Wednesday, February 21, 2018
Tampa Bay Lightning

Jones: It's time for the Lightning to trade Ben Bishop

He is the Lightning's most valuable player.

He is the reason the Lightning has made the playoffs the past three seasons. He is the reason it nearly won the Stanley Cup a year ago. He is the reason it came close to that again this season.

If you were listing all the reasons the Lightning could win the Stanley Cup next season, his name would be at the top.

He is goalie Ben Bishop. No player means more to this franchise.

And the Lightning should trade him. Right now.

Sounds crazy, right? Franchises might go decades without getting a goalie this good. For most of its history, the Lightning desperately needed and constantly searched for a goalie this good. Finally it has one — one of the best goalies on the planet — so why in the world would it get rid of him?

Because it would be crazy not to.

Now before we go any further, let's get something straight. In a perfect world, Bishop would be the Lightning's No. 1 goalie for years to come. He's not only an outstanding goalie but a heck of a good guy. He's well-liked, particularly by those inside the organization. He's a good teammate and a good representative of the franchise.

It's easy to run off a player who is a lousy teammate, a rotten person and a goalie who can't stop a medicine ball. It's quite another to suggest that the Lightning gets rid of a player who is as solid off the ice as he is on it.

If I'm Lightning general manager Steve Yzerman, it would break my heart to trade Bishop.

But emotions can't be involved in making business decisions, and trading Bishop simply is good business.

Bishop gets hurt too much, he's due too much money, the Lightning has a hot prospect who is ready to be a No. 1 goalie. And chances are, the Lightning is going to lose a goalie in the next year or two anyway.

So let's make a deal.

Start with the injury factor. As reliable as Bishop has been getting Tampa Bay to the playoffs, he has been just as unreliable when the Lightning gets there. The best ability is availability, and Bishop has been unavailable at crucial stages of the postseason each of the past three seasons.

The Lightning was swept in the opening round by Montreal in 2014 as Bishop sat with a wrist injury. In 2015, Bishop missed one full Stanley Cup final game and a portion of another, and was less than 100 percent for a couple more because of a groin injury. This postseason, Bishop missed all but 13 minutes of a seven-game loss to the Penguins in the Eastern Conference final because of a leg injury.

In each case, Bishop was legitimately hurt, and you can't blame a player for getting hurt. No one should suggest that he is soft. If he could have played, he would have. But bottom line is he couldn't play. The biggest games of the year and Bishop was in street clothes.

Eventually, the Lightning has to decide whether it wants to count on a goalie who, history suggests, will miss time at the worst possible time.

Next is Bishop's contract. For starters, he does have a partial no-move clause, meaning he could be traded only to certain teams. But it's the rest of the contract that is important. Bishop has one more year left on his deal and can be an unrestricted free agent next summer. He is in line for big raise, from $5.9 million to maybe more than $8 million a year. That's too much to pay for a team trying to figure out how to pay a slew of other stars.

Also consider that Bishop turns 30 next season. To keep him, you might have to sign him to a long-term deal that would pay him millions well into his 30s and maybe past his prime.

Meantime, the Lightning has a promising goalie in Andrei Vasilevskiy, who will be much more salary-cap friendly than Bishop over the next few years.

See, this is the key. The Lightning already has his replacement.

Vasilevskiy, by all accounts, is on his way to becoming an elite goaltender, maybe even better than Bishop, maybe better than any goalie in the league. He turns just 22 next month and already has shown he can handle big-time NHL pressure. He won a Stanley Cup final game in 2015 and nearly knocked off the eventual Stanley Cup champion Penguins in this season's conference final.

Is he better than Bishop right now? Not quite. Has he proven he can be a No. 1 goalie for more than a playoff series? Well, not yet. Has he proven he can be a No. 1 goalie for a whole season? No, he hasn't.

But eventually the Lightning needs to make a call on moving forward with either Bishop or Vasilevskiy, and that time is now.

The longer you wait to trade Bishop, the more his value goes down because he moves closer to free agency. It's best to trade him now when his stock is at its highest. And Vasilevskiy has shown enough that it's time to take a leap of faith. He's too good to keep as a backup any longer.

