Wednesday, June 20, 2018
Florida News

State regulators vote to increase some cancer-causing toxins in state water

Florida regulators voted to approve a new water quality standard  Tuesday that will increase the amount of cancer-causing toxins allowed in Florida's rivers and streams under a plan the state says will protect more Floridians than current standards.

The Environmental Regulation Commission voted 3-2 to approve a proposal drafted by state regulators that would increase the number of regulated chemicals  from 54 to 92 allowed in rivers, streams and other sources of drinking water.

"We have not updated these parameters since 1992. It is more good than harm,'' said Cari Roth, a Tallahassee lawyer who represents developers on the commission before the vote.

But the proposal, based on a one-of-a-kind scientific method nicknamed "Monte Carlo," is being vigorously criticized by environmental groups who warned that it will allow polluters to dump dangerous amounts of chemicals in high concentrations before they trigger the limits of the new rule.

"Monte Carlo gambling with our children's safety is unacceptable,'' said Marty Baum of Indian Riverkeeper, an environmental group based in Indian River County.

He and more than three dozen other environmentalists warned that the state's attempt to devise a new way to assess the risk of toxic chemicals on human health will result in higher concentrations of chemicals being dumped into Florida rivers and streams.

Under the proposal, the acceptable levels of toxins will be increased for more than two dozen known carcinogens and decreased for  13 currently regulated chemicals. The proposal also will reduce impose new rules on 39 other chemicals that could  be dumped into Florida rivers and streams that are currently not regulated.

The agency defended the proposal, and its new Monte Carlo approach -- also known as "probabilistic analysis" -- saying it is more responsive to Florida variables by shielding people who consume large amounts of fish from the build up of dangerous toxins.

The approach attempts to calculate the health effects of being exposed to a lifetime of toxic chemicals by taking into consideration average body weight, drinking water consumption rate, fish and shellfish consumption rate, and the fat content of fish -- important because fat absorbs most of the toxins in seafood.

But during a seven-hour hearing in Tallahassee, more than three dozen members of the public, many representing environmental groups, raised concerns that the new state rule is 80 to 90 percent less protective than for most chemicals than the federal recommendations.

" All the new criteria that are added "are less protective than what EPA recommends,'' said Linda Young, executive director of the Florida Clean Water Network.

But DEP aggressively defended it proposal, saying it has been developing the criteria for more than a decade.

"The department has left no stone unturned to develop science-based and legally defensible criteria,'' said Tom Frick, director of the DEP division of environmental management and restoration, at a day-long meeting of the ERC.

Adam Gelber of Miami, who represents science and technical interests, opposed the rule. He commended the department but said he was not confident that the information was based on Florida data.

He raised questions about the decision by DEP to increase the allowed levels of benzene, a known carcinogen. DEP initially proposed raising the standard from 1.18 parts per billion in Florida’s drinking water sources to 3 parts per billion but, after public outcry, the agency revised its criteria and reduce the level to 2 parts per billion. The federal standard is 1.14 parts per billion.

"I fear there is a fatal flaw,'' Gelber said. "If we went back and adjusted the models, how would the other criteria drop?...It would appear to me there are some tweak in the system that could be made across the board."

Environmentalists say they are suspicious that DEP has increased levels of benzene, which is found in the wastewater of oil and gas fracking operations, in an effort to pave the way for legislation to open the door to fracking in Florida.

DEP officials, however, said that the science of benzene has changed in recent years resulting in the higher limits.

Also voting against the proposal was Joe Joyce of Gainesville, who represents agricultural interests on the commission. He also raised questions about the unexplained rise in benzene levels.

But Craig Varn, a lawyer from Miami, who was the DEP general counsel a year ago, said "fundamentally what it came down to either I'm going to accept the modeling as good or I'm going to reject it. ...I'm erring on the side of human health. Is it perfect, no?"

In an interview with the Herald/Times, Varn said he could not recall being involved in the development of the rule while he was general counsel. 

Broward County's top environmental scientist was among those who urged the commission to reject the new rule, warning that they will also for dangerous concentrations of chemicals that may not be detected by testing.

DEP's documents acknowledge that permits can be allowed to require companies to meet the water quality standard in a water body after the discharge has passed through what is known as "mixing zones," thereby allowing for dilution and diffusion of the pollution beyond the point of discharge before its is tested, said Jennifer Jurado, director of Broward County environmental planning and community resilience division.

