Tuesday, May 22, 2018
Things To Do

Oscars: Best Picture nominees have more than a kernel of truth

Re-creating truth in movies has consequences.

Like a $25 million lawsuit, filed by someone claiming to be damaged by his depiction in The Wolf of Wall Street. Or the real-life Captain Phillips knowing a movie makes him appear more heroic than he was.

Sometimes the result of repackaging truth — accurately or not — is Hollywood's most coveted prize, an Academy Award for best picture.

Odds are better than ever this year that a cinematic version of a true story will win the Oscar. Nine finalists, and six are ripped from headlines, history or memoirs. Twice as many as in recent years when Argo and The King's Speech, each based on fact, took the top prize.

Whether tonight's winner is based on, inspired by or plays loose with the truth like American Hustle, movies remain unreliable eyewitnesses, portraying the way things really happened only for viewers wanting to believe.

And, yes, I've heard someone ask if Gravity is a true story.

"People see (a movie) and automatically believe that's true," said Kevin Lang, founder of HistoryVsHollywood.com, dedicated to sorting out fact and fiction in popular movies. "But I'm finding that a lot of people really are curious, and question things."

"If more people are picking these films apart, it's going to put more pressure on filmmakers to get it right, or not veer too far away from the story. Especially the ones vying for Academy Awards, because that can come back to bite them."

Lang pointed to Denzel Washington's failed Oscar bid for The Hurricane, when the movie's depiction of Ruben "Hurricane" Carter's murder conviction was slammed for inaccuracies. Last year, Zero Dark Thirty's chances of winning the best picture Oscar were dashed when its depictions of interrogation torture were contradicted by CIA and military personnel. There is no such thing as bad publicity in Hollywood, unless it's during the home stretch of Oscar season.

This year's fact-based nominees made it through the balloting process without any "pants on fire" accusations that could sway voters. Lang's website does point out interesting deviations from sources including Solomon Northup's and Jordan Belfort's books, and the media unraveling of Abscam, Somali pirates, Ron Woodroof's AIDS crusade and Philomena Lee's search for her stolen son.

Lang rates 12 Years a Slave and The Wolf of Wall Street as tonight's most credible best picture nominees, the latter surprisingly so.

"After seeing all the outrageous things this guy does, all the sex and drugs, you think there's no way that could all happen in a life," he said. "Then I researched and found out most of that stuff really happened."

Not the dwarf tossing, though. Or the chimpanzee. But the sunken yacht, swallowed goldfish and helicopter mishap are apparently true. One notable detour from fact doesn't involve debauchery but how Belfort (Leonardo DiCaprio) meets his future partner, the pseudonymed Donnie Azoff (Jonah Hill). In the movie it's a chance encounter in a diner, with Belfort flashing a Jaguar and fat pay stub. In reality, Belfort reportedly met the man's wife first, offering his seat on a city bus, his ride before his rise.

Lang said 12 Years a Slave is tough to verify since Northup's memoir is all researchers have to work with. "When you look at the book compared to the film, a lot is very accurate," he said.

The discrepancies include Northup fathering two children when in reality there were three, and portraying Benedict Cumberbatch's slave owner as much less forgiving than Northup described. A scene involving a slave ship sailor murdering a prisoner is apparently screenwriter John Ridley invoking creative license. One searing scene — when Patsey (Lupita Nyong'o) begs Solomon (Chiwetel Ejiofor) to kill her — may be mistaken due to a misread sentence in Northup's book that seems to imply Mistress Epps (Sarah Paulson) urged Solomon to kill Patsey, a rival for her husband's attention.

Like 12 Years a Slave, Philomena tells a story for which researchable records barely exist. The movie hews closely to journalist Martin Sixsmith's account of assisting Philomena, with Steve Coogan and Judi Dench in the roles. Detractors so far have been defensive since an Irish Catholic abbey selling illegitimate children in the 1950s is the villain of the piece.

Dallas Buyers Club also leans heavily upon one writer's take on a subject. Screenwriter Craig Borten collected 20 hours of interviews with Woodroof, who in the 1980s smuggled pharmaceuticals unapproved at the time for use by HIV and AIDS patients. Borten told Slate.com that he and co-writer Melisa Wallack needed to streamline Woodroof's story, including composites of characters that became people played by Jared Leto and Jennifer Garner. The movie also makes Woodroof into a rodeo rider, when in fact he was just a fan.

