Make us your home page
Instagram

Taste test: pecan shortbread cookies

When researching foods believed to bring good luck in the new year, we were excited to learn that residents in Scotland used to bring baked goods, including shortbread cookies, to the homes of friends they visited on New Year's Day. That was all the inspiration we needed to start eating cookies. We found six brands of pecan shortbread cookies at local grocery stores and picked our top three favorites. Judges said they would eat these cookies even if they weren't rumored to bring good luck.

Kathy Saunders, Times correspondent

Product/Score

(out of 100)
Keebler 67Murray Sugar Free 66Great Value 62
Judges'

comments
Judges said Keebler's pecan shortbread cookie was the most "classic" of those sampled. "It's a great tasting cookie with a hint of butter flavor and just a touch of pecan," said one panelist. Another liked the very pale, almost uncooked looking appearance of the cookie. "They just seem light," she said, adding, "I like the slight hint of salt in them too." Tasters appreciated the thickness of the cookies and the good balance of sugar. "They are not too sugary," said one judge."This is definitely a winner in the pecan cookie race," said one judge. "It's light with a good nut mixture." Another liked the smaller size of the cookie, saying he especially enjoyed the strong pecan chunks. "This has a perfect, tender crumb and a good, solid crunch," said another. None of the judges realized these were sugar-free.These cookies were a bit firmer than the others, but judges said they packed plenty of flavor. "They are buttery with a nice crunch and body and a nice bit of pecan flavor," said one judge. "They are snappy," said another. One said she would love these cookies with a hot cup of coffee. Another said, "Overall, this is a good cookie, but I would need a glass of milk to soften it up."
Would

they buy?
Three of the four judges said yes.Three of the four judges said yes.Three of the four judges said yes.
Shopping information$2.65 for an 11.3-ounce package from Publix.$2.93 for a 5.5-ounce package from Walmart.$1.98 for an 11.3-ounce package from Walmart.


Also Sampled: Pamela's (3.99 for a 7.25-ounce box from Publix, 56 points); Winn-Dixie ($2 for a 13-ounce bag, 47 points);

and Publix ($2.50 for a 13-ounce pack, 32 points).

Panelists: Nan Jensen, registered dietitian; Jeff Jensen, public information officer for the city of Treasure Island; Wayne Conery, retired restaurant manager; and Liz Mergenthaler, dietetic intern. All foods were tasted blind.

Send suggestions for product testing to: Taste section, Tampa Bay Times, P.O. Box 1121, St. Petersburg, FL 33731 or email them to mstark@tampabay.com. Please put TEST SUGGESTION in the subject line. To read past Taster's Choice columns, go to

tampabay.com/things-to-do/food/tastetest.



Serving sizeTwo cookiesThree cookiesTwo cookies
Calories170170160
Fat/Fiber10g / 0g11g /1g9g / 0g
Sugars/Sodium7g / 110mg0g / 115mg3g / 95mg
Carbs/Protein18g / 2g18g / 2g19g / 2g

Taste test: pecan shortbread cookies 01/25/16 [Last modified: Monday, January 25, 2016 5:07pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for the week of June 26-July 2.

    Events

    Vans Warped Tour: The festival returns Saturday to St. Petersburg's Vinoy Park, featuring shock-metal icons Gwar, hardcore punks Sick Of It All, ska band Save Ferris and indie-pop group Never Shout Never ($39.50-$49.50). vanswarpedtour. …

    Crowd for the Motionless in White band at the 2014 Vans Warped Tour at Vinoy Park, Friday, July 25, 2014.  CHERIE DIEZ   |   Times
  2. Glen Campbell's wife Kim discusses challenges, guilt caregivers of Alzheimer's patients, others face

    Life Times

    If there's one thing Kim Campbell would change about caregiving for Alzheimer's patients, it's the attitude so many of us have toward transferring a loved one from home to a long-term care facility. According to Campbell, it's often the most kind, loving decision you can make. It's not a sign of failure, but one of …

    Kim Campbell, wife of country music legend Glen Campbell, is acknowledged by those attending the free event where she shared the story of her personal journey with Alzheimer???‚??„?s disease and the struggles she faced caring for her husband on Friday (5/26/17) at the Suncoast Hospice's Empath Health Service Center in Clearwater. Empath Choices for Care, a member of Empath Health, and Arden Courts Memory Care hosted the free event where Kim shared her story to help others understand the early stages, how the disease changes lives, the challenges families face and the role of caregiver.
  3. What happened when I took my dad to a Pitbull concert

    Music & Concerts

    TAMPA — "So, you know how you like Pitbull?" I asked my dad. "We can see him."

    Selfie of Divya Kumar and Anand Kumar at Pitbull/Enrique Iglesias concert.
  4. Tampa City Council votes to accept travel invitation from Cuban ambassador

    Blogs

    The invitation came to Tampa City Council chairwoman Yvonne Yolie Capin in a June 9 letter from Cuban ambassador to the United States José Ramón Cabañas Rodriguez.

    The Tampa City Council voted 6-0, with Frank Reddick out of the room, to respond to a travel invitation from Cuban ambassador to the United States José Ramón Cabañas Rodriguez.
  5. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for June 25

    Events

    St. Pete Pride Festival: The daytime festival covers Central Avenue's Grand Central District with more than 350 vendors, multiple stages, live music, art and food. 9 a.m., Grand Central District, 2429 Central Ave., St. Petersburg. Free. (727) 342-0084.

    Kristen Whalen poses for a photo before the start of the St. Pete Pride Parade in St. Petersburg last year. It's that time of year again, so check with us for your planning purposes. [LUIS SANTANA  |   Times (2016)]