By contrast, she said, Broward County water quality criteria imposes a stricter standard, imposing water quality testing at the end of the pipe where the chemicals are discharged into a water body.

"So there is a lot of flexibility, depending on how they choose to apply the standard, that creates an exposure,'' she said.

The commission was scolded for not having its full complement of members while agreeing to reschedule the vote on the controversial rules from September to July.

As the commission was about to take a vote, John Moran, who identified himself as a graduate student from Stanford University, walked to the dias and sat in an open chair.

"The governor has spat on our decision process by keeping these seats vacant for over a year,'' he said. DEP security escorted him out.

Comments
Report: Bucs QB Jameis Winston bracing for suspension from NFL

Report: Bucs QB Jameis Winston bracing for suspension from NFL

Bucs quarterback Jameis Winston could be suspended for up to three games  next season following the league's investigation into allegations he groped a female Uber driver in Arizona in 2016, a Tallahassee radio station reported.Jeff Cameron, a&#...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Lightning’s Victor Hedman wins NHL’s Norris Trophy

Lightning’s Victor Hedman wins NHL’s Norris Trophy

Victor Hedman, a relentless part of the Lightning's push to the Eastern Conference final, was honored Wednesday night with the Norris Trophy, given to the NHL's top defenseman."To the Lightning organization, Mr. Jeff Vinik, Steve Yzerman and the coac...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Passengers on fatal Southwest flight sue airline and manufacturers of plane and engine

Passengers on fatal Southwest flight sue airline and manufacturers of plane and engine

Eight passengers who were aboard a Southwest Airlines flight that was forced to make an emergency landing in Philadelphia after one of its engines blew apart filed suit Wednesday against the airline, Boeing and the companies that manufactured the eng...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Former employee sued by Tesla says he was a whistleblower

Former employee sued by Tesla says he was a whistleblower

Tesla sued a former employee Wednesday, accusing the man of hacking the automaker’s computer systems and stealing company secrets, shedding light on what chief Elon Musk had suggested was the work of a secretive internal saboteur.But the employee, Ma...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Rays see the results of keeping a good, young core group together.

Rays see the results of keeping a good, young core group together.

HOUSTON — The Rays saw a lot on the weeklong trip that ended with Wednesday's game against that Astros, beyond the street hustlers prowling in Times Square and the urban cowboys and girls parading through H-town.There was an impressive debuting...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Police: Couple leased someone else’s home to 15 families at same time

Police: Couple leased someone else’s home to 15 families at same time

LARGO — Vanessa Rodriguez thought she found the right house for her three kids, in the right neighborhood, for the right rent. She signed the lease for April 30, sent a $2,300 money order and planned to move in June 1.Then the delays started. She sai...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Clearwater wants $40 million from the county for a stadium. But there’s not $40 million to give.

Clearwater wants $40 million from the county for a stadium. But there’s not $40 million to give.

CLEARWATER —The city’s proposed $79.7 million overhaul of the Philadelphia Phillies’ spring training facilities depends on getting $40 million in bed taxes from Pinellas County.But records show even if county officials wanted to bankroll the Phillies...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Hillsborough commissioners approve referendum on making county officers non-partisan

Hillsborough commissioners approve referendum on making county officers non-partisan

TAMPA — The debate over whether "Rep" or "Dem" should be on the ballot alongside the name of candidates for sheriff or property appraiser is now in the hands of Hillsborough County voters.Hillsborough County commissioners voted 5-2 Wednesday to hold ...
Updated: 4 hours ago
For starters: Rays at Astros, with a different look

For starters: Rays at Astros, with a different look

UPDATE, 6:43: Cash said the key to how the pieced the lineup together was the opportunity to give Cron (who is struggling) and Duffy (who is doing well) back to back days off. … Looking ahead to the weekend, the Rays will use RHP Ryne Stanek as...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Seminole Heights restaurant Mortar & Pestle files for bankruptcy reorganization

Seminole Heights restaurant Mortar & Pestle files for bankruptcy reorganization

TAMPA — Mortar & Pestle, a fledgling Seminole Heights eatery with a mom-and-pop pharmacy theme, has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy reorganization. Seacoast Bank was listed as the creditor with the largest unsecured claim: $1.4 million.The restaurant...
Updated: 7 hours ago