Make us your home page
Instagram

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Playing under protest? Good luck with that

Joe Girardi argues with umpire Dana DeMuth over a call Tuesday.

New York Times

Joe Girardi argues with umpire Dana DeMuth over a call Tuesday.

When New York Yankees pitcher Dellin Betances overthrew first baseman Mark Teixeira, allowing the Houston Astros to score a run Tuesday, manager Joe Girardi was incensed. The Astros' 6-foot-4 Carlos Correa had caused the errant throw by running on the field side of the first-base line, Girardi believed, and not in the running lane.

So Girardi followed the pattern trod by so many managers. First, he argued. And when that did not work, he announced that he was playing the game under protest.

Playing a game under protest because of some perceived injustice is not uncommon in baseball. In 2014, the Tampa Bay Rays objected to the timing of a replay challenge. In the 2012 National League wild-card game, the Atlanta Braves disputed an infield fly rule call. In 2011, the Philadelphia Phillies were angry about fan interference.

These grievances, like so many others, had two things in common: They led to the game being played under protest. And the protest was quickly dismissed.

Reversals after a game is over are exceedingly rare. Rule 7.04 sets a fairly high bar: Even if it is held that the protested decision violated the rules, no replay of the game will be ordered unless in the opinion of the league president the violation adversely affected the protesting team's chances of winning the game.

The historical research group Project Retrosheet found 15 games that were resumed after a successful protest, but only one in the 21st century. The key element in that successful protest was, of all things, a tarp.

When rain came in a San Francisco Giants-Chicago Cubs game in August 2014, the host Cubs struggled to get the tarp on the field quickly. The game was eventually called on account of rain, and the Cubs were declared winners by the score at the time.

But, the league said: "The groundskeeping crew was unable to properly deploy the tarp after the rain worsened. In accordance with Rule 4.12(a)(3), the game should be considered a suspended game that must be completed at a future date."

Major League Baseball executive Joe Torre said the failure to store the tarp properly contributed to the problems.

Two days later, the game resumed. The Giants scored a run, but the Cubs hung on for a 2-1 victory.

By far the most famous resumed contest was the Pine Tar Game of 1983. George Brett's ninth-inning homer was declared void after his bat was found to have too much pine tar on it, and the Yankees went on to beat the Kansas City Royals. But the league decided the ruling was wrong, reinstated Brett's homer, and ordered the game to be resumed from that point. The Royals hung on for the win.

Playing under protest? Good luck with that 04/07/16 [Last modified: Thursday, April 7, 2016 9:46pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, New York Times.
    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Rays call up Jose De Leon to add depth to bullpen tonight

    Blogs

    The Rays decided that after playing 15 innings Sunday they could use some depth and length in their bullpen after all and have decided to call up RHP Jose De Leon from Triple-A.

    RHP Erasmo Ramirez is still slated to start tonight, even after throwing 12 pitches to get the final three outs - and the save - in …

  2. Tiger Woods arrested in Florida on DUI charge, released

    Public Safety

    Tiger Woods was arrested early Monday on a DUI charge in Jupiter, Florida, and spent nearly four hours in a county jail before he was released.

    Tiger Woods has been arrested on a DUI charge in Florida.
  3. After state, academics will trump athletics for King ace Brian Lee

    Baseballpreps

    TAMPA — Brian Lee can still see himself on the pitcher's mound at Venice High School. Four years ago he was a freshman left-handed reliever just trying to keep King's state championship dreams alive.

    Pitcher Brian Lee participates in a practice at King High in Tampa, Fla., on Friday, May 26, 2017.
  4. Five cool things to do when it's hot outside

    Outdoors

    Summer is not officially here, but it may as well be. School is out, vacations are coming, and it's time to enjoy the outdoors. Don't buy the argument that summer in Florida is too hot to get outside. There is plenty to do, and we'll prove it. Here are five cool things to do outdoors during another hot summer.

    Rainbow Springs State Park is a registered natural landmark. Rainbow Springs State Park in Dunnellon is one several state parks with natural swimming holes in Florida. (Octavio Jones | Times)
  5. Rays morning after: A lot that went into a marathon win

    Blogs

    Rays manager Kevin Cash had a simple strategy when Fox Sports Sun's Alex Corddry asked him how the team would move on from Sunday's marathon win and get ready to face the Rangers tonight in Texas:

    Kevin Kiermaier of the Rays celebrates as teammate Michael Martinez slides safely into home plate to score a run against the Minnesota Twins during the 14th inning.