Saturday, June 23, 2018
Tampa Bay Lightning

Here's how NHL determines which hits earn suspensions

NEW YORK

Jonathan Drouin was knocked to the ice on a hit to the head by the Islanders' Calvin de Haan on Nov. 1.

Within seconds, Lightning fans rendered their verdict on Twitter.

"De Haan should be suspended."

"Dirty hit!"

"@NHLPlayerSafety better be on this."

The league's Department of Player Safety was. By the time de Haan had served his five-minute major penalty for interference, the hit had already been flagged, clipped and emailed to 13 people in the department. They decided the hit was unavoidable, so de Haan wouldn't face supplemental discipline.

The controversial check sidelined Drouin for seven games, the wing returning Thursday against the Sabres.

"We discussed that play in depth," says Patrick Burke, director of player safety.

Burke reflected on the hit last Sunday as he sat in the back row of the department's "war room" on the 12th floor of the league office. On any given night, up to nine full-time employees are watching every play of every game on 16 flat-screen, high-definition televisions. Ten additional workstations provide the home and away teams' television feeds.

Roughly 650 hits are flagged each season for further review. An average of 30 result in suspensions. That's just under 5 percent. The department has its share of critics, but it prides itself on being thorough and transparent. It realizes that with 30 fan bases, it will always be unpopular, depending on what player is on the receiving end of a controversial hit.

"Every fan is genuinely convinced we hate their team," Burke said.

Every flagged play is scrutinized in slow motion, from every available angle, the razor-thin line separating legal from illegal always kept in mind.

"We know the difference between a suspension and not a suspension can be 6 inches in a game where guys are going full speed," said Burke, a former Flyers scout. "We do a really good job in taking away (from the game) the really, really vicious, violent, vigilante plays. Most of our suspensions now are guys who missed slightly or just a hit that went a little bit sideways, for some reason."

•••

This hi-tech hit courtroom has been around for only about five years in its current form.

A decade or two ago, teams had to send VHS tapes of questionable hits to the league office via snail mail. Burke knows that well. His father — Brian Burke, now the Flames' president for hockey operations — was in charge of such reviews in the mid 1990s while an NHL executive vice president. Patrick would often sign for the packages when they were sent along to the Burke home.

"I'd be the first to watch them," Patrick quipped.

He remembers once when he was 11, his father called around bedtime. He told his dad, "I think something happened in the Islanders game."

"Okay, Patty, I'll take a look," his father said.

Sure enough, a suspension resulted from the game. Patrick said that then-Islanders general manager Mike Milbury told Brian, "After everything that went down, our guys are getting suspended because your kid is watching games?"

Said Patrick: "It's a little better system now than when an 11-year-old is watching games. But I nailed it."

•••

Damian Echevarrieta is the historian of the Department of Player Safety.

Hired by the NHL in 1999, Echevarrieta helped set up a makeshift war room with a satellite dish, several TVs and games recorded on VHS tapes. The current, much more advanced setup started in 2011, when the department was made its own entity. A separate office in Toronto handles goal reviews and coaches challenges.

On a recent Sunday, the war room was pretty quiet. Only a handful of games were being played. Coordinators such as Chris Nastro sat at a workstation, documenting every questionable hit from a Chicago-Montreal game: interference, hit to the head, high-stick. He noted a scrum earlier in the game in case a retaliatory illegal hit resulted later. In general, three to four hits a night might be flagged for review.

On Nov. 1, one of them was de Haan's on Drouin.

The clip was sent to Stephane Quintal, senior vice president of player safety, who decided it was worth discussion, asking everyone on the 13-person email chain for their take. Each emailed clip has certain information: if a penalty was called on the play, whether a player was injured, when the offending player's next game is and if he has discipline history.

Not factors in determining if a hit is illegal are a player's discipline history and whether an injury resulted, Burke said. But those things are factors in determining a suspension's length.

If the consensus is a hit is suspension-worthy, with Quintal having the final call, a phone hearing is held, typically the following day. On the line are department senior staff members, the offending player, his agent, the general manager of the player's team and a representative from the players union, among others.

If a suspension is issued, the department puts a video online, on Twitter @NHLPlayerSafety and nhl.com.playersafety, to explain why.

