Make us your home page

Taste test: Recap of the foods we tasted so far in 2016

When our panelists for the Taster's Choice column award foods more than 90 out of 100 points, the items are featured in our Hall of Fame. In recent years, the hall has been pretty empty. This year is no different.

Related News/Archive

Each year, we run two columns listing the favorite foods tasted the previous six months. Below is a list of the "winners" from our tastings for the first half of 2016. Since January, our panelists haven't been thrilled with many foods, but they have given some pretty high scores to a few unsuspecting entries. They loved Indian River Select grapefruit juice (89 points); Krusteaz Double Chocolate muffins made from a mix (83 points); coconut oil from the Fresh Market (81 points); Gefen and Wild Selections water-packed tuna (87 and 82 points, respectively); Lay's Kettle chips (84 points); and Arnold hot dog buns (86 points).

We started our Taster's Column in 2004 just before the Fourth of July. Our first column was a hot dog-tasting competition.

We try to taste foods that are popular among our readers as well as those lesser-known items lining local grocery store shelves. Our mission is to help shoppers navigate through the many product choices offered by food manufacturers. In February, we tried 18 brands of pizza sauce — so you don't have to.

We also like to try new foods for readers who might not want to spend their own money on an unknown treat or staple. One recommendation from the panelists this spring was the Breyers Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream. It tasted like a Reese's peanut butter candy cup in the form of ice cream, and judges loved it.

We try to find healthier options when available. We prepared 10 frozen beef burgers for one column this May. And we followed up with a column on frozen veggie burgers.

In general, we shop at all major grocery stores including Publix, Winn-Dixie, Walmart and Target. Sometimes we get to Aldi, the Fresh Market and Trader Joe's.

And remember, we are comparing the same foods. Readers often ask us to sample fresh fruit, for example. But an apple purchased at a store one day would not taste the same as an apple purchased at another store. It depends on when it was picked, how it was shipped and the ripeness of the fruit.

We always are open to suggestions. If you have ideas for our judges, email them to

Grapefruit JuicesIndian River Select89
Publix Premium74

Pecan ShortbreadKeebler67
Murray Sugar Free66
Great Value 62

Market Pantry47

Chocolate MuffinsKrusteaz Double Chocolate83
Martha White Gluten Free Chocolate Chocolate Chip50
Martha White Chocolate Chocolate Chip43

Pizza SauceRao's Homemade68
Sugo de Pomidoro61
Del Grosso52
Ragu Traditional50

Frozen Lobster RavioliJoseph's Gourmet72
Trader Joe's59
New York Ravioli & Pasta Co.55

Coconut OilThe Fresh Market81
Carrington Farms73

Hard Taco ShellsGreat Value77
Taco Bell65
Trader Joe's59

Frozen French Fries from Fast-Food ChainsSteak n Shake Thin & Crispy Seasoned Fries67
Red Robin Seasoned Steak Fries55
Checkers & Rally's54

Strawberry Gelatin DessertGreat Value77
Kool-Aid 49

Water-packed TunaGefen87
Wild Selections82

New England Clam ChowderPublix45
Progresso Traditional 42
Trader Joe's33

Frozen Veggie BurgersMorning Star Farms75
Dr. Praeger's California Veggie Burger57
Publix GreenWise Garden Style Veggie Burger50

Frozen Beef BurgersFatburger71
Sam's Choice65
Great Value56

Kettle ChipsLay's84

Wasabi SauceSeminole66
Silver Spring63

Bacon BitsHormel64
Great Value41
Oscar Mayer41

Hot Dog BunsArnold86

Taste test: Recap of the foods we tasted so far in 2016 07/18/16 [Last modified: Monday, July 18, 2016 10:16am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Taco and Beer Fiesta set for St. Pete, followed by the Ooze and Booze Fest

    Food & Dining

    The Gulf to Bay Food Truck association recently announced a trio of events for mobile comfort food lovers.

    The big a-- nachos are tortilla chips topped with pulled pork, chili, cheese sauce, salsa, chopped jalenpenos, feta cheese and cilantro sour cream from Maggie on the Move. [Gulf to Bay Food Truck Association]
  2. Ryan Reynolds and Samuel L. Jackson can't keep 'The Hitman's Bodyguard' on-target


    The Hitman's Bodyguard is an assault tank on semi-automatic pilot, spraying jokes and bullets with only the ammo consistently hitting its targets. The irresistible teaming of Ryan Reynolds and Samuel L. Jackson might be even funnier if they missed once in a while.

    Samuel L. Jackson plays a master assassin testifying against a dictator, and Ryan Reynolds plays a bodyguard tasked with keeping him alive.
  3. 8 things to do in Tampa Bay on Aug. 17


    Clearwater Threshers: vs. St. Lucie Mets: For "Taps and Tacos" night, 16 local craft beers on tap near the Tijuana Flats kiosk, located on the concourse along the third-base line. 7 p.m., Spectrum Field, 601 N Old Coachman Road, Clearwater. $6-$10. (727) 467-4457.

    St. Lucie Mets outfielder Tim Tebow during the Mets at Threshers game at Spectrum Field on Monday, August 14, 2017, in Clearwater, Fla. Monday night was Tim Tebow's 30th Birthday Party celebration.
  4. What's new in theaters: 'The Hitman's Bodyguard,' 'Logan Lucky,' 'Wind River'




    Loving the trailer for The Hitman's Bodyguard (R) poking fun at quotes from reviewers prone to phrases like "It's a roller coaster ride!" for better chances to see their names in TV ads.

    Salma Hayek and Samuel L. Jackson in The Hitman’s Bodyguard.
  5. Howard Jones and the legend of Jed


    Howard Jones is all over the place. After headlining the Retro Futura in America this summer he will return back to the West and participate in 80s In The Sand. How did Howard get so good at bouncing right back? Well he had some practice in the '80s with the song Bounce Right Back.