Finally, there's the news that broke this week. The NHL is expected to place an expansion team in Las Vegas, perhaps as soon as 2017. The way expansion-draft rules are likely to be set up, teams would be able to protect only one goalie. That means there would be a good chance an expansion team goes after one of the Lightning's goalies. Why lose one for nothing when you can trade one for something?

For all these reasons, it makes sense to move a goalie.

And the goalie who makes the most sense to move is Bishop.

Comments
Could Detroit’s Mike Green be next domino to fall at deadline?

Could Detroit’s Mike Green be next domino to fall at deadline?

The Red Wings have started wheeling and dealing, shipping goalie Petr Mrazek to the Flyers for a package of conditional draft picks.That has shifted focus to a potential Lightning target, Red Wings defenseman Mike Green, who is expected to be moved b...
Published: 02/20/18
Trade rumors can weigh on NHL players as deadline approaches

Trade rumors can weigh on NHL players as deadline approaches

WASHINGTON — Tyler Johnson was as good as gone.Or so it seemed.The scuttlebutt around last year's trade deadline was that the Lightning center could be the piece headed elsewhere to land a top-four defenseman. Maybe Nashville? St. Louis?Then th...
Published: 02/19/18
Better ‘D’ starts at home with Lightning

Better ‘D’ starts at home with Lightning

TAMPA – The Lightning still might land that top tier defenseman it certainly needs by the Feb. 26 trade deadline. But if that player was wearing a Tampa Bay sweater Saturday, would the outcome against the Devils have been any different?The Ligh...
Published: 02/19/18
Rumor mill: What Lightning might do at trade deadline

Rumor mill: What Lightning might do at trade deadline

Reports and rumors involving the Lightning leading up to the NHL trade deadline on Feb. 26:Feb. 17A smaller move could pay big dividendsIf you look at the history of recent Stanley Cup champions, their pivotal moves were subtle, not splashy, the Time...
Published: 02/19/18
Devils’ Wood gets 2 games for boarding Namestnikov

Devils’ Wood gets 2 games for boarding Namestnikov

Devils forward Miles Wood was suspended two games without pay for his boarding penalty Saturday night against Lightning forward Vladislav Namestnikov during the second period of the Devils 4-3 victory.The hit knocked Namestnikov into the boards ...
Published: 02/18/18
Updated: 02/19/18
Flashy trades not always the smartest moves

Flashy trades not always the smartest moves

TAMPA — When it comes to the trade deadline, everyone wants the big names. They dream of blockbusters.Lightning fans would love Senators defenseman Erik Karlsson or Rangers defenseman Ryan McDonagh. Maybe even Rangers wing Rick Nash.But if you ...
Published: 02/17/18
Updated: 02/18/18
Dotchin working on ‘inconsistencies’

Dotchin working on ‘inconsistencies’

TAMPA — Lightning D Jake Dotchin was scratched Saturday against the Devils, making it the fifth time in six games that he did not play."Obviously the playing time is down a bit," Dotchin said after the morning skate. "I just got to keep working...
Published: 02/17/18
Updated: 02/18/18
Winter Olympics: Americans had brawn. Russians had more goals.

Winter Olympics: Americans had brawn. Russians had more goals.

GANGNEUNG, South Korea — It was a game for Cold War nostalgia and present-day geopolitical angst, for feisty, post-whistle scraps in the corners and for cheap jokes on Twitter. It was a game drenched in history at the start and simmering with ill fee...
Published: 02/17/18
Updated: 02/18/18
Emphasis on ‘D’ continues as Lightning face Devils

Emphasis on ‘D’ continues as Lightning face Devils

The emphasis was on defense during Friday's practice and today's morning skate as the Lightning look to reduce not only the number of shots on goal allowed but also scoring chances. It allowed 39 in Thursday's win against the Red Wings and 33 in Thu...
Published: 02/17/18
Lightning falls to Devils

Lightning falls to Devils

TAMPA — The Lightning took enough shots to win Saturday’s game against the Devils. It scored enough goals to win, too. Problem was, the Lightning made enough mistakes to lose."There were a lot of positives," captain Steven Stamkos said, "but they sco...
Published: 02/17/18
Updated: 02/18/18