Make us your home page
Instagram

Review: Olde Bay Cafe serves up fresh seafood at the Dunedin Marina

DUNEDIN

It was a perfect sunset, the kind with lurid pinks and corals and yellows slathered across streaky clouds of an approaching cold front, a row of royal palms thrown into inky relief. Everyone had their cellphones out, little rectangles duplicating the glory unsatisfactorily in the way they almost always do. It was my second visit to Walt Wickman's Olde Bay Café, and I was thoroughly smitten.

I had loved Wickman's previous restaurant, Walt's Seasonal Cuisine, which for six years was a homey spot at 1140 Main St. (which now houses Bistro Atlantis). There, Wickman developed a mid-price menu with an abiding respect for gulf species like hogfish and cobia and grouper. The economy laid the hurt on and he ended up closing shop and working for his family's fish market in an old wooden fish house at the Dunedin Marina.

Wickman's dad had purchased the Dunedin Fish Co. with a buddy of his in the early 1970s, then sold it to Wickman's uncle, Bruce Lee (not that Bruce Lee, this one is 6 feet 5 with red hair), who had the retail and wholesale fish market for 27 years. When Lee's business skewed more wholesale than retail, he sold the retail part of the operation to Sarma Reynolds. She went out of business right before the BP oil spill, and Walt took over the space in March 2011.

I don't know why it took me so long to get over there, but the launch of stone crab season — and October is National Seafood Month — got me thinking saltwater. So on a gorgeous, balmy evening with the marina spread out before us, corralled boats rocking on gentle swells, a friend of mine and I shared a half pound of stone crabs (two jumbo claws, $15), delicious in their sweet simplicity, and then the kind of honest, fresh seafood dinner that is maddeningly rare around here.

Wickman, 41, has a big following in Dunedin. On Thursday nights, a group of local runners end their exertions here on the patio with good beer prices (Wickman is a strong supporter of Florida craft beer, most drafts hovering around $5). The rest of the week, it seems like regulars, most of the staff recognizing folks and kibitzing accordingly. The servers know the menu cold, not that it's vast. But still.

Every day there are a few kinds of fresh fish (the retail side of the business lists the fresh fish on the website), which you can have as a pair of messy tacos, in a sandwich or as a dinner. First, though, spend a little time with a bowl of thick, cream-based corn shrimp chowder ($6) or a half pound of huge peel-and-eat shrimp ($11) offered cold with cocktail sauce or hot with butter (don't feel like peeling, a solid shrimp cocktail, $9, cuts out the work).

The lion's share of seating is outside on the covered patio, but step into the bar and glance around to the left and you'll see the microscopic kitchen. There's no deep fryer, no big grill. Most of the grub is steamed or pan-seared — no hardship there. On my second visit, the kitchen was out of the snappy, skinny green beans that had wowed me the previous week, so with my fresh swordfish (perfect texture, very fresh-tasting, $18) I ordered a fan of fresh avocado and a little green salad with a slightly sweet, citrus-y vinaigrette, the whole dish working synergistically with flavors and textures.

What Wickman is doing now is a little more casual and affordable (alright, and the wine list isn't as good) than it was at his previous venture. That suits the setting, the economy and Wickman himself (he and his wife have a 4-month-old baby). With culinary training at Johnson and Wales University, he certainly has the pedigree to do "fancy" food, but it's his background in the family fish business that informs what he's doing at Olde Bay Café.

Laura Reiley can be reached at lreiley@tampabay.com or (727) 892-2293. Follow @lreiley on Twitter. She dines anonymously and unannounced; the Times pays all expenses.

.review

Olde Bay Café

51 Main St., Dunedin

(727) 733-2542; oldebaycafe.com

Cuisine: Seafood

Hours: 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily (fish market is open 10 a.m. to 6 p.m.)

Details: AmEx, V, MC, Disc; no reservations; beer and wine

Prices: Fish tacos $5 to $6; sandwiches $11 to $14; dinner plates $13 to $22

Rating out of four stars:

Food: ★ ★ ★ Service: ★ ★ ★

Atmosphere: ★ ★

Overall: ★ ★ ★

Review: Olde Bay Cafe serves up fresh seafood at the Dunedin Marina 10/28/13 [Last modified: Monday, October 28, 2013 2:58pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Behind the lens: To capture an exhilarating moment, it's better to be lucky AND good

    Travel

    Editor's note: Boyzell Hosey, our Assistant Managing Editor - Photography/Multimedia, shot this image while on a family vacation in Alaska. Below is his description of the shot.

  2. Looking Back: The Ybor City Streetcar gets a new life (Dec. 27, 1991)

    Attractions

    Before World War II Tampa's public transportation needs were covered by a network of Birney streetcars, with a peak of 24 million passengers in 1926. When a local streetcar enthusiast came across a 1920's model, she contacted the Tampa Trolley Society with an eye towards restoration. That streetcar would become the part …

  3. It's possible to do Tampa Bay Comic Con on a budget. Here's how.

    Events

    One of the best parts about being a geek is going to conventions. Huge halls packed with cosplayers, celebrities, comic books, collectibles and a community of like-minded weirdos. It's paradise.

    Luis Romero of Tampa has five Spider-Man suits and has made 25 different covers and inside panels out of $3 presentation boards. 
“I spent three years of research trying to find the perfect red and blue classic Spider-Man suit,” the 37-year-old said.
  4. Plan your weekend: DJ Kitty Onesie, Taking Back Sunday, Kid Day, comic Felipe Esparza

    Events

    Fashion

    DJ Kitty Onesie: The first 15,000 ticket holders who arrive to the Rays-Rangers game Saturday will score the most questionable fashion statement of the season: a free adult-sized DJ Kitty Onesie. It's complete with a tail, a hood featuring a cat face and "DJ Kitty" written across the back. …

    An adult-sized DJ Kitty onesie will be the giveaway when the Tampa Bay Rays play the Rangers July 22.
  5. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for July 20

    Events

    Kehlani: See the Grammy-nominated R&B singer during her SweetSexySavage tour in support of her debut studio album. Ella Mai, a singer from London, opens. 7 p.m., The Orpheum, 1915 E Seventh Ave., Ybor City. $24-$29. (813) 248-9500.

    Handout for music planner on 4/6/17: Handout photo of Kehlani, performing at the Orpheum in Tampa on 4/11/17. Credit: Atlantic Records