Thursday, November 15, 2018
Outdoors

Researchers take issue with Florida shark attack terminology

Florida is often called the "Shark Attack Capital of the World." But one noted shark researcher thinks the state has gotten a bum rap. • "It can be very misleading," said Bob Hueter, director of Mote Marine Laboratory's Center for Shark Research in Sarasota. "Not all shark-human encounters are created equal. To use the word 'attack' to describe every incident is just not accurate."

Most shark attacks occur close to land. Marine biologists believe that in most cases, the shark has mistaken the swimmer or surfer for a common food source, such as a seal or large fish.

Yet despite these cases of mistaken identity, every shark-human incident is called an "attack," as if it involved malicious or predatory intent.

That is why Hueter and Christopher Neff of the University of Sydney in Australia have proposed a new system of classification to support more accurate reporting of shark-human interactions.

The study, published this year in the peer-reviewed Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences, bolsters the argument that the word "attack" is often misleading.

For starters, of the roughly 500 species of sharks, only a few are known to be dangerous to humans. Three species — the white shark, tiger shark and bull shark — are responsible for most fatal attacks.

In Florida, most shark-human encounters occur in Volusia and Brevard counties and usually involve surfers. Why? The answer is simple. Surfers typically spend more time in the water than swimmers. The longer you spend in the water, the more likely you are to run into a shark.

"They call this area Shark Alley," Hueter said. "The surfers look for waves around the inlets and jetties, which are the same places that the blacktip and spinner sharks look for food."

Hueter said that fatal shark attacks are "extremely rare." Records show that 11 fatal bites have been recorded over the past 129 years in Florida, vastly fewer than the number of deaths by drowning or lightning strikes.

"So we shouldn't classify the accidental bite of a 2-foot-long shark on a surfer's toe the same way we would classify the fatal bite of a 15-foot great white shark on a swimmer," Hueter added.

So Hueter and Neff, his Australian colleague, have come up with four categories that can be used to describe a wide range of shark incidents:

• Shark sightings: Sightings of sharks in the water in proximity to people with no physical contact.

• Shark encounters: No bite takes place and no humans are injured, but physical contact occurs with a person or an inanimate object holding a person, such as a surfboard or boat. A shark might also bump a swimmer and its rough skin might cause a minor abrasion.

• Shark bites: Bites by small or large sharks that result in minor to moderate injuries.

• Fatal shark bites: One or more bites causing fatal injuries. Hueter and Neff cautioned against using the term "shark attack" unless the motivation and intent of the shark are clearly established by experts, which is rarely possible.

Hueter said that sharks are in danger, thanks in part to the popular misconception that these creatures are all man killers.

"The term 'man-eater' was coined two centuries ago by a scientist who had limited understanding of shark behavior and biology," he said. "Then, in the 1950s, another researcher wrongly suggested sharks could go 'rogue' and develop a taste for human flesh."

Hueter said that the unwarranted use of the word "attack" in newspaper headlines or in television broadcasts has added to the poor public perception of sharks.

"Sharks play a vital role in the marine ecosystem," Hueter said. "The more people understand them, the better their long-term chance of survival."

   
Comments
Take it outside: Chasing an inshore slam in Tampa Bay with Roland Martin

Take it outside: Chasing an inshore slam in Tampa Bay with Roland Martin

Fishing with Roland Martin was a bucket list couple of days for Misty Wells.
Published: 11/14/18
Captainís Corner: Whatís happening with the redfish?

Captainís Corner: Whatís happening with the redfish?

Fall is when adult redfish return from the open gulf and spawn just offshore of the major estuaries. These breeders rarely come back inshore to the flats where they spend their first 3-4 years of life. Once they mature, usually at around 30-32 inches...
Published: 11/10/18
Updated: 11/11/18
Captainís Corner: Snook fishing has been strong

Captainís Corner: Snook fishing has been strong

This year continues to bring challenges for the bay areaís guide business. What most donít realize is how good fishing is inside Tampa Bay. Most of the bay it is free of Red Tide and full of marine life. In fact, I have notice that the clean areas ar...
Published: 11/08/18
Updated: 11/09/18

Captainís Corner: Tips for Old Salt King of the Beach kingfish tournament

The Old Salt King of the Beach kingfish tournament is this weekend, and there are plenty of reasons to think itís going to take a fish in the 40-pound range to wear the crown. Last Sunday was the final leg of this yearís Wild West kingfish tournament...
Published: 11/07/18
Updated: 11/08/18

Captainís Corner: A welcome return of flounder to Tampa Bay

It has been two years but flounder have again become an option around Tampa Bay. If you know where to go for the under≠utilized species, you can have excellent flounder action. Theyíre easy to catch but challenging. I call it flounder frustration: Yo...
Published: 11/05/18
Updated: 11/07/18
Captainís Corner: Low tides offer good snook, redfish and trout fishing

Captainís Corner: Low tides offer good snook, redfish and trout fishing

Inshore waters are full of bait and are attracting schools of ladyfish, bluefish, trout and Spanish mackerel. The bite can be insane at times, especially on a good moving tide. Toss out live pilchards for chum to attract the fish to your area and als...
Published: 11/05/18
Updated: 11/06/18

Captainís Corner: Shark exodus is good news for divers

The summer-time sharks have started their migration away from the Tampa Bay area to the coastal waters of South Florida. This makes it safer for the divers who are spearing in the darker inshore waters of the bay. Most of these bay spearfishermen are...
Published: 11/04/18
Updated: 11/05/18
Captainís Corner: Normal conditions on water close to returning

Captainís Corner: Normal conditions on water close to returning

High winds and rain will change the conditions of the water in North Pinellas this weekend. The clarity had been good and I expect a couple of calm days will return conditions to normal. Cooler temps are creeping into the area, but the water is still...
Published: 11/02/18
Updated: 11/03/18

Captainís Corner: Speckled sea trout a good target

The gulf water temperature has dropped into the 70s, significantly lower than the mid 80s just 10 days ago. The drop in temperature has caused the speckled sea trout fishing to become a reliable target. Redfish have been on the move, so sea trout has...
Published: 11/01/18

Captainís Corner: Cooler weather should help fish action heat up

If the forecast is correct, we will finally have cooler weather, with water temperatures in the 70s. Fishing is always better when water temperatures teeter in the low 70s for spring and fall runs. Cold fronts will usher in lots of wind with cold air...
Updated one month ago