Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Column | John C. Cotey

A high school football coach's concern can cloud college future for his players

TAMPA — Robert Marve was out, and Bob Weiner was incensed.

The smoke from his scorched-earth response to University of Miami coach Randy Shannon dismissing his former Plant High quarterback could be seen from Coral Gables to Tallahassee.

Effectively banning any of his future players from accepting football scholarships to Miami, including current prized recruit Orson Charles, is nothing Weiner is willing to apologize for, even if the Web burned up with people calling the Plant coach a jerk.

More like knee-jerk.

"I know I said that about Randy Shannon,'' Weiner said, "and I don't apologize for the reaction. I was just standing up for one of our kids, and that's what we do as coaches.''

Weiner isn't the first coach to ban a big-name college from recruiting his players.

Just last week, Tucker (Ga.) High coach Franklin Stephens said that South Carolina coach Steve Spurrier "is no longer welcome" to recruit his players after senior linebacker Jonathan Davis had his scholarship offer pulled.

"Coach Spurrier accepted blame for the situation … (but he) is not going to do anything to fix the situation, therefore South Carolina will not be recruiting any more Tucker players," Stephens told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

Both coaches made strong, public decisions. Weiner has set things right with Miami; Stephens should probably follow suit.

Recruiting is a dirty, messy game. Colleges offer more scholarships than they actually have. They make promises they can't keep. They can, when reckless, ruin a teenager's life.

But no high school coach has the right to deny an opportunity for another player years down the road. Banning a school isn't an answer; educating players about the tricks of the trade most definitely is.

Lawrence Dawsey, who recruits the Tampa Bay area for Florida State, says he understands the hazards of his job. He knows there is probably always a school out there making better offers, bigger promises, but there is a price to pay when they aren't delivered.

"It's when you lie to them they want to do something like (blackball you),'' he said. "But this is my home ground; I can't afford to have one of my high school coaches mad at me.''

There is a perception that FSU has been banned from Armwood's campus, but coach Sean Callahan says that's only because the Seminoles haven't landed any Hawks in recent years.

Callahan has, however, banned a school from recruiting his players in the past.

In 2003-04, Callahan arranged for North Carolina State to meet with three of his recruits at the same time. But he says that at Armwood's practice, the Wolfpack recruiter zeroed in on receiver Chris Murray, who had orally committed to Miami.

"He's the only kid I've had that ever decommitted,'' Callahan said.

Embarrassed, Callahan said he prohibited the other three players from going to N.C. State and didn't let the school back on campus until the staff at the time was fired.

Few coaches have banned colleges from visiting, but a greater danger to eager recruiters might be high school coaches who steer their players away.

Armwood quarterback Mywan Jackson joined teammate Angelo Hadley in recently committing to North Carolina, where Callahan's son Kirk is an assistant.

Jackson chose North Carolina over Auburn, Louisville and Michigan, but he said Callahan told him to make his own decision.

"He told us to go with our hearts,'' Jackson said. "He said, 'I'm not going to push you either way.' ''

Callahan said he only pushes his players to make at least two visits and do their research.

He would not hesitate, however, to warn a player about a school that had harmed one of his players in the past.

Weiner said he and other coaches are merely protecting players. If programs are going to renege on scholarship offers, break promises made to get kids to sign, and treat them poorly once on campus, he feels obligated to inform future players.

Banning a school, though?

Even Weiner admits that's a little harsh and maybe unfair to future players.

Since his comments about Miami and Shannon, Weiner still stops short of an apology but has reconsidered any ban.

After patching things up the past two weeks with the Miami staff, he finally had a conversation with Shannon on Monday hoping to rebuild that bridge.

"It was a knee-jerk reaction,'' said Weiner, one of the bay area's more emotional and fiercely protective coaches. "I would never tell a kid he can't go somewhere. If someone wanted to play for Randy Shannon or Miami, I would help pursue that.

"That being said, as coaches we have the responsibility to help create a pros and cons chart. What might be better and what might not be. But I'd never give that advice unsolicited.''

The smoke lingers for these coaches, and colleges recruiting their players know that where there is smoke, there is fire.

John C. Cotey can be reached at

A high school football coach's concern can cloud college future for his players 01/14/09 [Last modified: Thursday, January 15, 2009 7:12am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Celtics were only team in position to deal for Kyrie Irving


    The Cavaliers found themselves in a seemingly impossible situation when it came to trading Kyrie Irving. Not only did Cleveland need to try to extract the kind of price a team looks to get to trade its star — some combination of cap relief, young players and draft picks — it also needed to acquire talent to …

    Kyrie Irving, left, is guarded by Stephen Curry during the NBA Finals last season. [Associated Press]
  2. Browns, who visit Bucs this week, take a courageous step toward social change


    CLEVELAND — The laughingstock of the league during a 1-15 season in 2016, the Browns took a dramatic step forward Monday night.

    Browns players kneel as others stand to support their circle during the national anthem before Monday night's preseason game against the Giants. [Associated Press]
  3. Can Bucs become Tampa Bay's favorite team again?


    Their playoff run came up a tiebreaker short.

    Bucs fullback, Mike Alstott talks to the crowd as he walked along Kennedy Blvd. in downtown Tampa during the Buccaneer victory parade Tuesday, Jan. 28, 2003.Times Photo by: Fraser Hale
  4. Jones: Koetter-Winston exchange highlights latest 'Hard Knocks'


    There are certain things that make HBO's Hard Knocks must-see television.

    Jameis Winston, left, has an exchange with Dirk Koetter that highlights Hard Knocks.
  5. Trevor Plouffe is DFA'd by Rays, Kittredge recalled for now


    INF Trevor Plouffe didn't do much with the opportunity the Rays gave him, and time ran out Tuesday when he was designated for assignment after the game.

    Plouffe hit just .178, with one homer and two RBIs, in 31 games for the Rays, his primary playing time from starting at first or third against lefties.