Thursday, April 26, 2018
Music News, Concert Reviews

Review: Florida Orchestra plays Tchaikovsky's 'Pathétique' with great passion

Tchaikovsky's Symphony No. 6 is easy to mess up. It sounds sloppy when performed by a subpar orchestra. The melodic themes can seem rambling if not played with care and expression.

Although the French title Pathétique (generally meaning "pathetic") has been used for the symphony since it was published, the Russian equivalent of the title would actually be translated to "passionate" or "emotional." And a passionate performance is exactly what the audience at the Straz Center heard on Friday when the Florida Orchestra played this masterpiece.

Every movement of the symphony was brought to life in fascinating color. Every melody, especially the popular one that opens the second movement, had shape and momentum. Guest conductor Cristian Macelaru was positively entertaining to watch. And it was obvious that he cared very deeply about the work.

Before they played the symphony, he talked about the audience's role. The third movement is actually the most exciting of the four and ends with great thrill. Most audiences are tempted to clap, but Macelaru pleaded this once to resist in order to experience the work as Tchaikovsky intended — with a moment of silence before the lamentoso finale. He then followed that up with a dramatic cutoff gesture for the third movement that seemed more for the audience than for the orchestra.

Tchaikovsky was more proud of this symphony than any of his other works. Even though he seemed happy in all of his correspondences at the time, he was dealing with a significant amount of stress. Several of his close friends died while writing the symphony and he had a pending legal case against him on a charge of homosexuality. This combined with the fact that he died nine days after its premiere has lead many musicologists to believe the symphony was a musical suicide note, even though he most likely died from cholera contracted by drinking a glass of water that he supposedly didn't know was unboiled.

Before intermission, all of the deep emotions conveyed by the orchestra's performance of the Tchaikovsky were simply not present. The neoclassical Stravinsky ballet Jeu de Cartes was thought-provoking and incredibly precise, though, especially under the baton of Macelaru.

The Concierto Barroco for guitar and orchestra by Roberto Sierra was about the same, except perhaps lacking a bit of precision. Guitar virtuoso Manuel Barrueco was brilliant on his part, but the piece itself is not a grand showpiece. It comes across in dreamlike episodes, some sounding contemporary and some like they were written in the Baroque period. And if the goal is to reimagine the story of the novel on which it was based, then that was certainly achieved by the performance.

Comments
Review: Foo Fighters drop an all-night rock revival on Tampa’s MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre

Review: Foo Fighters drop an all-night rock revival on Tampa’s MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre

Dave Grohl charged out like a pre-tween hopped up on Code Red, sprinting from corner to corner of the stage, all kinds of jacked up to preach the high holy gospel of RAWK."You know why I'm here? Do you know why I came here tonight?" the Foo Fighters ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Royal Guardsmen return, Snoopy in tow, 50 years after Florida’s first pop hit

Royal Guardsmen return, Snoopy in tow, 50 years after Florida’s first pop hit

OCALAIt’s midmorning at the pub, not far from the backyard patio where it all began, and the old guys from the old band are reminiscing on the old days over cream of mushroom soup."When we were kids," Billy Taylor said, "all you wanted was a hot show...
Updated: 6 hours ago
Fleetwood Mac coming to Amalie Arena in Tampa

Fleetwood Mac coming to Amalie Arena in Tampa

Before Christine McVie and Lindsey Buckingham came to Ruth Eckerd Hall last fall, Buckingham said Fleetwood Mac was mapping out a tour for 2018 and beyond. And he fully expected to be a part of it."Fleetwood Mac is absolutely a dysfunctional family, ...
Published: 04/25/18
This week’s best concerts: Flo Rida, Queens of the Stone Age, Bay 2 Beach Festival and more

This week’s best concerts: Flo Rida, Queens of the Stone Age, Bay 2 Beach Festival and more

ROCK ROYALTY: Queens of the Stone AgeWhen Queens of the Stone Age singer Josh Homme got in trouble recently for kicking a photographer at a show, local fans might have seen it coming. During a gig here in 2014, a fan got up on stage and tried to gree...
Published: 04/25/18
Review: Yanni returns to ‘Acropolis’ for a passionate night at Ruth Eckerd Hall in Clearwater

Review: Yanni returns to ‘Acropolis’ for a passionate night at Ruth Eckerd Hall in Clearwater

I have to confess: I was not prepared to see Yanni walk on stage Tuesday night at Ruth Eckerd Hall.I mean, of course I knew he would be there. It was a Yanni concert, after all. Can't throw a Yanni concert without Yanni.But if you've seen photos of Y...
Published: 04/25/18
Hernando Symphony Orchestra ends season with ‘Kaleidoscope’ concert

Hernando Symphony Orchestra ends season with ‘Kaleidoscope’ concert

BROOKSVILLE — Some are full of bluster and bravado, while others are sentimental and romantic.And when the Hernando Symphony Orchestra closes out its season this weekend with its Kaleidoscope concert, audiences will witness the wide range of talents ...
Published: 04/24/18
SoundBytes: Tracy Morgan, Nipsey Hussle, Jimmie Vaughan and more

SoundBytes: Tracy Morgan, Nipsey Hussle, Jimmie Vaughan and more

— Tracy Morgan is coming to the Capitol Theatre in Clearwater. He'll perform there on Nov. 2. Tickets are $49.50 and up. Click here.— Former Kiss guitarist Ace Frehley is returning to the Capitol Theatre on Nov. 9. Tickets are $35 and up....
Published: 04/23/18
Janelle Monae coming to Jannus Live in St. Petersburg

Janelle Monae coming to Jannus Live in St. Petersburg

Janelle Monae's Dirty Computer, which drops this Friday, is one of most music watchers' most anticipated albums of 2018.Looks like the R&B star will follow it with one of the year's most anticipated tours.Monae's Dirty Computer Tour will take her to ...
Published: 04/23/18
J Balvin coming to the USF Sun Dome in Tampa

J Balvin coming to the USF Sun Dome in Tampa

J Balvin just had himself a mighty fine Coachella.On Saturday, he popped out on stage with Beyonce to perform their hit single Mi Gente. And on Sunday, he showed up for Cardi B's set to perform I Like It with Bad Bunny.Pretty soon, Tampa can get a ta...
Published: 04/23/18
Janet Jackson coming to the MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre in Tampa

Janet Jackson coming to the MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre in Tampa

A mere three years after her last trip to Tampa, Janet Jackson is on her way back.The pop icon announced a new slate of tour dates for her State of the World Tour, which has been dormant since December, and Tampa's one two Florida cities (the other i...
Published: 04/23/18