Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Tampa Bay Lightning's Dwayne Roloson slumping, but still No. 1 goalie

TAMPA — The dance is not new to either man. They lived it once before in another time, and another place.

It was a little more than four years ago when Mathieu Garon signed a two-year deal to be the backup goaltender to a 38-year-old starter in Edmonton.

When the old guy got off to a 3-9-1 start, Garon was suddenly the most popular hockey player in the city. He started getting playing time. He started getting praise. And by the time midseason rolled around, he had gotten the starting job.

The man he replaced?

Dwayne Roloson.

The story today in Tampa Bay is nearly identical, except the old guy has seen four more birthdays added to his resume. Once again, Garon has signed a two-year deal to be a backup. Once again, Roloson is off to a slow start.

Just don't assume history is about to repeat itself. Lightning coach Guy Boucher is not about to tear up his goaltending plans nine games into a season.

Instead, you might want to consider this a sequel with an ending still to be determined. Roloson has hit a rough patch, Garon has a hot hand, and Boucher is obliged to ride the goaltender who will give his team the best opportunity to win tonight.

"My faith in Roli has not changed at all. Not at all," Boucher said Monday afternoon. "I have always believed in him, not only what he does on the ice, but off the ice as well. Specifically, I believe in his approach to get his game back when it's not at its best.

"He's not only been a man about it, but he's been the perfect example of what you need to be. He's the guy cheering the team on from the bench, he's got the right attitude in practice, and he's showing everybody it's about winning and not about him."

Ask yourself why this is Boucher's stance.

Ask yourself why, when Garon is due to start his third consecutive game tonight in Buffalo, the coach does not make the goaltending job an open competition.

Because the answers are pretty simple when you think about it.

There is a reason Roloson went into the 2007-08 season as the No. 1 goaltender ahead of Garon in Edmonton. There is a reason Roloson reclaimed his job early the next season, and a reason Garon was traded to Pittsburgh a short time later.

And, yes, there is a reason Roloson was No. 1 again when the goaltenders were reunited in Tampa Bay this season.

Roloson has the better track record in the regular season, he has far more experience in the postseason, and he has a stronger reputation for stability in the league.

Now, is it possible circumstances have changed? That Garon, at 33, has finally found his footing with his sixth NHL team? And that Roloson, at 42, has finally seen his time pass?

That is entirely conceivable. A couple of months from now, we may even say it is probable.

But there is no reason to pass final judgment on the goaltenders today. To take a job away from Roloson so quickly into a season.

Garon has been strong in consecutive victories, and Roloson's numbers look embarrassing in contrast. Yet it's not fair to blame Roloson for all the goals that were scored, and it's not fair to credit Garon for all the gains that have been made.

The skaters have played a far tighter and smarter game for Garon. There have not been as many shots on goal, nor as many penalty kill situations.

No one is excusing Roloson's lapses, but the Lightning is also aware that there are mitigating factors for his poor statistics.

"Every goalie goes through this," Boucher said. "The problem is that position is in such a spotlight. That's why not everybody can play goalie because there's so much pressure, and you're under the gun all the time and you're under the radar all the time, and the minute you're a little off or make one mistake, it all comes down on you."

So, yes, there is a good chance Garon will get more playing time than you originally expected. At his age, Roloson was not going to start 60 games anyway. He was probably going to be in the 50-start range, so maybe the final tally will be closer to a 45-37 mix.

Or maybe Garon gradually takes over the job as the season progresses. The point is there is no reason to bury Roloson in October. If his body is finally betraying him, there is plenty of time to figure that out in the coming weeks.

For now, he is still the guy the Lightning considers No. 1.

He still deserves the chance to prove that.

Tampa Bay Lightning's Dwayne Roloson slumping, but still No. 1 goalie 10/24/11 [Last modified: Tuesday, October 25, 2011 10:30am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Rays vs. Orioles, 12:10 p.m. Wednesday, Tropicana Field


    Today: vs. Orioles

    12:10, Tropicana Field

    TV/radio: Fox Sports Sun; 620-AM

    Tickets: $15-$275; available at Tropicana Field box office,, surcharge of up to $5 within 5 hours of game time.

    PORT CHARLOTTE, FL - FEBRUARY 18:  Alex Cobb #53 of the Tampa Bay Rays poses for a portrait during the Tampa Bay Rays photo day on February 18, 2017 at Charlotte Sports Park in Port Charlotte, Floida.  (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images)
  2. Bruce Arena blends intense demands with humor to lead U.S. soccer


    SANTA CLARA, Calif. — Bruce Arena bites his fingernails religiously, a habit he has had since age 10.

    Among some other unmentionables.

    Bruce Arena
  3. Red state: Yes, Bill O'Reilly is a Bucs fan


    TAMPA -- The question was simple enough for Bucs fans: Why is former Fox News personality Bill O'Reilly wearing a red Bucs polo?

    O'Reilly was wearing the polo during a few video clips from his "No Spin News" podcast posted on his website Monday, which was exciting news for some Bucs fans and not-so-exciting …

    Former Fox News personality Bill O'Reilly was sporting a red Bucs polo during his "No Spin News" video podcast Monday. An assistant said the shirt was given to him by former Bucs tight end Dave Moore.
  4. For starters: Slumping LoMo, Dickerson not in Rays lineup tonight vs LHP


    1B Logan Morrison and LF Corey Dickerson, two of the main slumpers in the Rays lineup, are not in tonight's lineup with the Orioles throwing LHP Wade Miley.

    Logan Morrison is 0-for-12 on this homestand.
  5. Ex-Buc Booger McFarland becomes ABC college football analyst


    Former Bucs defensive lineman Booger McFarland is continuing his broadcasting rise by joining ABC's studio coverage for the upcoming college football season, ESPN announced Tuesday.

    Former Bucs lineman Booger McFarland (No. 92) will become an ABC studio analyst this college football season.