Tuesday, December 12, 2017
Tampa Bay Music & Shows

Review: Florida Orchestra plays Tchaikovsky's 'Pathétique' with great passion

Tchaikovsky's Symphony No. 6 is easy to mess up. It sounds sloppy when performed by a subpar orchestra. The melodic themes can seem rambling if not played with care and expression.

Although the French title Pathétique (generally meaning "pathetic") has been used for the symphony since it was published, the Russian equivalent of the title would actually be translated to "passionate" or "emotional." And a passionate performance is exactly what the audience at the Straz Center heard on Friday when the Florida Orchestra played this masterpiece.

Every movement of the symphony was brought to life in fascinating color. Every melody, especially the popular one that opens the second movement, had shape and momentum. Guest conductor Cristian Macelaru was positively entertaining to watch. And it was obvious that he cared very deeply about the work.

Before they played the symphony, he talked about the audience's role. The third movement is actually the most exciting of the four and ends with great thrill. Most audiences are tempted to clap, but Macelaru pleaded this once to resist in order to experience the work as Tchaikovsky intended — with a moment of silence before the lamentoso finale. He then followed that up with a dramatic cutoff gesture for the third movement that seemed more for the audience than for the orchestra.

Tchaikovsky was more proud of this symphony than any of his other works. Even though he seemed happy in all of his correspondences at the time, he was dealing with a significant amount of stress. Several of his close friends died while writing the symphony and he had a pending legal case against him on a charge of homosexuality. This combined with the fact that he died nine days after its premiere has lead many musicologists to believe the symphony was a musical suicide note, even though he most likely died from cholera contracted by drinking a glass of water that he supposedly didn't know was unboiled.

Before intermission, all of the deep emotions conveyed by the orchestra's performance of the Tchaikovsky were simply not present. The neoclassical Stravinsky ballet Jeu de Cartes was thought-provoking and incredibly precise, though, especially under the baton of Macelaru.

The Concierto Barroco for guitar and orchestra by Roberto Sierra was about the same, except perhaps lacking a bit of precision. Guitar virtuoso Manuel Barrueco was brilliant on his part, but the piece itself is not a grand showpiece. It comes across in dreamlike episodes, some sounding contemporary and some like they were written in the Baroque period. And if the goal is to reimagine the story of the novel on which it was based, then that was certainly achieved by the performance.

Comments
Mary J. Blige coming to Amalie Arena in Tampa

Mary J. Blige coming to Amalie Arena in Tampa

An icon of modern R&B is coming to town to warm your winter right up.Mary J. Blige, the Queen of Hip-Hop Soul, is coming to Amalie Arena in Tampa on Feb. 21, part of her ongoing Strength of a Woman Tour. Tickets start at $47.25 and go on sale at 10 a...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Kesha, Macklemore coming to the MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre in Tampa

Kesha, Macklemore coming to the MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre in Tampa

Brush your teeth with Jack Daniel's and put on your grandpa's hand-me-downs, because Kesha and Macklemore are teaming up for a summer tour.The pop outcasts-turned-heroes will hit the road for a 30-city trek that includes a stop at Tampa's MidFlorida ...
Published: 12/11/17
Dead and Company’s Orlando concert, postponed after John Mayer’s appendectomy, rescheduled for Feb. 27

Dead and Company’s Orlando concert, postponed after John Mayer’s appendectomy, rescheduled for Feb. 27

John Mayer is on the mend, and Dead and Company are making plans to get back on the road.The Grateful Dead-honoring supergroup has rescheduled several concerts postponed by Mayer's emergency appendectomy this week, including a Dec. 7 date at Orlando'...
Published: 12/08/17
Clearwater Sea-Blues lineup: Kenny Wayne Shepherd, ZZ Ward, more coming to Coachman Park

Clearwater Sea-Blues lineup: Kenny Wayne Shepherd, ZZ Ward, more coming to Coachman Park

A handful of artists are about to put the blues back into the Clearwater Sea-Blues Festival.Blues guitarists Kenny Wayne Shepherd and Ana Popovic will headline the 2018 Sea-Blue Festival, Feb. 24-25 at Coachman Park in Clearwater. Fiery singers ZZ Wa...
Published: 12/08/17
SoundBytes: Senses Fail, Scott Bradlee’s Postmodern Jukebox, YoungBoy Never Broke Again and more

SoundBytes: Senses Fail, Scott Bradlee’s Postmodern Jukebox, YoungBoy Never Broke Again and more

— Senses Fail is coming to the Orpheum in Tampa on March 6, along with Reggie and the Full Effect, Have Mercy and Household. Tickets are $16 and up. Click here.— Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox will perform at the Tampa Theatre on Apri...
Published: 12/07/17
Updated: 12/08/17
The Band Perry drops out of Florida Strawberry Festival

The Band Perry drops out of Florida Strawberry Festival

Tickets went on sale for the 2018 Florida Strawberry Festival Thursday, but if you were hoping to see the Band Perry, think twice before you purchase.The band has canceled its March 3 performance at the Strawberry Festival, according to organizers. N...
Published: 12/07/17
This week’s best Tampa Bay concerts: 98 Degrees, David Crosby, Petula Clark

This week’s best Tampa Bay concerts: 98 Degrees, David Crosby, Petula Clark

PACKAGE DELIVERY: 98 Degrees Oh, the weather outside is far from frightful — that’s one of the perks of December in Florida, you know. But inside the Mahaffey Theater on Friday, it’ll be 98 Degrees and steamy. The Brothers Lachey w...
Published: 12/06/17
Updated: 12/08/17
Dead and Company postpone Thursday’s Orlando concert after John Mayer’s emergency appendectomy

Dead and Company postpone Thursday’s Orlando concert after John Mayer’s emergency appendectomy

If you had to guess which member of Dead and Company might have an emergency medical issue that would force the postponement of several shows, you might guess Bob Weir, right? Or maybe Mickey Hart or Bill Kreutzmann?Nope. It's John Mayer.The guitaris...
Published: 12/06/17
Jason Mraz coming to the Mahaffey Theater in St. Petersburg

Jason Mraz coming to the Mahaffey Theater in St. Petersburg

Jason Mraz is coming from the Great White Way to the Sunshine City.The pop singer-songwriter will embark on a solo acoustic tour next spring that includes several stops in Florida — including a March 17 date at the Mahaffey Theater in St. Peter...
Published: 12/06/17
Photos: Lil Pump gets his ‘Gucci Gang’ lit at the Ritz Ybor in Tampa

Photos: Lil Pump gets his ‘Gucci Gang’ lit at the Ritz Ybor in Tampa

Teenage Miami rap phenomenon Lil Pump packed the Ritz Ybor last week, bringing hundreds of members of his Gucci Gang to Tampa.It was an all-too-brief show — he went on late and left early, spending only a short time on stage — but the Tim...
Published: 12/05/17