Thursday, April 26, 2018
Things To Do

Review: 'Great Gatsby' more grand than bland

The '20s roar until they're hoarse in Baz Luhrmann's splashy, slap-dashy adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, a movie to divide moviegoers into camps of swooners and groaners, and occasionally make them switch sides.

At times wildly propulsive and stodgily inert at others, Luhrmann's version of the classic novel is everything both his admirers and critics expect and more, for better and worse. It is aggressively bold, taking the excesses and conspicuous consumptions of Fitzgerald's characters to their illogical ends. If a scene calls for sparks, Lurhmann provides fireworks; if drama demands depth, he presents it in 3-D.

As a stylist, no one surpasses this Aussie auteur for audacity; he never met an anachronism he didn't like, including a Spotify soundtrack (Jay-Z, Florence + the Machine) for an antenna radio era. As an emotionalist, however, Luhrmann requires the grand delusions of lovesick fools — Romeo, a Parisian poet in Moulin Rouge or Jay Gatsby — to express the heart beneath the pulse. Nothing subtle, plenty gained.

Certainly nothing is subtle about Jay Gatsby, not his lavish reality or the mystique built around him by gossips in a tony Long Island community in 1922. His mansion is the scene of weekly bacchanals where no one needs invitations for everyone in high society to attend. Gatsby is a phantom at his own affairs, waiting for the one guest to arrive for whom everything has been planned: Daisy Buchanan, a former lover now married though Gatsby hopes not for long.

Leonardo DiCaprio plays Gatsby, and the role doesn't always fit as well as his suits. He gets a movie star entrance to die for, a killer tux and smile backed by fireworks and Gershwin. DiCaprio's confidence makes even Gatsby's upper crust accent and verbal tic of calling everyone "old sport" feel charming. Yet when Gatsby's confidence is shaken, so is DiCaprio's performance; the wrong insecurity creeps in, of trying too hard to move an audience. But he is far more effective than Robert Redford in the role 39 years ago.

At the same time, Carey Mulligan is the Daisy that Fitzgerald fans waited through other adaptations to see, willing to be as self-centered and undeserving of Gatsby's obsession as the character demands. Mulligan's voice is suitably "full of money" but not like Mia Farrow's sing-song parody of flapper-speak in 1974. This Daisy is a gold digger; no matter how rich she is it's never enough, which is the immoral to Fitzgerald's story.

The weakest link among performances — as it typically is with Gatsby adaptations — is Tobey Maguire's Nick Carraway, saddled as he is with snobbish explanations of motivations and back stories. The script devises an excuse for Nick's narration that Fitzgerald didn't, couched in therapy sessions in a sanitarium. The character still delivers some of Fitzgerald's best lines, but Maguire in the movie is, as Nick describes himself, "within and without, simultaneously."

When the beat slows, so do Luhrmann's movies, and that's about 45 minutes before The Great Gatsby ends. Luhrmann and co-writer Craig Pearce are remarkably faithful to the book but should also be impudent enough to rewrite parts of this Great American Novel, especially when the love triangle tightens inside a Manhattan hotel room, strangling Luhrmann's knack for making the ordinary interesting. One final, wild night on the town, stretching the confrontation over more drinks and frenetic dancing, might preserve momentum.

Yet as a purely sensory experience at the movies you're hard-pressed to find anything more dazzling than the first 90 minutes of The Great Gatsby, when Luhrmann's riotous amusements make anything possible. Musical eras overlap like Nick's superimposed handwriting, smash zooms and silky dissolves force off-kilter perspectives, colors are garish and even 3-D can't contain the overflow of energy from the screen. That's when this Gatsby is truly great, which shouldn't be forgotten after it turns ordinary.

Steve Persall can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 893-8365. Follow him @StevePersall on Twitter.

 
Comments
FEC plans crackdown on zombie campaigns

FEC plans crackdown on zombie campaigns

The federal agency that oversees elections has announced a crackdown on former lawmakers who continue to spend leftover campaign donations long after leaving office.The Federal Election Commission announced Wednesday that it will start scrutinizing t...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Big Boi’s concert at the Ritz Ybor in Tampa: Canceled

Big Boi’s concert at the Ritz Ybor in Tampa: Canceled

Well, this news is colder than a polar bear's toenails.Outkast rapper Big Boi has canceled his May 24 concert at the Ritz Ybor "due to unforeseen scheduling," according to a tweet from the venue. No further explanation was given, but refunds will be ...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Wonder Woman 2 to take place in .. the ’80s!

Wonder Woman 2 to take place in .. the ’80s!

After the success of the Wonder Woman big-screen reboot in 2017, there was little doubt a sequel would be coming soon. But here's the fun twist: Wonder Woman 2 will be set in the 1980s!Screenrant.com says director Patty Jenkins confirmed the next mov...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Enjoy a beach day in Mahahual, minutes from the cruise port in Costa Maya, Mexico

Enjoy a beach day in Mahahual, minutes from the cruise port in Costa Maya, Mexico

A trip to the Caribbean conjures up visions of swaying palms and a watercolor palette of blues, greens and shades in between. Just 10 minutes or so from the port of Costa Maya, Mexico, a fixture on most western Caribbean cruise itineraries, lies an i...
Updated: 7 hours ago
5 things to do under $5 this week

5 things to do under $5 this week

Looking for free or cheap fun this weekend?
Updated: 8 hours ago
Top things to do in Tampa Bay for April 27

Top things to do in Tampa Bay for April 27

Waitress: The Broadway hit musical based on Adrienne Shelley’s film follows Jenna, a waitress stuck in a bad marriage and a small town. 8 p.m., Carol Morsani Hall at the Straz Center for the Performing Arts, 1010 N MacInnes Place, Tampa. $45-$128. (8...
Updated: 8 hours ago
This week's best concerts: Flo Rida, Queens of the Stone Age, Bay 2 Beach Festival and more

This week's best concerts: Flo Rida, Queens of the Stone Age, Bay 2 Beach Festival and more

Want to see some live music?
Updated: 8 hours ago
5 things to do under $5: 10,000 Maniacs, Dragon Boat Races, Pepper Fest

5 things to do under $5: 10,000 Maniacs, Dragon Boat Races, Pepper Fest

Here's your free and cheap ideas for the weekend.
Updated: 9 hours ago
Less Than Zero series coming to Hulu

Less Than Zero series coming to Hulu

Of all the '80s flicks to be reborn as TV series, nobody had put any money on Less Than Zero to make the cut. And yet, that's the news: Hulu is developing a TV series based on the 1987 film that starred Andrew McCarthy, Robert Downey Jr., J...
Updated: 10 hours ago
The Royal Guardsmen talk about ‘Snoopy vs. The Red Baron,’ reuniting 50 years after their breakthrough and more

The Royal Guardsmen talk about ‘Snoopy vs. The Red Baron,’ reuniting 50 years after their breakthrough and more

It's midmorning at the pub, not far from the backyard patio where it all began, and the old guys from the old band are reminiscing on the old days over cream of mushroom soup."When we were kids," Billy Taylor said, "all you wanted was a hot shower ev...
Updated: 10 hours ago