Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Whining about Lightning's 1-3-1 defense misses the point

Imagine this: A slugger steps up to the plate in a baseball game. The defense goes into an exaggerated shift in an attempt to prevent a hit. So the batter steps out and refuses to hit until the defense goes back to its normal spots. Ridiculous, right?

That's essentially what the Flyers did Wednesday night when the Lightning, missing several regulars, sat back in its 1-3-1 (prevent) defense hoping to slow the league's top-scoring team. In protest, the Flyers took their puck and tried to go home. They skated figure eights, played with the puck and made little attempt to attack the goal.

Then they whined about the Lightning's tactic, as did the Versus announcers calling the game nationally. That outrage became hockey's hot topic across the United States and Canada on Thursday.

And somehow, the Lightning is the bad guy.

Never mind that Sabres coach Lindy Ruff estimates half the league plays a form of the 1-3-1. Never mind that Lightning coach Guy Boucher was hailed as an innovator for introducing this style to the NHL more than a year ago. Never mind the Lightning held the Flyers to a mere 15 shots, half their normal output. Never mind the Lightning won the game 2-1 in overtime.

Versus analyst (and former Flyer, by the way) Keith Jones called the Lightning's style "embarrassing,'' said Boucher "should be embarrassed,'' applauded the Flyers' work stoppage and summed up his comments by saying the Lightning should be "punished.''

Punished? Punished how? And for what? For winning? Exactly what rules were broken?

Meantime, Jones' sidekick, Mike Milbury, who thinks that the louder he talks, the more right he is, walked off the set during the second intermission in protest of the Lightning's style. (Gee, if I'd known that's what it took to get him off the air, I would've paid someone to play the 1-3-1 years ago.) Before he left, Milbury ripped into the Lightning and said, "The objective of the game is to score goals.''

Wait, isn't the objective to win the game? Milbury's definition of the game's purpose might be the reason the former coach now spends his time in a broadcast studio instead of behind a bench.

Stanley Cup-winning coach (Devils, 1995) and Hall of Famer Jacques Lemaire, often criticized for his neutral-zone trap that suffocated offenses, said, "Are we supposed to coach so we please the people? We please the people who are announcing the game? Is that a new style, or what? Do we have to please Milbury when we coach? It's the first time I hear this.''

Boucher's defense was less sarcastic but more direct: "I'm paid to win games, and our rink is full, and (GM) Steve Yzerman is happy.''

As for the Flyers, see: Yap, shut your.

For much of this season, the Lightning's 1-3-1 defense has looked like a none-3-none defense. Entering play Thursday, the Lightning was tied for 24th in the league in goals allowed, which suggests the other teams on its schedule figured out a way to score against Tampa Bay. Yet the big, bad Flyers, the Broad Street Bullies, would rather belly­ache than come up with the brains to figure out an antidote and the brawn to execute it.

Maybe someday the league will have a rule outlawing the 1-3-1. But how can you blame a team for putting in a legal game plan it believes is best suited for success and then having it succeed? Isn't that the point?

Whining about Lightning's 1-3-1 defense misses the point 11/10/11 [Last modified: Thursday, November 10, 2011 10:22pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Cup-winning Lightning captain Dave Andreychuk makes Hockey Hall of Fame

    Lightning Strikes

    TAMPA — Hall of Fame coach Scotty Bowman said Dave Andreychuk's name has surfaced often the past eight years with the selection committee.

    30 Oct 2001:  Left wing Dave Andreychuk #25 of the Tampa Bay Lightning skates towards the blue line during the NHL game against the Toronto Maple Leafs at Air Canada Centre in Toronto, Canada.  The Maple Leafs defeated the Lightning 3-2.  Mandatory Credit:  Dave Sanford /Allsport
  2. Rays acquire slick-fielding shortstop Adeiny Hechavarria from Marlins

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — Chaim Bloom said the Rays weren't necessarily in the market for a shortstop. The team has a number of those. But when the Marlins recently began shopping Adeiny Hechavarria, well, that was too much to pass up.

    Adeiny Hechavarria has emerged as one of baseball’s top defensive shortstops in the past three seasons with the Marlins.
  3. Rays at Pirates, 7:05 p.m. Tuesday, Pittsburgh

    The Heater

    Tonight: at Pirates

    7:05, PNC Park

    TV/radio: Fox Sports Sun; 620-AM, 680-AM (Spanish)

    Probable pitchers

    Rays: Alex Cobb (6-5, 4.05)

    PORT CHARLOTTE, FL - FEBRUARY 18:  Alex Cobb #53 of the Tampa Bay Rays poses for a portrait during the Tampa Bay Rays photo day on February 18, 2017 at Charlotte Sports Park in Port Charlotte, Floida.  (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images)
  4. Lightning journal: Forward Yanni Gourde agrees to two-year deal

    Lightning Strikes

    TAMPA — Just three years ago, Yanni Gourde was fighting to stay in pro hockey.

    Tampa Bay Lightning center Yanni Gourde celebrates after scoring against the Florida Panthers during the second period of an NHL hockey game, Saturday, March 11, 2017, in Tampa, Fla. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara) TPA108
  5. What they're saying about Dave Andreychuk making Hall of Fame

    Lightning Strikes

    "Dave helped me so much when I was just starting my career, a young kid that was looking to find his way as a hockey player, a person and a member of the Tampa Bay community. In addition to watching him compile such awe-inspiring statistics, I remember him as a big brother to me and many others, making sure all the …