The most contentious Oscar finalist has been Captain Phillips, with lawsuits filed by crew members of the cargo ship Maersk Alabama, claiming Capt. Richard Phillips, played by Tom Hanks, disregarded warnings to sail at least 600 miles off the coast of Somalia. The ship cruised within 300 miles of the coast, increasing the danger of pirates. Phillips publicly denied the movie's depiction of offering himself to be shot or taken hostage, instead of his crew.

Appropriately enough, the nominee most far from the truth is the con artist yarn American Hustle, changing names to protect the guilty. The outline of the FBI's Abscam sting of the late 1970s and early '80s, coaxing politicians into bribery scandals, is exaggerated and played for laughs.

"History replays itself as farce," Lang said. And Hollywood again makes truth just another prop.

Steve Persall can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 893-8365. Follow @StevePersall on Twitter.

     
 
Comments
All Children’s CEO: Not telling parents about needle left behind was “complete failure”

All Children’s CEO: Not telling parents about needle left behind was “complete failure”

Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital halted most pediatric heart surgeries last year, the hospital’s top administrator said Tuesday, providing new details about its response to problems within its Heart Institute.The only operations curr...
Updated: 1 hour ago
SZA will not appear at tonight’s Kendrick Lamar Championship Tour

SZA will not appear at tonight’s Kendrick Lamar Championship Tour

Singer SZA will not perform at Kendrick Lamar's Championship Tour at the MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre in Tampa Tuesday, organizers announced shortly before the concert. Lamar's Top Dawg Entertainment label posted the news on Twitter. The Gra...
Updated: 3 hours ago
The Dirty Heads talk backyard barbecues, shedding the ‘reggae rock’ label and more

The Dirty Heads talk backyard barbecues, shedding the ‘reggae rock’ label and more

It's hard to say, exactly, how many 97X events the Dirty Heads have played at this point. There were three Next Big Things, at least, plus an acoustic Green Room performance or two.And if you want to talk about shows in St. Petersburg, forget about i...
Updated: 7 hours ago
The Dirty Heads talk backyard barbecues, shedding the 'reggae rock' label and more

The Dirty Heads talk backyard barbecues, shedding the 'reggae rock' label and more

It's hard to say, exactly, how many 97X events the Dirty Heads have played at this point. There were three Next Big Things, at least, plus an acoustic Green Room performance or two.
Updated: 9 hours ago
Despite hurdles, Ballet Nacional de Cuba returns to Tampa after 15 years

Despite hurdles, Ballet Nacional de Cuba returns to Tampa after 15 years

For decades, the reputation of the Ballet de Nacional de Cuba has never dropped below excellent.
Updated: 9 hours ago
Cress Williams of 'Black Lightning' talks Season 2, being recognized as a superhero before MegaCon Orlando

Cress Williams of 'Black Lightning' talks Season 2, being recognized as a superhero before MegaCon Orlando

No matter what Cress Williams does the rest of his acting career, he'll always be remembered as the first to play Black Lightning.
Updated: 9 hours ago
Despite Walt Disney's wishes, you can now buy alcohol at every Magic Kingdom restaurant

Despite Walt Disney's wishes, you can now buy alcohol at every Magic Kingdom restaurant

Well, you did it millennials. As of this month, every sit-down restaurant in the Magic Kingdom now serves alcohol.
Updated: 9 hours ago
8 ways to get on the water in Tampa Bay if you don't own a boat

8 ways to get on the water in Tampa Bay if you don't own a boat

According to the old wisdom, the two happiest days of a boater’s life are the day they buy a boat and the day they sell it. There’s also an argument to be made for the day when a generous friend buys one. Boating, from the sun to the bre...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Top things to do in Tampa Bay for May 23

Top things to do in Tampa Bay for May 23

Ballet Nacional de Cuba: Making its first return since 2003, the acclaimed company founded nearly 60 years ago by prima ballerina Alicia Alonso survived the Cuban revolution and the subsequent decline in the economy. Ballet remains a principal export...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Cress Williams of ‘Black Lightning’ talks Season 2, being recognized as a superhero before MegaCon Orlando

Cress Williams of ‘Black Lightning’ talks Season 2, being recognized as a superhero before MegaCon Orlando

No matter what Cress Williams does the rest of his acting career, he’ll always be remembered as the first to play Black Lightning.The 47-year-old actor with roles on ER, Grey’s Anatomy and Friday Night Lights is now that face of a DC comics franchise...
Published: 05/22/18