Make us your home page

Review: Engaging premise goes to waste in American Stage's 'Informed Consent'

Juliana Davis, center, turns in a solid performance as Jillian, the only character invested with any kind of nuance.

Joey Clay Photography

Juliana Davis, center, turns in a solid performance as Jillian, the only character invested with any kind of nuance.


From its unveiling nearly a year ago as part of the current American Stage season, Informed Consent showed promise.

This one-act would dive into the historical tension between science and religion. Through the lens of a landmark court case pitting an American Indian tribe against a university over genetic research, the play would explore power and myth-making, ask hard questions and challenge audiences to come up with their own answers.

That is not exactly what happens here. Instead, this production delivers a thin, didactic screed that despite its best efforts fails to engage the mind. Playwright Deborah Zoe Laufer raises interesting questions, or starts to, then turns the narrative over to ill-advised hodgepodge of devices, including nameless ensemble cast members who loom out of the shadows to chant genome sequences, an apparent reference to the quasi-religious attachment we have with science.

This kind of self-infatuated argumentation, with which the story begins and ends, is just one of many examples showing why Informed Consent disappoints, content with allowing mostly threadbare characters to make pronouncements that are supposed to represent actual people. If there is a contrast worth noting, it is the gulf between what this play promises and what it delivers.

The production directed by Benjamin T. Ismail has strengths. Jerid Fox's sterile set hints at a lives dominated by the laboratory, up to and including a suspended round tube at ceiling level that looks like a microscope lens. Juliana Davis turns in a solid performance as Jillian, the only character invested with any kind of nuance. The same cannot be said of the rest of the cast, although Melanie Souza as Jillian's mother and the others all have tolerable moments.

Jillian is the driving force, a genetic anthropologist who persuades her boss to let her study a tribe of Havasupai Indians who show high rates of diabetes. Her mother had died of early-onset Alzheimer's, and her motives in promoting genetic research are both academic and personal.

She arrives at their home of the canyon dwelling tribe by helicopter, ready to draw blood that might unlock their secrets. But it's a struggle. A spokeswoman for the tribe, Arella (Dana Segal), allows the testing to go forward only reluctantly.

"We believe our blood is sacred," she tells the scientist. Apparently there's no time to get into why. The researcher responds with incredulity. So begins a tug-of-war between the methods of myth and science, both of which also carry different notions of history. Is it in our genes or what our elders told us?

As in the 2004 civil case between the tribe and the Arizona Board of Regents, the diabetes study yielded little useful information. Researchers later submitted DNA from their subjects for unrelated studies delving into schizophrenia, migration and inbreeding — all taboo topics. The tribe argued that such unauthorized use of their DNA violated their civil rights and confidentiality.

Running parallel is Jillian's onset of Alzheimer's, something she had predicted and from which she would like to shield her own daughter. At the height of her crisis she has an epiphany, suddenly deciding that "stories of our family" are just as valuable as genetic research, and, "We have our own stories to tell."

Like most other aspects of Informed Consent, this monumental development is more stated than felt. The audience rose to its feet at the end and cheered, including a few who had dozed or slept through parts of it.

Contact Andrew Meacham at [email protected] or (727) 892-2248. Follow @torch437.

.If you go

Informed Consent

American Stage's play runs through April 9 at the Raymond James Theatre, 163 Third St. N, St. Petersburg. $39 and up. (727) 823-7529.

Review: Engaging premise goes to waste in American Stage's 'Informed Consent' 03/21/17 [Last modified: Tuesday, March 21, 2017 5:51pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Josbite goes all out, gets results with annual musical, 'The Threepenny Opera'


    TAMPA — As the house lights dimmed for the second act, burglars and pickpockets, prostitutes and scam artists weaved between the little tables of the Jaeb Theater, warning customers they'd best wind down their talking and silence their phones. This was done with a wink but the point was made. This is elitism …

    Miscreants in Jobsite Theater's The Threepenny Opera, which runs through Nov. 12, include (from left) Amy E. Gray, Jonathan Harrison, Giselle Muise, Chris Jackson, Fo'i Meleah, and Derrick Phillips. Courtesy of Jobsite Theater.
  2. Top things to do in Tampa Bay for Oct. 24


    On Your Feet: The Broadway musical follows the true story of Emilio and Gloria Estefan's journey as Cuban immigrants coming to America to becoming pop-crossover sensation Miami Sound Machine. 7:30 p.m., Carol Morsani Hall at the Straz Center for the Performing Arts, 1010 N MacInnes Place, Tampa. $45 and up. (813) …

    Alma Cuervo (far left), an Academy of the Holy Names graduate, stars in the upcoming production of "On Your Feet" at the Straz Center for the Performing Arts on Tuesday (Oct. 24). Also pictured, Claudia Yanez (as Rebecca), