Make us your home page

Up your sandwich game with these 12 ideas

Sandwiches are the ultimate creative food outlet.

Put enough protein and vegetables and schmears between two pieces of bread, and a sammie can be suitable for any meal, a way to get ingredients to party in a way they never organically would.

Sandwiches can also be pedestrian (though sometimes, as with a classic PB and J, that's satisfying, too). But they don't have to be. We asked an expert how to take your sandwich game up a level.

Matt Bonano, owner of the sandwich and cheese shop Brooklyn South in St. Petersburg, considers almost every filling squeezed between a bread product a sandwich. Burger? Yes. Quesadilla? Sure. Crepes? Why not?

For Bonano, building a sandwich is all about having fun, being creative and mixing flavors to make something better than the sum of its parts.

"If there's any place there are no rules, it's in the sandwich world," he said.

One of his big tips for home cooks putting together their own sammies is to rely heavily on leftovers. Next time you cook salmon, double the amount of servings and repurpose it the next day between two slices of bread. (He likes to dredge his fillets in an egg wash and pan-fry them.) Meatloaf, roast chicken and large cuts of beef can be used the same way.

And if you do opt for standard sliced meat from a deli counter, try asking for a thicker portion, then grilling just until it gets some gentle grill marks.

"You'd be amazed how much more flavor you can add this way," Bonano said.

He loves to play around with sandwich recipes at his shop on Central Avenue (which just expanded from tiny to slightly-less-tiny, going from two tables to seating for 23 people), coming up with new combinations constantly. He rattles off some of his recent favorites, which range from whipped ricotta cheese with roasted fruits and honey to peanut butter and fig jam to a corned beef-Gruyere-sauerkraut rollup. His personal go-tos? Tuna salad, made with lemon juice and olive oil instead of mayonnaise and topped with crunchy veggies like fennel, celery and capers; and anything with pulled pork.

Other sandwich-making tips from Bonano: For the best results, toast your bread before applying sandwich fillings; keep the dry components of a sandwich toward the top, and make sure wet items like tomatoes and lettuce are in the middle so they don't turn either piece of bread soggy; use romaine or oak leaf lettuces, which have a nice crunch, instead of iceberg, which he refers to as "sawdust." Don't be afraid to change the composition — think fried sandwiches, open faced, pressed. Make something up. Play with your food.

"Trying to make a meal and put it between two pieces of bread — that's what I love to do," Bonano said.

Now it's your turn to build your own sandwich. Follow the pairings below for some suggestions.


Start with ... Roast beef

Add ... pumpernickel bread; red onion, tomato, lettuce; cheddar cheese; horseradish sauce.


Start with ... Turkey

Add ... sourdough bread; sprouts; provolone cheese; whole-grain mustard.


Start with ... Chicken

Add ... ciabatta bread; tomato, mozzarella cheese; balsamic vinegar; basil


Start with ... Ham

Add ... rye bread; lettuce and pickle; Swiss cheese; chipotle mayonnaise



Start with ... Tuna (canned, in water, mixed with olive oil)

Add ... whole wheat roll; arugula, cucumber, sliced olives; mayonnaise, fresh dill


Start with ... Salmon (blackened)

Add ... brioche bun; avocado, red onion, tomato; mayonnaise, lemon zest


Start with ... Cod (breaded and fried)

Add ... sourdough bread; bibb lettuce, pickles; American cheese (optional); tartar sauce


Start with ... Shrimp (deveined and sliced in half)

Add ... baguette; celery, grated sweet onion, capers; mayonnaise, hot pepper sauce



Start with ... Peanut butter

Add ... whole wheat bread; sliced banana; honey, slivered almonds, raisins


Start with ... Beets (cooked and sliced thin)

Add ... ciabatta bread; red onion, spinach; feta cheese; hummus;


Start with ... Roasted veggies (try squash, red pepper, mushrooms)

Add ... baguette; sprouts, watercress; goat cheese; pesto


Start with ... Black bean burger (store-bought or homemade)

Add ... hamburger bun; shredded carrots; cheddar cheese; ranch dressing


Up your sandwich game with these 12 ideas 05/09/16 [Last modified: Monday, May 9, 2016 12:54pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for July 30


    Tampa Bay Comic Con: Celebrity appearances today include Wallace Shawn (Princess Bride) and all are welcome to join the cosplay parade at 11:30 a.m. It runs 9 a.m.-5 p.m. Tampa Convention Center, 333 S Franklin St., Tampa. $30, 12 and younger free. (813) 274-8511;

  2. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for July 29


    Tampa Bay Comic Con: The fan convention's biggest crowd is expected today. Celebrity appearances include actors Kate Beckinsale, Rose McGowan and Michael Biehn from Terminator and Aliens. Doors open at 8 a.m. Tampa Convention Center, 333 S Franklin St., Tampa. $30-$40; 12 and younger free. (813) …

    Kate Beckinsale is appearing this weekend at Tampa Bay Comic Con. Miramax Film Corp (2009)
  3. Want to audition for Howl-O-Scream? Here's how.


    How would you like a job that has you running all night, dodging punches and earning high marks from your boss if you make someone wet their pants?

    Lindsay Weppelman, a University of South Florida biomedical science student, plays a Zombie Bride in one of Busch Gardens' open-air scare zones at Howl-O-Scream 2016.  Photo courtesy of Busch Gardens.
  4. Tampa Bay Comic Con: Live blog, and 5 things to know before heading there


    Tampa Bay Comic Con returns to the Tampa Convention Center this weekend, expected to attract more than 55,000 like-minded nerds mingling with cosplayers, celebrities, artists and sellers of comic books and collectibles.

    Surrounded by the bridesmaids dressed as Disney princesses and groomsmen dressed as Marvel superheroes, Gwen Walter of Venice, Fla., kisses her husband, Shawn Walter, also of Venice, after their wedding ceremony on day two of the 2016 Tampa Bay Comic Con in the Tampa Convention Center on August 6, 2016. The pair got engaged at Megacon 2015 and were married wearing "Nightmare Before Christmas"-themed costumes. Two different couples were married in Room 24 on the second day of the Tampa Bay Comic Con 2016. ANDRES LEIVA   |   Times