Sunday, May 20, 2018
Cooking

From the food editor: the popularity of Allrecipes, and a recipe for panzanella

As the editor of a food section, I constantly think about the best recipes to feature in these pages. What will be most useful to our readers, both the ones who have been cooking for decades or want to challenge themselves, and those beginners who could use some help? We try to strike a balance, but the fact is not everyone is going to get maximum satisfaction out of every recipe.

An article published last week on the website Slate helped explain why, with an interesting look at one of the Internet's most popular food sites: Allrecipes. The article's premise is that there is a large gulf between the food (and, more broadly, the culture) we talk and write about and the food people actually make in their homes each night. Like how music or TV shows that get the most critical acclaim are, more often than not, ones that have smaller wide appeal.

The article reports that "Allrecipes is the most popular English-language food website in the world," with almost 50 million visits to the site last December, the most monthly views for any food site by far. A lot of this is due to Allrecipes' uncanny ability to appear high up in Google search results. Next time you search for a recipe, notice how the site is almost always within the first five results.

And for home cooks, the site is especially appealing because user feedback plays a vital role. Readers can give each recipe a star ranking, and a comment, and recipes often become popular (or not) because of their ratings. It fosters a sense of community, a feeling that if your fellow home cook liked this recipe, you will, too.

There are recipes like the Slow-Cooker Chicken Tortilla Soup, which has more than 3,000 reviews and a 4 ½ star out of 5 rating from the more than 5,000 people who have made the dish. Comments range:

"We live in Mexico and this is AS CLOSE TO AUTHENTIC as possible."

"This recipe, unfortunately, is only worth two stars — barely. Too watery, too spicy, and tasted just like liquid enchiladas."

A very simple dish, eliciting thousands of opinions.

As Slate points out, the majority of recipes on this site are not glamorous or elaborate. They're convenient, with simple ingredients and steps that involve little more than chopping and moving things around in a skillet. As you make many of the recipes — and I have made some in my kitchen over the years — you start to notice that a lot of the ingredients are canned, or otherwise more convenient versions of fresher products. Shortcuts to help get dinner on the table quicker.

I get it, but personally, this reliance on convenience is a reason I don't frequent this site anymore. As someone who considers herself a solid cook, the process of working with ingredients — grating a block of Parmesan cheese; dicing a fresh tomato; turning flour, butter and cheese into a sauce — is vital. The reasons you cook may be different. For some people, it's a task. For others, it's a process of exciting discovery. And sites like Allrecipes tend to not gin up a ton of excitement in my kitchen.

This week's recipe

It's with all of this in mind that I recommend this week's recipe, a panzanella salad. It's an example of a dish that sounds fancy, complicated, not like something you could whip up in the middle of the week — but it is actually a simple amalgamation of very common ingredients.

And, in keeping with the theme of our cover story, it's kind of like a deconstructed sandwich. Panzanella is a Tuscan bread salad traditionally made during the summer. It usually involves tomatoes.

It is a good way to use up older, softer tomatoes, herbs and bread that may be past its prime. Chop them all up, add some cheese and some olive oil, and you've got a hearty salad fit for dinner. No oven, or complicated instructions, required.

Contact Michelle Stark at [email protected] or (727) 893-8829. Follow @mstark17.

Comments
Host a watch party and British breakfast for Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's royal wedding

Host a watch party and British breakfast for Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's royal wedding

The nuptials of Meghan Markle and Prince Harry commence Saturday in London, and once again we Americans have become bonkers for the wedding of a member of the British royal family. Almost 23 million viewers in the United States watched coverage of H...
Published: 05/16/18
Five ideas for sleep-friendly midnight snacks

Five ideas for sleep-friendly midnight snacks

When the clock strikes midnight, I reach for the cookie jar. Okay, maybe itís not an actual jar ó maybe Iím even lazier, and I reach for the cardboard box of chocolate chip cookies I bought from the store. The point is, my late-night snack habits are...
Published: 05/16/18
Exploring alternative tea drinks to toast Prince Harry and Meghan Markleís royal wedding

Exploring alternative tea drinks to toast Prince Harry and Meghan Markleís royal wedding

The year was 2011. It was the night before Prince Williamís wedding to Kate Middleton, and I stood in my kitchen making chocolate chip scones. I set my alarm for 3:30 a.m., with plans to sit in the spare bedroom of the townhome and watch Britainís ro...
Published: 05/15/18
Taste test: pineapple juice

Taste test: pineapple juice

Having always loved a fresh pineapple stick in my brewed iced tea, I wondered recently if a splash of pineapple juice would give it the same sweet kick. While few of us drink pure pineapple juice, our panelists definitely enjoy an occasional watered-...
Published: 05/14/18
Branch out: Give Sauteed Asparagus in Soy Sauce Glaze a try

Branch out: Give Sauteed Asparagus in Soy Sauce Glaze a try

Asparagus is by far the favorite vegetable of my family. I can serve nearly 3 pounds of asparagus a couple of times a week to my family of six, and my girls will still argue over who gets the last stalk. I say this not to impress you with the adventu...
Published: 05/11/18
Five ideas for Motherís Day breakfasts

Five ideas for Motherís Day breakfasts

Are you stumped for Motherís Day ideas? Donít stress. This year, surprise the mothers in your life with a special breakfast that fits perfectly with their personalities. Whether she loves the tradition of breakfast-in-bed or prefers her meals on the ...
Published: 05/09/18
Updated: 05/10/18
Review: Rick Bragg’s ‘The Best Cook in the World’ a loving food memoir about his mother

Review: Rick Bragg’s ‘The Best Cook in the World’ a loving food memoir about his mother

When Rick Bragg told his mother that his new book about her would be titled The Best Cook in the World, Margaret Bragg protested: "I wasn’t even the best cook that lived on our road." Bragg writes, "I told her we couldn’t call it The Thi...
Published: 05/09/18
Making granola at home is easy and scrumptious with this Maple Cashew Granola

Making granola at home is easy and scrumptious with this Maple Cashew Granola

If Iím being honest, most of what I do in the kitchen is recreate really delicious things Iíve eaten somewhere else. No, it never tastes the same, but itís a useful way to get cooking inspiration, and also to not spend $10 on something it takes $2 to...
Published: 05/08/18
Updated: 05/09/18
Recipe for Slow Cooked Pork Roast

Recipe for Slow Cooked Pork Roast

Slowly cooking a big hunk of tough, inexpensive meat isnít just the best way to cook this cut of meat. Itís really the only way. Most tough cuts of meat come from the hardest working parts of the animal, and therefore have a lot of collagen. This col...
Published: 05/08/18
Taste test: New frozen chocolate treats

Taste test: New frozen chocolate treats

With longer summer nights on the horizon, our judges are always looking for a new cool treat to beat the heat. This week they sampled four new chocolate offerings found in local grocery store freezers. A couple were pool party worthy and others were ...
Published: 05/07/18