he spoke in front of a crowd of about 30 peop...
Published: 09/24/18
Lightning journal: Roster trimmed to 28

Lightning journal: Roster trimmed to 28

TAMPA – After Sunday morning, the Lightning sat five cuts away from having a 23-man roster to start the regular season.It cut its training camp roster by 27, leaving 28 players on the roster with the start of the regular season less than two we...
Published: 09/23/18
Lightning forward prospect Boris Katchouk putting together strong preseason

Lightning forward prospect Boris Katchouk putting together strong preseason

TAMPA — As the end of training camp looms, there's no clear-cut answer as to how the Lightning will fill the one, maybe two open forward spots in its lineup.It could go with Adam Erne. Spending much of his time in AHL Syracuse the past three se...
Published: 09/22/18
Lightning journal: ‘No-risk’ forward pickup; another preseason win; Fan Fest on Sunday

Lightning journal: ‘No-risk’ forward pickup; another preseason win; Fan Fest on Sunday

TAMPA — It didn't take long for Lightning GM Julien BriseBois to decide he wanted to put a waiver claim in Friday.Not when he saw that F Danick Martel was available."He's a player we have had on our radar for a while, going back to actually his...
Published: 09/22/18
Lightning journal: Adam Erne looks to stick in Tampa

Lightning journal: Adam Erne looks to stick in Tampa

Forward Adam Erne flicks the puck into the net, but he has no time to celebrate.He flips around. Crunch, crunch, crunch. Snow flies off his skates. Erne then squares his body as he arrives in the defensive zone, steps away from the net.Within a secon...
Published: 09/21/18
Lightning falls to Hurricanes again in preseason

Lightning falls to Hurricanes again in preseason

The Lightning did not fare much better in its second preseason crack at the Hurricanes.In fact, it did worse.It lost 6-1 Wednesday in Raleigh, N.C.Carolina put a much more veteran team on the ice than it did Tuesday in winning Tampa Bay's preseason o...
Published: 09/19/18
Second-round pick Gabriel Fortier among Lightning’s early cuts

Second-round pick Gabriel Fortier among Lightning’s early cuts

One round of cuts down, several more to go.The Lightning cut seven players on Wednesday, five of whom were training camp invitees, the team announced. All seven players were assigned to juniors.Gabriel Fortier was the most notable cut. The Lightning'...
Published: 09/19/18
Lightning journal: Can Mathieu Joseph sneak his way onto the opening-day roster?

Lightning journal: Can Mathieu Joseph sneak his way onto the opening-day roster?

It remains to be seen if F Mathieu Joseph will make the Lightning's roster. If he doesn't, it certainly won't be because of a lack of opportunities.Joseph saw time on the Lightning power play and penalty kill on Tuesday at Amalie Arena when Tampa Bay...
Published: 09/19/18
Hockey News poll: Lightning favored to win Stanley Cup, other awards

Hockey News poll: Lightning favored to win Stanley Cup, other awards

Falling just short of winning a championship the past few seasons has done nothing to erode fans' confidence in the Lightning.Not just locally, but also nationally and across Canada.The Lightning is the runaway favorite to win the Stanley C...
Published: 09/19/18
Lightning journal: Alex Killorn’s just puttin’ on the Fitz

Lightning journal: Alex Killorn’s just puttin’ on the Fitz

TAMPA — How big is FitzMagic? It has hit the Lightning, too.Proving that Harvard guys stick together, Lightning forward Alex Killorn showed support for fellow Harvard grad Ryan Fitzpatrick by, sort of, dressing up the way Fitzpatrick did after ...
Published: 09/19/18