Thursday, June 21, 2018
News Roundup

Instant replay is changing baseball

The year-old instant replay system in baseball has been highly controversial, with many supporters and many opponents. The sport is attempting to shy away from its more traditional roots by using the modern technology that is employed in football and basketball.

The chief motto of Major League Baseball in this pursuit is that its wish is to "get the call right." However, many fans fear that use of instant replay has detracted from the overall appeal of the game and do not believe that it will be a beneficial change for spectators in the long run.

I have reviewed the pros and cons of the instant replay system. The statistics in the article were retrieved from fivethirtyeight.com, a sports website affiliated with ESPN, and Retrosheet, a baseball stats website.

The pros

The main pros of the instant replay system lie in its ability to ensure that baseball calls are made correctly, and there are no errors to alter the final score of the game. The team managers are given power over calls, thus have an additional task during baseball games: deciding when to use their one challenge.

As of the final month in the 2014 regular season, there were 1,130 challenges by managers. Of these 1,130 challenges, 529 led to the overturning of a call. This is a 47 percent clip, which is interesting considering that managers initiated 83 percent of these challenges.

This means that the new instant replay system has allowed the managers more input into the calls and allowed the game results to be more accurate. The plays that get challenged the most include force and tag plays, home runs and home plate collisions. This pattern coincides with the events that transpired before instant replay: these were the most debated and influential plays on the flow of the game.

Force plays were overturned 259 times and confirmed 73 times, with 134 calls "standing" — meaning there wasn't enough evidence to overturn them. Tag plays were overturned 183 times, with 75 confirmed and 122 standing. Not as many calls on home runs (21, vs. 43 and 21) and home plate collisions (12, vs. 57 and 11) were overturned, but a significant number on each was.

These statistics illustrate the importance of having instant replay in the effort to get the calls right.

The cons

The cons of the instant replay system center on time — in any sport, the primary concern of replay is the delay that occurs as a result. However, most proponents of the instant replay system argue that the average challenge lasts for only one minute and 48 seconds, and there are only 0.48 challenges per game on average. So, replay challenges add an average of 52 seconds per game, which does not seem like a substantial number.

Unfortunately, in the 2014 baseball season, the challenges altogether occupied 2,031 minutes, which equates to about 1.4 days of time. Numbers show that the number of challenges rises as the game goes on, with the majority of challenges occurring in the ninth and 10th innings. This can potentially irritate and even bore the audience, as the game is slowed and delayed during the times when the excitement is the most intense.

Furthermore, the instant replay system has dramatically altered the baseball culture. Mets fan Jerry Seinfeld recently told ESPN that getting the call right is not a priority for himself and other fans. Instead, he claims that replay has led to the loss of baseball's "human element": the "futile, frustrated managerial tirade."

This change in aesthetics threatens to derail the sport in the long term — fans of the traditional form of America's game may suffer from the modernization that it is struggling to undergo.

Final verdict

From the accumulated information, it is clear that the Major League Baseball instant replay system has more pros than cons. The drawbacks of the system are primarily apparent in the alterations of the aesthetics of the sport: fans are concerned that the frustration of players and managers, which they have found amusement in for so long, will be removed from the game. This may be true, but the sport of baseball is sure to transform itself and include instant replay in a way that audiences find appropriate. The cost of adding less than a minute per game to ensure that it is officiated correctly is tantalizing, and is well worth the loss of visual enjoyment and time that accompanies it.

Comments
Pasco deputies searching for missing Holiday autistic teen

Pasco deputies searching for missing Holiday autistic teen

The Pasco County Sheriff’s Office is searching for a missing autistic boy who walked out of his Holiday residence Wednesday night.Jordan Webb, 16, left his home at 2522 Wood Pointe in Holiday around 11 p.m. He was last seen wearing a black Carolina P...
Updated: 22 minutes ago
Koko, the gorilla who knew sign language, dies at 46

Koko, the gorilla who knew sign language, dies at 46

WOODSIDE, Calif. (AP) — Koko, the gorilla who mastered sign language, has died.The Gorilla Foundation says the 46-year-old western lowland gorilla died in its sleep at the foundation’s preserve in California’s Sana Cruz mountains on Tuesday.Koko was ...
Updated: 22 minutes ago
Forecast: A rainy ‘official’ start to summer for Tampa Bay

Forecast: A rainy ‘official’ start to summer for Tampa Bay

It’s the first day of summer and Tampa Bay can expect a lot of rain through the weekend as a broad low-pressure system moves into the gulf from the northeast.Scattered showers and thunderstorms may march through the Tampa Bay area on Thursday morning...
Updated: 1 hour ago
The Daystarter: CareerSource used credit cards to boost hiring totals; report says Winston suspension coming; Hedman wins Norris Trophy; get ready for Pride

The Daystarter: CareerSource used credit cards to boost hiring totals; report says Winston suspension coming; Hedman wins Norris Trophy; get ready for Pride

Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what to know today.• Today is also the official start of summer, not that anyone will be able to tell. It will be hot and muggy with just a 30 percent chance of rain heading into Friday, according to 10We...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Rays journal: 7 pitches, 3 straight homers prove too much in loss to Astros

Rays journal: 7 pitches, 3 straight homers prove too much in loss to Astros

HOUSTON — The Rays were engaged in a third straight tight, go-either-way battle with the defending champ Astros on Wednesday.Until they were not.A brutal seven-pitch sequence by starter Nathan Eovaldi changed everything, as he gave up three con...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Romano: Intrigue behind all those manicured lawns

Romano: Intrigue behind all those manicured lawns

I’ve always thought homeowners associations had a lot in common with cops.People love to complain about them and often accuse them of abusing their power. And yet as soon as a neighbor paints his house a hot shade of fuchsia, you’re screaming for the...
Published: 06/21/18
Tampa tech firm Newgentek hiring 20 following expansion

Tampa tech firm Newgentek hiring 20 following expansion

TAMPA — Information technology company Newgentek plans to hire 20 new employees over the next two years following an expansion of its Tampa headquarters."In the last 90 days, the Newgentek team has grown 24 percent and is now operating at 80 percent ...
Published: 06/21/18
Daniel Ruth: Florida should consider taking back its outsourced foster care services

Daniel Ruth: Florida should consider taking back its outsourced foster care services

We hear a great deal about how government is the source of all evil, a wasteful, incompetent coven of lazy paper-pushing bureaucrats.That is why the heavens open and the angels sing and all is right with the world whenever we can wrest away various s...
Published: 06/21/18
Spring Hill farm: Where people and horses save each other

Spring Hill farm: Where people and horses save each other

SPRING HILLWhen Luke Betancourt, 3, first came to Serenity Stables, he didn’t talk. He was born on the autism spectrum and with sensory processing disorder. Doctors said there was a chance he’d always be nonverbal.His mom, Diana Betancourt, heard tha...
Published: 06/21/18
A tight supply cuts into Tampa Bay home sales while prices keep rising

A tight supply cuts into Tampa Bay home sales while prices keep rising

Tampa Bay’s two largest counties showed anemic home sales in May as prices continued to rise due to a tight supply. In Pinellas, sales of single-family home plunged nearly 12 percent from the previous May, the second-worst showing in a year. P...
Updated: 2 hours ago