Make us your home page

Taste test: Tartar sauce

Fish is on the dinner menu at our house at least twice a week. If we are lucky, it's fresh off my husband's boat from a successful fishing trip. Even if it's not, being surrounded by water makes fish familiar fare in Florida. If possible, I blend my own sauce to slather on fish sandwiches or fish filets. But it's always nice to have handy a bottle of tartar sauce just in case pickles, capers and fresh mayonnaise aren't in the fridge. Our judges tasted 10 different brands of storebought tartar sauce in search of a few options for their pantries.

Kathy Saunders, Times correspondent


(out of 100)
Hellmann's 79Trader Joe's 55Louisiana Fish Fry 42

This popular mayonnaise maker produced a thick and attractive sauce that appealed to all of our panelists. "It's red flecked, with pickles, and tangy with a little heat," said one judge. She also appreciated the "nice balance of sweet and creamy." Another said he liked the "good consistency and tasteful mayo base" of the sauce. The relish in this sauce also seemed very fresh to our judges. "I can taste this on a fried grouper sandwich with a giant slice of cheese," said one panelist."This white mayo was thick with big dots of green and orange," said one judge who liked the zesty flavor. "I like the hint of sweetness with the tang," she added. "I would serve this on fried or baked seafood," said another judge. "It's a great, all-around relish."Golden hues and thin texture set this tartar sauce apart from some of the competition. "I like the pleasant mayo-to-pickle balance," said one judge. "It's homemade tasting and eggy in a good way." Another said he liked the sauce but would add more relish to give it a thicker consistency. "I would spread a thin layer of this on a piece of fish before I put it in the oven," he added. "It's got a nice, tart flavor that would give the dish a little kick."

they buy?
All four judges said yes.Two of the four judges said yes.Two of the four judges said yes.
Shopping information$2.49 for an 11.5-ounce bottle from Publix.$1.99 for an 8-ounce jar.$2.99 for a 10.5-ounce bottle from Publix.

Also Sampled: Kraft ($2.39 for a 12-ounce bottle from Publix, 39 points); the Fresh Market ($2.49 for an 8-ounce bottle, 26 points); House Autry ($2.39 for a 10.25-ounce bottle from Winn-Dixie, 15 points); and Thomas Fish Camp ($2.49 for a 12-ounce bottle from the Fresh Market, 14 points); Bennetts ($3.59 for a 10.5-ounce bottle from Publix, 11 points).

Panelists: Jeff Jensen, public information officer for the city of Treasure Island; Wayne Conery, retired restaurant manager; Jill Dunn, Realtor for Yes-Homes; and Laura Reiley, Times food critic. All foods were tasted blind.

Send suggestions for product testing to: Taste section, Tampa Bay Times, P.O. Box 1121, St. Petersburg, FL 33731 or email them to Please put TEST SUGGESTION in the subject line. To read past Taster's Choice columns, go to

Serving size2 tablespoons2 tablespoons2 tablespoons
Fat/Fiber6g / 0g14g / 0g14g / 0g
Sugars/Sodium2g / 290mg1g / 270mg3g / 160mg
Carbs/Protein4g / 0g2g / 0g3g / 0g

Taste test: Tartar sauce 08/01/16 [Last modified: Monday, August 1, 2016 12:11pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Three ways to top toast anytime


    We're getting better and better at putting Things on Toast, a culinary category that's hard to beat for its versatility. Some spreads applied thin can boost flavor while creating a protective layer between crisp surface and squishy toppings. Good loaves of unsliced bread allow us to control the degree of thickness …

    Grilled Corn and Scallion Toast With Cilantro Crema
  2. St. Pete Coffee Tours offer a glimpse into the world of local craft coffee

    Food & Dining

    ST. PETERSBURG — What started as a small gathering of friends is now a growing business that has people hyped about St. Petersburg specialty coffee.

    At Craft Kafe, Jason Waits explains Kyoto-style drip coffee during a St. Pete Coffee Tour in May.
  3. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for Tuesday May 30


    Finding Neverland: The hit Broadway show follows the story behind playwright J.M. Barrie as he struggles to find inspiration to create Peter Pan, until he meets four young brothers and their beautiful widowed mother. 7:30 p.m., Carol Morsani Hall at the Straz Center for the Performing Arts, 1010 N MacInnes Place, …

    Mitchell Wray, Jordan Cole, Finn Faulconer and Ben Krieger as the Llewelyn Davies Boys in the National Tour of Finding Neverland. Photo by Carol Rosegg.
  4. Big rents and changing tastes drive dives off St. Pete's 600 block

    Music & Concerts

    ST. PETERSBURG — Kendra Marolf was behind the lobby bar of the State Theatre, pouring vodka sodas for a weeknight crowd packed tight for Bishop Briggs, the latest alternative artist to sell out her club.

    Sam Picciano, 25, left, of Tampa and Molly Cord 24, Palm Harbor shop for record albums for a friend at Daddy Kool Records located on the 600 block of Central Avenue in St. Petersburg, Florida on Saturday, May 20, 2017. OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times
  5. Restaurant review: Features Gastropub in Riverview is fine as movie theater fare, but unimpressive otherwise

    Food & Dining

    Movies aren't exactly dying. Despite all the sturm und drang of predictions that Netflix and streaming videos would kill the cinema, global box office receipts hit $38.6 billion in 2016, a 1 percent gain over the previous year. But that doesn't mean going to the cinema is precisely what it was a generation …

    Soft pretzels are displayed with a beer at the Features Gastropub in the Riverview 14 GDX  theater in Gibsonton, Fla. on Thursday, May 25, 2017.   The 5,900-square-foot Features Gastropub open in the . This element of the project is the brainchild of Philadelphia chef Brian Duffy, who appears frequently on NBC's The Today Show and the Spike TV show Bar Rescue