Make us your home page

Review: Cristino's brings coal-oven pizza, gelato and more to Ybor


Their accents are pure Brooklyn with an overlay of Mother Italy, all "aeh" vowel sounds and dropped r's. In my experience, these accents are strongly correlated with having supernatural skills when called upon to make pizza. Brothers Joe, Marco and Lenny Cristino are not anomalies in this regard. I've been a fan of their thronged Clearwater pizzeria, their flagship restaurant on Fort Harrison, since early in 2007, largely on the strengths of the pies, but the housemade gelatos heighten my ardor.

They had been considering a Cristino's Coal Oven Pizza No. 2 for some time. But where to put it? With its density of late-night noshers, historic Ybor City made sense. And coal-oven pizza itself is historic, with fans of Lombardi's on Spring Street in New York pitted for most of a century against fans of Patsy Grimaldi's in Hoboken, N.J.

Truth is, there's a lot of pizza in Ybor already, found both in casual pizzerias like Old Manhattan and New York, New York and restaurants that offer pizza as part of their lineup, such as New World, Bernini and Tampa Bay Brewing.

What makes coal-oven pizza different is heat. These ovens cook a pizza in under five minutes, the results thin-crusted, cheesy and with those charry black bubbles pocking the crust. So the brothers have that to distinguish themselves from the other neighborhood pies. But then they also have their tremendous lineup of gelatos, a broader menu of classic Italian pastas and entrees, a full bar and a wide and inviting patio in their favor.

It took them more than six months to overhaul the old Spurs and Play bars, the finished space clean, bright and fairly capacious, located right across from Game Time and Crowbar. The menu is an expanded version of what they serve in Clearwater with an array of hot and cold paninis, pastas and more ambitious fish and meat entrees added to the mix.

Still, it's about the pizza. I've never visited their hometown of Mola di Bari, Italy, but I like to think this pie is just like there. Two people can almost dispatch a large (but when has a little leftover pizza ever been a problem?). The best on my visits was the Italia ($14.99 small, $17.99 large), topped with housemade mozzarella, tomato sauce, prosciutto and a big tangle of fresh arugula, and the four-cheese version ($12.99, $15.99) with moz, ricotta, goat and gorgonzola (but it's not a white pizza, there's still tomato sauce on this one). On both, the cheese-to-sauce-to-crust ratio is excellent, although I wish the prosciutto had been less abundant and more thinly shaved because it kept flapping down my chin in a most unbecoming way.

The eggplant rollatini ($7.99) and eggplant parm ($8.99) are both comfort food doozies, the former tucking ricotta into the mix along with the tomato sauce and a mantle of molten moz. The chain Anthony's has gotten plaudits for its marinated wings given tender treatment in the coal oven and then topped with caramelized onions, but Cristino's gives them a run for their money (10 for $8.99), the finished wings moist on the inside and just crisp-edged.

Still, I think my favorite dish at the new Cristino's is the panzarotti ($8.99). A dish from Apulia (but a specialty of South Jersey), these are smallish calzones made of a softer dough, stuffed with sauce, moz, ham and basil that release a cloud of steam once pierced. Although the coal oven is the star attraction at Cristino's, these are slightly more delicious when ordered deep fried.

If you order one fried, you might be slightly less gung-ho about tacking on cannoli ($3.99) or New York cheesecake ($5.99), but surely you can manage a scoop of fruity or chocolatey gelato. The Cristino brothers will tempt you with a few little plastic spoonful samples (if they give you a spoon of stracciatella, you'll be helpless to resist).

Opened just before Christmas, service is laudably together in this newcomer. It doesn't yet have the homey bustle of the Clearwater location, but based on the strength of its pizzas, that will come.

Laura Reiley can be reached at or (727) 892-2293. Follow@lreiley on Twitter. She dines anonymously and unannounced; the Times pays all expenses.


Cristino's Coal Oven Pizza

1701 E Eighth Ave., Ybor City

(813) 248-2056

Cuisine: Pizza and Italian

Hours: 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Sunday to Thursday, until 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday

Details: Amex, MC, V, Dis.; reservations accepted; full bar

Prices: Appetizers $4.99-$8.99; pizzas $9.99-417.99; desserts $3.99-$5.99

Rating out of four stars:

Food: ★★★ Service: ★★★

Atmosphere: ★★

Overall: ★★½

Review: Cristino's brings coal-oven pizza, gelato and more to Ybor 01/13/14 [Last modified: Monday, January 13, 2014 3:06pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Jobsite goes all out, gets results with annual musical, 'The Threepenny Opera'


    TAMPA — As the house lights dimmed for the second act, burglars and pickpockets, prostitutes and scam artists weaved between the little tables of the Jaeb Theater, warning customers they'd best wind down their talking and silence their phones. This was done with a wink but the point was made. This is elitism …

    Miscreants in Jobsite Theater's The Threepenny Opera, which runs through Nov. 12, include (from left) Amy E. Gray, Jonathan Harrison, Giselle Muise, Chris Jackson, Fo'i Meleah, and Derrick Phillips. Courtesy of Jobsite Theater.
  2. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for Oct. 24


    On Your Feet: The Broadway musical follows the true story of Emilio and Gloria Estefan's journey as Cuban immigrants coming to America to becoming pop-crossover sensation Miami Sound Machine. 7:30 p.m., Carol Morsani Hall at the Straz Center for the Performing Arts, 1010 N MacInnes Place, Tampa. $45 and up. (813) …

    Alma Cuervo (far left), an Academy of the Holy Names graduate, stars in the upcoming production of "On Your Feet" at the Straz Center for the Performing Arts on Tuesday (Oct. 24). Also pictured, Claudia Yanez (as Rebecca), Christie Prades (as Gloria) and Nancy Ticotin (as Gloria Fajardo). Photo by Matthew Murphy
  3. Hip-hop artist looks to deliver music, monologues with one-woman show


    Tampa hip-hop artist and actress Dynasty takes her career into a new direction Saturday at Stageworks Theatre with her first one-woman show: A Star in Life's Clothing : Life. Love. Language. Lyrics.

    Hip-hop artist and actress Dynasty will present a one-woman show Saturday (Oct. 28) at Stageworks Theatre. Photo courtesy of @JoeyClayStudio.
  4. With volunteers as its heartbeat, annual Hillsborough County Fair grows larger


    DOVER — There's nothing else in the Tampa Bay community quite like the Hillsborough County Fair.

    Retired Tampa police officer Larry Henderson of Seffner sharpens a hewing ax used for squaring wood in the Hometown Hillsborough historical area of the fair. Beside him is a small sampling of the more than 7,000 tools he’s collected over the years.
  5. Mandarin Hide celebrates 7 years serving craft cocktails in St. Petersburg

    Bars & Spirits


    With its mascot, a mounted buffalo head named Manny, decked out in streamers and a shiny party hat, the Mandarin Hide celebrated seven years of serving cocktails on Central Avenue last Thursday night.

    Mandarin Hide’s mascot, a buffalo head named Manny, donned streamers and a shiny party hat as the bar celebrated seven years of serving cocktails last week.