Make us your home page

When did buying eggs become so complicated?

When did buying eggs at the grocery store become so complicated?

There are white ones. And brown ones. Medium, large or extra large. Organic. Omega-3. And now the pricing scale comes with animal welfare guilt, too.

Beginning next month, Publix Super Markets will sell pasture-raised eggs for the first time. The Fresh Market made a pledge this month to sell only cage-free eggs by 2020. Tampa-based Bloomin' Brands, which operates chain restaurants like Bonefish Grill, Carrabba's Italian Grill and Outback Steakhouse, follows McDonald's, Chick-fil-A and other brands in shifting to use only cage-free eggs by 2025.

So what does this all mean, anyway?

It means eggs just aren't eggs anymore, said Darren Tristano, president of Technomic, a Chicago-based food research firm. He says we can thank the millennials for that.

Similar to what we've seen happen in the produce and meat departments, the demand for higher-quality, healthy food has raised awareness about the treatment of animals, farmers and crops.

"The issue is more around the social corporate responsibility and the sensitivity of the millennial generation," Tristano said. "Although the changes we have seen in restaurants and supermarkets are good for the welfare of chickens, the supply chain will have to adapt and the price of eggs will likely increase and stabilize over the next few years."

What that means for consumers is that we now have more choices that come at different price points.

But picking the right kind of egg can be overwhelming and confusing, admits Betsy Babcock, founder and CEO of Handsome Brook Farm, the company that will supply all 1,100-plus Publix Super Markets in six states with pasture-raised eggs beginning in April.

"Back in the day, most people had their own chickens in their back yard. But as we became a more urbanized country, commercialized farms developed to supply the needs of urban consumers," Babcock said. "People were very comfortable with that because it was a way to get very inexpensive eggs. But over the last 10 years or so, there's been this tremendous momentum from a new generation of consumers that prioritize the quality of animal welfare over price."

That's what led her to create a successful network of 75 family-owned farms, starting with her own in upstate New York, where chickens roam freely through pastures and aren't confined to cages or aviaries with concrete floors, which happens more often at commercial egg farms. That's what consumers are paying extra for — the better treatment of the chickens that lay the eggs we buy.

"Pasture-raised chickens get to forage, eat grass and bugs, which is so important to the chicken's health and welfare," Babcock said. "And the quality of the egg is exceptional."

There is some science to this. A 2010 study by researchers at Penn State University's College of Agricultural Sciences said "moving pastured hens" that eat mixed grasses and can forage have a higher concentration of omega-3 fatty acids and vitamins A and E.

But Nan Jensen, a registered dietitian with Pinellas County Cooperative Extension, said there's not a big enough difference in the quality of egg type, be it free-range eggs or pasture-raised ones, to justify the added cost.

"Is there an additional health benefit? Probably not," Jensen said. "You could very easily get more omega-3 fatty acids from other sources, like salmon, instead of paying more for a tad of a difference in an omega-3-enhanced egg. I think people buy these eggs because it makes them feel that they're making better choices, which is great, but a very personal decision."

Pasture-raised eggs also aren't regulated the same way "farm fresh" eggs are, which is the name given to the standard egg that comes from a traditional commercial farm and is sold in grocery stores, Jensen said.

"Because it's not regulated by the government, there's no way to tell where they come from, or what they eat," she said.

But that hasn't stopped the trend from gaining steam. California voters passed legislation in 2008 and 2010 that made commercial egg farms provide cage-free accommodations for egg-laying hens. But it still has a long way to go. As of 2015, organic and cage-free egg production accounted for just 8.7 percent of all egg production in the United States.

"With regards to grocery stores, I would expect to see more farm-raised marketing, higher prices, more organic and brown eggs that will allow consumers to feel better about what they cook and consume at home," Tristano said. "But it will take several years to get there, so supply continues to be an issue."

Contact Justine Griffin at Follow @SunBizGriffin.


What's in a name?

Here are the different classifications of eggs consumers can buy at the grocery store, local co-op or farmers market today.

Farm fresh eggs: This is the standard name for your average carton of eggs sold in a grocery store. Most of the time chickens are kept in cages and they aren't fed an organic diet. These usually come from large, industrial farms.

Cage-free eggs: These eggs come from chickens that technically aren't held in cages but share aviaries with other chickens in an industrial farm setting.

