Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Pride, hurt feelings driving NHL lockout

Hubris and hurt feelings. That is pretty much what the NHL lockout has come down to.

Related News/Archive

The owners, taking a page from the 2004-05 lockout, are confident if they play hardball long enough, the players will cave. The players, still seething about the 24 percent pay cut they swallowed after the last lockout, recoil at the thought of another 12 percent cut.

Commissioner Gary Bettman, the unyielding face of the league's squash-'em-like-a-bug effort, has the support of at least the most militant owners.

Union head Donald Fehr has sold his members on solidarity, reminding them fractures among players during the last lockout sapped their strength to resist.

It seems a lot to overcome. Really, though, the sides are not that far apart, and that is what makes this so maddening.

Both agree the split of league revenue is going to be 50-50. The owners want it immediately. The players, who took 57 percent of revenue last season, want the decrease to be gradual. Players also want contracts honored. That's reasonable, given that owners were sufficiently flush in the two days before the lockout began to sign players to contracts worth about $200 million.

For the most part, that's it. Canada's Globe and Mail reported the difference in the opposing positions in a five-year collective bargaining agreement might be as little as $300 million — relative chump change.

Even President Barack Obama, on television with NBC's Jay Leno, chided the very wealthy owners and very well-paid players for being unable to carve up a record $3.3 billion in revenue during a time of national economic stress.

Yet, we have this: games canceled through Nov. 30 — that's 600 to 800 part-time workers at the Tampa Bay Times Forum out of game-day jobs — no negotiations since Oct. 18, none planned and both sides blaming the other in the media.


It's difficult to have sympathy for the owners. Their initial offer of a 43 to 46 percent revenue share for players was unnecessarily hostile. Their unwillingness to meet with the players association last week was unnecessarily petulant. And they failed to tell the union leadership they recently provided a 48-hour window during which owners and general managers could speak to players. That simply amped up the players' already substantial distrust of their employers.

It is the players, too, who are proposing plans that would cost themselves hundreds of millions of dollars over the life of an agreement. And you can't help but wonder if this whole thing could have been avoided had owners been more charitable with revenue sharing to help financially troubled franchises.

That said, the union didn't help matters by waiting until Aug. 14, one month before the old agreement expired, to make its initial proposal. And perhaps the recently received escrow checks of about 8 percent of last season's salaries have provided it just enough cushion to call the bluff of owners who hoped a lack of paychecks would cause players to submit.

Either way, watching billionaires and millionaires fight over how to split a gigantic pot of money has been unseemly. And what likely will be either a shortened season or no season at all is a permanent stain for the league.

Pride, hurt feelings driving NHL lockout 10/27/12 [Last modified: Saturday, October 27, 2012 7:36pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. With trade freeze over, Lightning could be active


    With the dust settling on the expansion draft saga, the Lightning can now focus on addressing some of its needs.

  2. NBA draft: Jonathan Isaac could make FSU history tonight


    Florida State forward Jonathan Isaac will probably hear his name called early in tonight's NBA draft.

  3. USF walk-on tight end Palmore faces charge of credit card fraud


    A University of South Florida football player faces charges of fraudulent use of a credit card and petit theft following his arrest by Temple Terrace police on Monday.

    USF senior tight end Adrian Palmore faces charges of fraudulent use of a credit card and petit theft after his arrest by Temple Terrace police on June 19, 2017. [Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office]
  4. Rowdies defender gets the call to represent Jamaica


    ST. PETERSBURG —- Damion Lowe has loved his first season with the Rowdies but has some other soccer-related business that might pull him away for a bit.

    Family business, too.

    Tampa Bay Rowdies defender Damion Lowe collides with Louisville City FC forward Luke Spencer earlier this year.
  5. Sarasota's Scooter Gennett: Utility man turned historic slugger

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — On June 10, 2009, the Brewers selected a Sarasota High School shortstop in the 16th round of the MLB draft. He'd assembled an impressive resume in prep ball, but as one of more than 1,500 players drafted that year, he had a tough road to the big leagues.

    Cincinnati Reds second baseman Scooter Gennett (4) of Sarasota makes the throw to first as Rays DH Trevor Plouffe (14) grounds into a double play at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg Monday, June 19, 2017. For Gennett, the three-game series this week with the Rays was his first trip back to Tampa Bay since his historic four-home run game June 6, 2017 against St. Louis. DIRK SHADD   |   Times