Make us your home page

That everyday barrel-aged imperial stout? Come on, brewers

Barrel-aged imperial stouts are dead.

Of course, I say this with some irony, following another string of massively hyped barrel-aged stout releases by St. Petersburg's Cycle Brewing. Cycle, which admittedly makes extraordinarily great stouts, has released more than 10 limited-edition barrel-aged imperial stouts this year, each featuring a line at the brewery before opening (in some cases, starting at 5 a.m. or earlier) and a $100+ price tag per bottle on the secondary market within the same day of release.

So, people obviously love barrel-aged imperial stouts — or at least, they're told they love them, or they know they can flip them for a profit — but does that mean that we really need more of them?

When Goose Island first played with aging imperial stouts in bourbon barrels, it was a novel concept. The shelves of your local beer shop weren't filled with bourbon barrel-aged imperial stouts. Now, barrel-aged imperial stouts are commonplace and predictable — they've become an inhibition to creativity instead of the fruitful experimentation they started as.

Here's an experiment: Visit any brewery that's been open for, say, a year or more. Ask if they have any special, limited beers, or beers for which they do a special bottle release. I'll set the over/under for "yes" and "a barrel-aged imperial stout" at 75 percent. It's ubiquitous to the point of being boring.

Now, there is a good reason for barrel-aged imperial stouts to be given special treatment. They're expensive, time-consuming and they generally age well, making them good candidates for bottle releases. My gripe is not with barrel-aged imperial stouts, per se — it's with the thought process and motivation that goes into making them.

Here's the formula: brew up a big ol' stout; age it in a barrel that once contained a type of whiskey, rum, brandy or tequila; add a flavoring addition consisting of a sole addition or combination of cocoa, vanilla, hazelnut, coffee, coconut, chili peppers, cinnamon or lactose; have a bottle release.

If you read those instructions and salivated a little, it's okay — I did as I was typing them. There's a reason every brewery seems to want to get in on the barrel-aged stout bandwagon, and it's because these beers more often than not taste pretty good. But they're not special anymore.

What I'd like to see is a bottle release for a beer that is truly special. I want a beer that a brewer put his heart into, working out a concept that actually means something to him, no matter how subtle or how bold.

If a brewer spent a year endlessly tweaking their Belgian dubbel and finally made what they feel is the perfect, ultimate recipe, then I want a bottle of that. If a brewer wants to really take a chance and flavor their house brown ale with a variety of local ingredients, then it may or may not be good, but it will at least be interesting. If a brewer makes an imperial stout and ages it in whiskey barrels, is it because they want to, or because they think they're supposed to?

I'll never stop enjoying barrel-aged imperial stouts. I've got more than a dozen of them in the beer fridge (and yes, half of them are from Cycle). But I'm also never going to get excited about them the way I used to, when they were somewhat uncommon; not on draft and in bottles at every taproom and bottle shop in town.

If you're a brewer and you're still reading this, consider holding off on that barrel-aged stout. We have plenty. Instead, why not give us something new, something exciting? After all, that's how barrel-aged stouts got to where they are now. Maybe your innovation will be the next thing people line up at 5 a.m. and wait for.; @WordsWithJG.

That everyday barrel-aged imperial stout? Come on, brewers 06/01/16 [Last modified: Thursday, June 2, 2016 2:36pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. On the Camino de Santiago, Day 17: Think 11 miles of nothing but straight trail and open, flat fields sounds easy? Think again.


    Day 17: Villarmentero de Campos to Lédigos: 33.5 km, 10.25 hours. Total for Days 1-17 = 394 km (245 miles)

  2. Tom Sawyer with a revolver? Twain house has live 'Clue' game


    HARTFORD, Conn. — Was it Tom Sawyer in Samuel Clemens' billiard room with a revolver?

    In this July 14 photo, actor Dan Russell, left, portraying the character Arkansas from Mark Twain's book Roughing it, responds to a question from 10-year-old Emma Connell, center, of Arizona during a "Clue" tour at the Mark Twain House in Hartford, Conn. The tour allows visitors to interact with Twain characters while playing a live-action version of the board game. [AP Photo/Pat Eaton-Robb]
  3. Until this song, Alan Parsons Project stood on much higher ground


    Listening to yesterday's Keats song made me pine for more Alan Parsons Project music and today we dig deeper into their catalogue with Standing On Higher Ground.

  4. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for July 23


    Marie Antoinette: Freefall 411: A contemporary look at the historic pariah looks at Marie Antoinette through the lens of society's obsession with celebrity. Through August 13. A brief talk prior to the performance provides insight to the production. 1 p.m., show starts at 2 p.m., Freefall Theatre, 6099 Central …

    Lucas Wells as King Louis XVI, left, and Megan Rippey as Marie Antoinette in Freefall Theatre's "Marie Antoinette."
  5. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for July 22


    Snooty the Manatee's 69th Birthday Bash: Snooty, documented by Guinness World Records as the oldest known manatee in captivity, turns 69 and celebrates with children's games, art activities, cookies, drinks , interaction with Snooty the mascot and reduced price museum admission. 10 a.m., South Florida Museum, 201 …

    Snooty the manatee poses for a photo Thursday morning while three young manatees are unloaded from Lowry Park Zoo in Tampa Thursday morning at the South Florida Museum in Bradenton.
PAUL VIDELA/ 12/20/07