Make us your home page
Instagram

Taste test: pecan shortbread cookies

When researching foods believed to bring good luck in the new year, we were excited to learn that residents in Scotland used to bring baked goods, including shortbread cookies, to the homes of friends they visited on New Year's Day. That was all the inspiration we needed to start eating cookies. We found six brands of pecan shortbread cookies at local grocery stores and picked our top three favorites. Judges said they would eat these cookies even if they weren't rumored to bring good luck.

Kathy Saunders, Times correspondent

Product/Score

(out of 100)
Keebler 67Murray Sugar Free 66Great Value 62
Judges'

comments
Judges said Keebler's pecan shortbread cookie was the most "classic" of those sampled. "It's a great tasting cookie with a hint of butter flavor and just a touch of pecan," said one panelist. Another liked the very pale, almost uncooked looking appearance of the cookie. "They just seem light," she said, adding, "I like the slight hint of salt in them too." Tasters appreciated the thickness of the cookies and the good balance of sugar. "They are not too sugary," said one judge."This is definitely a winner in the pecan cookie race," said one judge. "It's light with a good nut mixture." Another liked the smaller size of the cookie, saying he especially enjoyed the strong pecan chunks. "This has a perfect, tender crumb and a good, solid crunch," said another. None of the judges realized these were sugar-free.These cookies were a bit firmer than the others, but judges said they packed plenty of flavor. "They are buttery with a nice crunch and body and a nice bit of pecan flavor," said one judge. "They are snappy," said another. One said she would love these cookies with a hot cup of coffee. Another said, "Overall, this is a good cookie, but I would need a glass of milk to soften it up."
Would

they buy?
Three of the four judges said yes.Three of the four judges said yes.Three of the four judges said yes.
Shopping information$2.65 for an 11.3-ounce package from Publix.$2.93 for a 5.5-ounce package from Walmart.$1.98 for an 11.3-ounce package from Walmart.


Also Sampled: Pamela's (3.99 for a 7.25-ounce box from Publix, 56 points); Winn-Dixie ($2 for a 13-ounce bag, 47 points);

and Publix ($2.50 for a 13-ounce pack, 32 points).

Panelists: Nan Jensen, registered dietitian; Jeff Jensen, public information officer for the city of Treasure Island; Wayne Conery, retired restaurant manager; and Liz Mergenthaler, dietetic intern. All foods were tasted blind.

Send suggestions for product testing to: Taste section, Tampa Bay Times, P.O. Box 1121, St. Petersburg, FL 33731 or email them to [email protected] Please put TEST SUGGESTION in the subject line. To read past Taster's Choice columns, go to

tampabay.com/things-to-do/food/tastetest.



Serving sizeTwo cookiesThree cookiesTwo cookies
Calories170170160
Fat/Fiber10g / 0g11g /1g9g / 0g
Sugars/Sodium7g / 110mg0g / 115mg3g / 95mg
Carbs/Protein18g / 2g18g / 2g19g / 2g

Taste test: pecan shortbread cookies 01/25/16 [Last modified: Monday, January 25, 2016 5:07pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Blake High grad Taylor Trensch lands lead role in 'Dear Evan Hansen' on Broadway

    Stage

    For those who saw Taylor Trensch grow up in Tampa, his rise from promising student to star is heartwarming and entirely predictable. In January, Trensch, 28, will be moving into the title role of Dear Evan Hansen on Broadway, one of the hottest tickets in theater.

    Taylor Trensch, a 2007 Blake High graduate, will play the title role in Broadway's Dear Evan Hansen. Courtesy of Frank Trensch.
  2. A scene from "Epiphany."
  3. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for Oct. 22

    Events

    Clearwater Jazz Holiday: The Avett Brothers: The Avett Brothers, with their blend of folk, bluegrass and rock, lead the lineup. 1:30 p.m., Coachman Park, 301 Drew St., Clearwater. $16 per day, $45 reserved, $170 VIP. (727) 461-5200.

    AUSTIN, TX - MARCH 15:  (L-R)  Joe Kwon, Bob Crawford, Seth Avett, and Scott Avett of The Avett Brothers pose for a portrait at the "May It Last: A Portrait Of The Avett Brothers" Premiere - 2017 SXSW Conference and Festivals on March 15, 2017 in Austin, Texas.  (Photo by Matt Winkelmeyer/Getty Images for SXSW)
  4. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for Oct. 21

    Events

    Conor Oberst: The Bright Eyes mastermind will be joined by opener, the Felice Brothers. 8 p.m., Capitol Theatre, 405 Cleveland St., Clearwater. $30.50-$36. (727) 791-7400.

    Handout photo of Conor Oberst, performing Oct. 21 at the State Theatre in St. Petersburg. Credit: Grandstand Media
  5. McDonald's soft serve in Florida is made with handshakes and happy cows

    Consumer

    Floridians licked nine million McDonald's vanilla cones last year.

    Calves play with a rubber toy at the Milking R Dairy in Okeechobee, FL. Owners Sutton Rucks, Jr., and his wife Kris Rucks sell their milk to SouthEast Dairies cooperative, Edward Coryn of Dairy Mix in St. Petersburg buys it, transforms it into soft-serve ice cream base, and sells it to all the McDonald's. SCOTT KEELER   |   Times