Thursday, April 19, 2018
Taste Test

Taste test: Our top picks from January to June 2017

Navigating the choices on grocery store shelves can be as difficult as trying to find a shopping cart with four working wheels. The fearless judges on our Taster's Choice panel have taken on the challenge for the past 13 years to help shoppers traverse the aisles and select the right products for their palates.

A couple of times a year, we publish a list of the top picks from our panelists. In the past six months, judges have tasted steak sauces, frozen chicken wings, salted butter and orange juice. We also purchase and taste many of the new products advertised in end-cap displays aimed at grabbing our immediate attention. More often than not, the "new" offerings don't match up to their promotions. But, once in a while, we taste a delicious new item like Whole Fruit Frozen Juice Pops and stock our freezers.

Except for new products, we compare the options of the same foods from different manufacturers. Each month, we shop for all of the brands of various products and ask our judges to tell us how the items look, taste or smell and score them on a scale of one to 100 points. We also ask if they would buy the food. Our judging is unscientific, but the comments from our panelists can help readers understand the basis for their opinions. We also provide the scores of all of the items sampled to help shoppers make their own decisions. Some of the scores are very close, although we only describe the top three picks.

We try to shop at most of the major supermarkets including Publix, Winn-Dixie and Walmart. Usually, Trader Joe's and Fresh Market are on our shopping route, along with Aldi and Target on occasion.

We are always looking for more foods to try and appreciate reader input. If you have a suggestion, please let us know by emailing [email protected]

Here are the foods that have scored the highest among our judges since January.

Kathy Saunders, Times correspondent

Comments
A taste test for drinking water? They can be surprisingly different

A taste test for drinking water? They can be surprisingly different

BROOKSVILLEThey brought it in glass carboys, in jars, in 2-liter bottles. It stacked up at the entrance to the auditorium, some of it just slightly murky but most of it crystal clear.Water. For more than 15 years the members of Region IV Florida Sect...
Published: 04/18/18
Taste test: citrus-flavored sparkling water

Taste test: citrus-flavored sparkling water

Many years ago, I took a trip to Rome and learned enough Italian to find directions and order dinner from menus. I learned very quickly that if I didn’t make it clear, I would get sparkling water rather than still water at every restaurant. My husban...
Published: 04/16/18
Taste test: cocktail sauce

Taste test: cocktail sauce

One of our judges has been perfecting her homemade cocktail sauce for nearly two years. It takes just the right balance of horseradish, ketchup, lemon, Worcestershire, hot sauce and spices. With the onset of warm afternoons and more daylight, many of...
Published: 04/09/18
Taste test: Hawaiian sweet rolls

Taste test: Hawaiian sweet rolls

Whenever I see sweet rolls at the grocery store I always take pleasure knowing I used to enjoy the originals baked on King Street in Honolulu while growing up on the islands. While nostalgic about the treats of my childhood, I am glad the soft rolls ...
Updated one month ago
Taste test: New snacks from Oreo, Smash Mallow, Hostess and more

Taste test: New snacks from Oreo, Smash Mallow, Hostess and more

Snackmakers are always trying to find new ways to help us through those afternoon sugar lows, and our judges are happy to give their snacks a try. This week, we sampled four new offerings, mostly from known brands trying out a new twist on old standb...
Updated one month ago