Free-range eggs: Chickens that lay free-range eggs have access to outside areas, usually in contained, screened pens with concrete floors or small pastures.

Omega-3 eggs: These eggs have higher levels of omega-3 fatty acids because the chickens that lay them are fed a diet that contains more flaxseed or corn feed.

Pasture-raised eggs: Pastured eggs come from chickens that spend most of their day in a pasture but have access to coops or a barn. Their diet isn't necessarily organic as they can eat grass, insects and worms. Some farms list the square footage of room each bird has at the farm on the carton.

Organic eggs: Eggs are considered organic when they come from chickens that were fed a completely organic diet. That means they're not given antibiotics unless they were sick. To be organic, the chickens must live in a cage-free or free-range environment.

Vegetarian eggs: These chickens are fed a diet free of animal by-products, but the feed isn't necessarily organic.

Certified Humane: This designation comes from a couple of third-party organizations that audit farmers for humane practices and animal welfare.

Source: U.S. Department of Agriculture

Top 10 egg-producing states

Ranked by number of hens represented in thousands as of 2015.

1. Iowa: 36,733

2. Ohio: 30,786

3. Indiana: 29,364

4. Pennsylvania: 23,863

5. Texas: 16,368

6. Michigan: 12,922

7. California: 11,821

8. Georgia: 10,462

9. Minnesota: 8,961

10. Florida: 8,784

Source: USDA

Egg prices around Tampa Bay

How do the costs of these various eggs stack up? Below is a list of prices, from a few different brands and egg types. All prices come from a Publix in St. Petersburg, and all are for a dozen eggs.

Publix brand:

Large: $1.29

Extra large: $2.29

Jumbo: $2.39

Greenwise organic (brown): $5.19


Eggland's Best:

Farm fresh, large: $2.87

Farm fresh, extra large: $3.09

Cage- free (brown): $3.89


4 Grain:

Farm fresh: Two for $6

Cage-free (brown): $3.69

Vegetarian: Two for $6


The Country Hen:

Organic, Omega-3: $3.69 for a half-dozen


When did buying eggs become so complicated? 03/21/16 [Last modified: Monday, March 21, 2016 5:13pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Plan your weekend: June 30-July 2: Vans Warped Tour, fireworks, corgi races, Guardian Con, Dan TDM


    Plan your weekend

    Vans Warped Tour: The shirtless and inked-up masses will once again descend upon St. Petersburg's Vinoy Park on Saturday to mosh and thrash to dozens of bands across seven stages. This year brings the likes of Gwar, thrash group Municipal Waste, Southern metal band Valient …

    Corgi in the grass; Dog playing the the grass;
  2. Author Randy Wayne White could open St. Pete's biggest restaurant on the pier

    Food & Dining

    ST. PETERSBURG — The story begins with Yucatan shrimp.

    St. Petersburg Deputy Mayor Kanika Tomalin, pilot Mark Futch, Boca Grande, St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Kriseman, and author and businessman Randy Wayne White,  Sanibel, exit a Maule Super Rocket seaplane after taking a fight around Tampa Bay off the St. Petersburg waterfront, 6/28/17.  White and his business partners are in negotiations with the City of St. Petersburg to build a fourth Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille on the approach to the St. Petersburg Pier with a second event space on the pier according to White. The group met near Spa Beach after a ground breaking ceremony for the new pier. "We want to have our business open by the time the pier opens," said White. Other Dr. Ford restaurants are located on Sanibel, Captiva and Ft. Myers Beach. SCOTT KEELER   |   Times
  3. Fourth of July celebrations firing off all around Hillsborough


    Apollo Beach

    Food Truck Festival celebrates fourth

  4. Channelside, downtown sight of holiday festivities


    CHANNEL DISTRICT — The City of Tampa's largest Independence Day celebration, Light Up Tampa Bay, returns to Channelside Plaza on Tuesday with fireworks, live music, entertainment, face painting and food trucks.

    Fireworks explode over Channelside during last year’s July 4th celebration.
  5. YouTube's Minecraft sensation Dan TDM brings live show to Clearwater


    Dan Middleton's YouTube channel has had more than 10 billion views since 2012.

    Dan Middleton's Dan TDM live tour is set to stop in Clearwater on Sunday. [Photo by Emily Herogian]