Make us your home page
Instagram

Taster's Choice: Year in review

Like many shoppers, our taste panelists plead guilty when it comes to picking certain brands at the grocery store out of habit or familiarity. That's one reason we spent several weeks this year sampling products we tend to take for granted. We stirred nine packets of taco seasoning mix into sizzling ground beef, we prepared several boxes of stuffing, and we finished the year tasting canned black-eyed peas.

Since the Taster's Choice column made its debut 11 years ago, judges have always been pleasantly surprised to discover how well store brands often do among the competition. Our years of gastronomical research have made it clear that grocery shoppers do not have to pay more to get good quality staples.

Each week, we shop at all of the local grocery stores, including Publix, Winn-Dixie, Walmart, Fresh Market and Trader Joe's. Sometimes we check for products at GFS Marketplace. Our goal is to help shoppers make informed choices.

Our panelists taste as many brands of each product as we can find. We look for foods with enough choices for a proper comparison. Each season, we also try look for healthy options, although that quest becomes increasingly challenging as food manufacturers roll out snack foods as fast as we can devour a bag of chips.

Twice a year, we publish a list of the foods our judges favored in the tastings of the past six months. We love to get suggestions from readers, so feel free to send those to kathy@kathysaunders.com. Remember, though, we are comparing the same foods. Readers often ask us to sample fresh fruit, for example. But an apple purchased at a store one day would not taste the same as an apple purchased at another store. It depends on when it was picked, how it was shipped and the ripeness of the fruit.

Our judges rank the foods on a scale of 1 to 100. We try to taste at least five of every food. If we have more than 12 of one item, we sometimes split the tasting into two sessions to make it easier on our palates. If we taste only four items, we list all four scoring results. Below is a list of the top three picks from our samplings for the last six months of 2015.

Kathy Saunders, Times correspondent

July
Flavored MayonnaiseProductScore
Trader Joe's Wasabi Mayonnaise81
McCormick Mayonnaise With Lime Juice76
Just Mayo Chipotle71

Vanilla Ice Cream ConesProductScore
Publix70
Nestle64
Market Pantry60

August
Frozen or Refrigerated Macaroni & CheeseProductScore
Momma B's84
Joe's Diner78
Marie Callender's 66

Black Forest Ham (from area delis)ProductScore
Boar's Head (purchased at Mazzaro's Italian Market in St. Petersburg)52
The Fresh Market48
Winn-Dixie39

September
Chocolate CroissantsProductScore
Delifrance65
Trader Joe's65
Maison du Croissant 46
7 Days43

Dark Chocolate BarsProductScore
Valrhona63
Chocolove57
Godiva56

October
Banana

Bread Mixes
ProductScore
Pillsbury Quick Bread72
Chiquita53
Simple Mills42

GnocchiProductScore
Gia Russa65
Alessi64
Flora Fine Foods58

November
Kalamata OlivesProductScore
Lindsay62
Mezzetta61
Vigo53

Refrigerated Mashed PotatoesProductScore
Publix83
Bob Evans82
Reser's Main Street Bistro63

Boxed Stuffing MixesProductScore
Betty Crocker 86
Great Value67
Kraft Stove Top54

December
Chicken Noodle

Soups
ProductScore
My Goodness Soup Chicken and Orzo70
Campbell's Homestyle Chicken Noodle54
Campbell's Slow Kettle Style Roasted Chicken Noodle52

Dark

Hot Cocoa Mixes
ProductScore
Starbucks Double Chocolate63
Swiss Miss Dark Chocolate

Sensation
59
Land O'Lakes Chocolate Supreme53

CANNED

Black-Eyed Peas
ProductScore
Hanover59
Publix56
Great Value46

Taster's Choice: Year in review 01/04/16 [Last modified: Monday, January 4, 2016 4:49pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for Sept. 24

    Events

    Zac Brown Band: The country, folk and Southern rockers embark on the "Welcome Home" tour in support of the album. 7 p.m., MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre at the Florida State Fairgrounds, 4802 U.S. 301 N, Tampa. $27.50-$77.50. (813) 740-2446.

    Handout photo of the Zac Brown Band, performing at the MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre in Tampa on 9/24/17. Credit: Shore Fire Media
  2. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for Sept. 23

    Events

    Smithsonian Museum Day Live: Museums across the nation partner with the Smithsonian to offer free admission for one day. Among them are Florida Holocaust Museum, Leepa-Rattner Museum of Art in Tarpon Springs.Cracker Country in Tampa, Ringling Museum of Art. Note: Dalí Museum is free for Pinellas County …

    The Museum of Fine Arts in St. Petersburg is among the museums participating in the Smithsonian's Museum Day Live, offering free admission. (LANCE ROTHSTEIN   |  Special to the Times)
  3. Tampa Repertory's 'Flying' soars in some places, sputters in others

    Stage

    TAMPA — Tampa Repertory Theatre has always insisted on putting on plays that mean something. Several shows over the last couple of years have zeroed in on the social and cultural baggage that comes with being female (The Children's Hour, Silent Sky and Grounded come to mind). None of those …

    The Southeastern premiere of Flying, Sheila Cowley's play at Tampa Repertory Theatre about veterans of the Women's Air Force Service Pilots, includes (from left) Holly Marie Weber, Rosemary Orlando, and Becca McCoy. Photo by Megan Lamasney.
  4. After 22 years, it's last call for beloved Ybor venue New World Brewery

    Music & Concerts

    YBOR CITY — Steve Bird spreads his tools across a patio table. He has awnings to unbolt and paraphernalia to unpry, from the busted Bop City neon by the stage to the Simpsons "El Duffo o Muerte" mural in the courtyard. He'll uproot a fountain and dismantle a roof and attempt to keep his bar intact. The …

    Various decor and memorabilia fill the walls and shelves at New World Brewery in Ybor City.
Long time music venue and hangout New World Brewery in Ybor City will be closing it's doors and moving locations. Patrons enjoy one of the last events before New World Brewery changes its location to Busch Blvd in Tampa.  [Photo Luis Santana | Times]