On the de Haan-Drouin hit, it was quickly determined supplemental discipline wasn't merited, through application of Rule No. 48 on illegal hits to the head. Was the head the main point of contact? Was it a hit on a vulnerable player? The answer to both questions was yes. But Drouin admittedly put himself in a vulnerable spot by putting his head down while reaching for the puck along the wall. To Burke and the staff, it was unanimous: de Haan, trying to hit through the body, couldn't avoid hitting Drouin's head.

Burke said the department might end up using that clip in an educational video.

"That one was a really bad end result for a really talented hockey player that nobody likes to see," he said.

Even the ones reviewing it.

Comments
Lightning re-signs backup goalie Louis Domingue to 2-year deal

Lightning re-signs backup goalie Louis Domingue to 2-year deal

The Lightning has re-signed one of its restricted free agents in backup goalie Louis Domingue, who will be back with Tampa Bay on a two-year deal worth $2.3 million.Domingue, 26, was acquired from Arizona in November after he had posted a 4.33 goals-...
Published: 06/22/18
Lightning names ex-player Jeff Halpern as new assistant coach

Lightning names ex-player Jeff Halpern as new assistant coach

The Lightning has filled one of the openings on Jon Cooper's coaching staff, announcing Friday  that former Tampa Bay forward Jeff Halpern has been hired as an assistant coach.Halpern, 42, has spent the past two seasons as an assistant with the ...
Published: 06/22/18
Steve Yzerman: Lightning won’t re-sign forward Chris Kunitz

Steve Yzerman: Lightning won’t re-sign forward Chris Kunitz

As expected, Lightning general manager Steve Yzerman said he does not intend to re-sign veteran forward Chris Kunitz, who will seek his fifth Stanley Cup with a different team next season.Kunitz, 38, brought much-needed playoff experience in his lone...
Published: 06/22/18
Live blog: 2018 NHL entry draft

Live blog: 2018 NHL entry draft

The Lightning isn't scheduled to pick until the second round, but there's no telling how active they might be with trades, so you'll want to follow our live coverage throughout the NHL draft Friday (Round 1) and Saturday (Rounds 2-7) in Dallas.(funct...
Updated: 12 hours ago
2018-19 schedule unveiled: Lightning opens with five straight at home

2018-19 schedule unveiled: Lightning opens with five straight at home

NHL schedules all balance out at the end, but the Lightning will open 2018-19 with five straight home games and end the season with its last four on the road.The Lightning released its schedule Thursday evening for the upcoming season, with all sorts...
Published: 06/21/18
Updated: 06/22/18
Without a first-rounder, Lightning still could have busy draft weekend

Without a first-rounder, Lightning still could have busy draft weekend

The Lightning doesn't have a first-round pick in this weekend's draft, but that's not to say the weekend couldn't be busy for general manager Steve Yzerman and his front office.The Lightning sent its top draft pick to the Rangers in February as part ...
Published: 06/21/18
Islanders hire Barry Trotz as coach fresh off winning Stanley Cup

Islanders hire Barry Trotz as coach fresh off winning Stanley Cup

DALLAS — The New York Islanders have hired Barry Trotz as their new head coach. President of hockey operations Lou Lamoriello announced the move Thursday at the NHL draft, two weeks after Trotz won the Stanley Cup with the Washington Capitals and thr...
Published: 06/21/18
Lightning’s Victor Hedman salutes survivors in Norris Trophy acceptance speech

Lightning’s Victor Hedman salutes survivors in Norris Trophy acceptance speech

The victims and survivors of three tragedies — the mass shootings in Las Vegas and at Parkland Stoneman Douglas High School, and the bus accident that killed 16 members of the Humboldt Broncos junior hockey team — were a big part of Wedne...
Published: 06/21/18
Lightning’s Victor Hedman wins NHL’s Norris Trophy

Lightning’s Victor Hedman wins NHL’s Norris Trophy

Victor Hedman, a relentless part of the Lightning's push to the Eastern Conference final last season, was honored Wednesday night with the Norris Trophy, given to the NHL's top defenseman."To the Lightning organization, Mr. Jeff Vinik, Steve Yzerman ...
Published: 06/20/18
Lightning announce home opener: Oct. 6 vs. Panthers

Lightning announce home opener: Oct. 6 vs. Panthers

The Tampa Bay Lightning will announce their full 2018-19 schedule on Thursday, but the league announced each home opener Wednesday, with Tampa Bay playing host to the Florida Panthers at Amalie Arena on Saturday, Oct. 6.The Lightning will know their ...
Published: 06/20/18