Make us your home page
Instagram

Taste test: chicken pot pies

Nothing says comfort food like a pot pie. It's warm and cozy and it's a full meal in one dish. Trouble is, pot pies can be high in fat, calories and sodium, so the pastry-topped dinners have become more of an occasional treat to our panelists. If they are going to indulge in a pot pie, our judges want it to be a good meal. We sampled nine brands of frozen or refrigerated chicken pies and baked each of them in the oven. Several were good and one was nearly perfect.

Serving size One cup One cup One cup
Calories 380 560 360
Fat/Fiber 21g / 4g 38g / 2g 22g / 2g
Sugars/Sodium 4g / 740mg 4g / 620mg 4g / 360mg
Carbs/Protein 38g / 11g 40g / 12g 28g / 13g

Kathy Saunders, Times correspondent

 

Product/Score

(out of 100)
Marie Callender's 97 Boston Market 67 Trader Joe's 54
Judges'

comments
Marie's chicken pot pie was the first food to make our Hall of Fame list since 2010. Judges loved the beautiful, crimped edges and the golden brown look of the crust. "It has a great ratio of crust-to-sauce-to-chicken and lots of carrots and peas," said one judge. "It's got great flavor and it's nicely seasoned." Another described this pie as "classic." "It's the best. It's got a balanced blend of meat and vegetables and lick-the-plate gravy," he said. Big chunks of white meat chicken made this pie popular. The crust was rumpled and tasty and the pie was filled with good vegetables. Seasoning gave this pie a nice flavor as well. "I like the fluted edges on the crust — it gave this a really good first impression," said one judge. "The white chicken is well-salted." Another said the chicken was the big star, describing the chunks as "plentiful and delightful." We found pot pies in the freezer and the refrigerator at the new Trader Joe's in Sarasota. Judges liked the frozen one best. "The crust cooked up a bit pale, but it was melt-in-your-mouth tasty," said one panelist. "The nice chunks of potatoes, peas, carrots and meat are delicious." Another said the peas were plump and numerous. "I think the gravy is yummy," he added.
Would

they buy?
All four judges said yes. Three of the four judges said yes. Three of the four judges said yes.
Shopping information $2.99 for a 16-ounce pie from Publix. $3.59 for a 16-ounce pie from Publix. $3.79 for a 16-ounce pie.


Also Sampled: Willow Tree ($6.79 for a 26-ounce pie from Sweetbay, 28 points); Trader Joe's refrigerated ($6.99 for a 25-ounce pie,

51 points); Priscilla's ($8.99 for a 24-ounce refrigerated pie from the Fresh Market, 39 points); Banquet (85 cents for a 7-ounce pie from Publix,

35 points); Stouffer's ($2.50 for a 10-ounce pie from Publix, 46 points); and Swanson (99 cents for a 7-ounce pie from Publix, 30 points).

Panelists: Nan Jensen, registered dietitian; Wayne Conery, manager of the R-Bar on Treasure Island; Jeff Jensen, public information officer for the city of Treasure Island; and Laura Reiley, Times food critic. All foods were tasted blind.

Send suggestions for product testing to: Taste section, Tampa Bay Times, P.O. Box 1121, St. Petersburg, FL 33731 or e-mail them to jkeeler@tampabay.com. Please put TEST SUGGESTION in the subject line. To read past Taster's Choice columns, go to food.tampabay.com.

Taste test: chicken pot pies 01/15/13 [Last modified: Thursday, January 17, 2013 8:27am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. On the Camino de Santiago, Day 19: A peregrina spends the whole day under the weather, and part of the day under the table

    Travel

    Day 19: El Burgo Ranero to Puente Villarente: 25.4 km, 7.5 hours (Total for Days 1-19 = 454 km (282 miles)

    This list pretty much sums up my day:

    Eat two bananas

    Walk 13.1 kilometers

    Nap

    Walk 6.2 kilometers

    Nap

    Eat half an apple

    Walk 6.1 kilometers

    Crash< …

  2. On the Camino de Santiago, Day 18: Despite feeling ill, this pilgrim passes the midpoint in her 500-mile journey on foot

    Travel

    Day 18: Lédigos to El Burgo Ranero: 34.3 km, 12.25 hours (Total for Days 1-18 = 428 km (266 miles)

    Today was a struggle.

  3. Actor John Heard dies at age 72

    Blogs

    John Heard, who played so many roles in the '80s but was probably best known as the dad in the Home Alone movies, has died, according to media reports. He was 72.

  4. On the Camino de Santiago, Day 17: Think 11 miles of nothing but straight trail and open, flat fields sounds easy? Think again.

    Travel

    Day 17: Villarmentero de Campos to Lédigos: 33.5 km, 10.25 hours. Total for Days 1-17 = 394 km (245 miles)

  5. Tom Sawyer with a revolver? Twain house has live 'Clue' game

    Attractions

    HARTFORD, Conn. — Was it Tom Sawyer in Samuel Clemens' billiard room with a revolver?

    In this July 14 photo, actor Dan Russell, left, portraying the character Arkansas from Mark Twain's book Roughing it, responds to a question from 10-year-old Emma Connell, center, of Arizona during a "Clue" tour at the Mark Twain House in Hartford, Conn. The tour allows visitors to interact with Twain characters while playing a live-action version of the board game. [AP Photo/Pat Eaton-Robb]