Saturday, December 16, 2017
Tampa Bay Lightning

Fennelly: Why trading Jonathan Drouin could haunt the Lightning

This could haunt the Lightning.

Bolts GM Steve Yzerman and coach Jon Cooper don't scare easily. They proved as much Thursday and took a real chance by dealing Jonathan Drouin to Montreal. Au revoir.

In return, the Lightning gets Montreal's top defensive prospect, Mikhail Sergachev, who was picked ninth overall in the 2016 draft. Sergachev, 18, has the potential to be an elite puck-moving NHL defenseman. That's hard to pass up. A proactive move by Yzerman in the name of the future.

One day, this might be a great deal.

Only this isn't that day.

Drouin wasn't a prospect anymore. He scored 21 goals last season, and I think he has the potential to be a point-per-game guy in this league. He's only 22.

I get the Lightning approach. Drouin could have been a restricted free agent this summer. The Bolts can't sign everyone they want to keep, like Ondrej Palat and Tyler Johnson. Something had to give. Someone had to go. I would have kept Drouin.

I don't think Drouin's past — the sit-down in Syracuse in 2015-16 or the headaches he provided Cooper — were a major factor here, or at least they better not have been.

Drouin must be elated. He returns to Quebec and quickly signs that big contract — six years, $33 million — he was never going to get in Tampa Bay.

On the other hand, Drouin will be under pressure in Montreal. Why do you think Vinny Lecavalier never wanted to play there? Drouin better deliver, or eventually the headline will be "Hab Fans Bid Kid Adieu."

But the Lightning might be haunted first. Especially if Drouin excels in Montreal. Remember when Boston traded problem child Tyler Seguin to Dallas? Seguin is an scoring dynamo for the Stars.

Not only that, the Lightning has traded Drouin within the division, to a offensively starved team. And don't think Drouin won't be out to show up his old team.

Here's another thing: If the Lightning was so determined to get defense, why did it take Drouin third in the 2013 draft instead of defenseman Seth Jones, who went fourth? Jones has turned into an all-star with Columbus. The Lightning could have saved itself some time.

I don't remember Yzerman making many bad deals on his Lightning watch. But this one has mistake potential. Sergachev is a great prospect. But Drouin is already more than that.

Yes, Drouin could be a child. He got lost in his game sometimes, and he made mistakes. And I'm sure he wasn't willing to cut the Lightning a team-friendly deal — too much history.

But people who can make goals and have a genius for creating them for others are a rare commodity in this league, as rare as puck-moving defenseman, maybe more so when the commodity is as talented as Drouin.

Circle those Lightning-Canadiens games on the schedule when it comes out next week.

A haunting we will go?

Contact Martin Fennelly at [email protected] or 813-731-8029. Follow >@mjfennelly.>

   
Comments

Joe Smith’s takeaways from Lightning-Avalanche

Could tell just how much Ryan Callahan meant in the Lightning dressing room by hearing teammates talk about his latest injury. Steven Stamkos said he was "sick to my stomach." Brayden Point called him a "heart and soul player." Teammates all saw how ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Lightning journal: No easy answers on replacing injured Ryan Callahan

Lightning journal: No easy answers on replacing injured Ryan Callahan

The good news for the Lightning is that GM Steve Yzerman is hopeful RW Ryan Callahan will be ready to go in 3-4 weeks when his upper body injury is re-evaluated. The hard part, however, is finding someone to replace the veteran wing. "I don’t know if...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Lightning trying to replace ‘heart and soul’ Ryan Callahan

Lightning trying to replace ‘heart and soul’ Ryan Callahan

With veteran wing Ryan Callahan out at least 3-4 weeks with an upper body injury, the natural question is who will fill his shoes?"I don't know if anyone can," coach Jon Cooper said.That's not to say the Lightning (26-6-2) can't win without Callahan....
Updated: 4 hours ago
Q&A with Syracuse coach Benoit Groulx about the Lightning’s next generation

Q&A with Syracuse coach Benoit Groulx about the Lightning’s next generation

DENVER — There might be one team in hockey hotter than the Lightning.It is Tampa Bay’s AHL affiliate, Syracuse.The Crunch has won 10 straight after Friday’s victory over Providence. Why is this important? While the AHL is a developmental league, the ...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Ryan Callahan out at least 3-4 weeks for Lightning

Ryan Callahan out at least 3-4 weeks for Lightning

When Lightning wing Ryan Callahan took a nasty spill into the boards Thursday night, it didn't look good.Turns out, it wasn't. Callahan will be sidelined indefinitely with an upper body injury, evaluated after three to four weeks, per GM Steve Yzerma...
Published: 12/15/17
When you think you’ve got Brayden Point figured out, a surprise awaits

When you think you’ve got Brayden Point figured out, a surprise awaits

GLENDALE, Ariz. — Center Brayden Point is the Lightning’s calmest player, both on the ice and off, according to Victor Hedman.Point’s soft-spoken nature belies his baby face and 5-foot-10 frame. "I’ve never seen him angry before," Hedman said.That ma...
Published: 12/15/17
Ryan Callahan injury makes Lightning win ‘bittersweet’

Ryan Callahan injury makes Lightning win ‘bittersweet’

The Lightning's 4-1 victory over the Coyotes Thursday night still featured the usual post-game music in the dressing room.But there was more of a somber tone with veteran right wing Ryan Callahan's right arm in a sling. Callahan, who got hurt on a na...
Published: 12/15/17
Lightning routs Coyotes for sixth straight win

Lightning routs Coyotes for sixth straight win

GLENDALE, Ariz. — As much as the Lightning has been rolling, it remembered how it lost twice last season to the Coyotes.That included blowing a one-goal third-period lead at home down the stretch, with Tampa Bay missing the playoffs by a point."You l...
Published: 12/14/17
Updated: 12/15/17
Lightning’s Mikhail Sergachev earns more minutes, praise

Lightning’s Mikhail Sergachev earns more minutes, praise

GLENDALE, Ariz. — Coyotes center Clayton Keller is very familiar with fellow rookie Mikhail Sergachev, the dynamic Lightning defenseman. They both were top 10 picks in 2016, Keller at No. 7 and Sergachev No. 9 to Montreal. They faced each other in th...
Published: 12/14/17
Mikhail Sergachev earning trust – and more minutes with Lightning

Mikhail Sergachev earning trust – and more minutes with Lightning

Coyotes center Clayton Keller is very familiar with fellow rookie Mikhail Sergachev, the Lightning defenseman.They both were picked in the top-10 of the 2016 NHL Draft, Keller at No. 7 and Sergachev No. 9 to Montreal. They faced each other in three w...
Published: 12/14/17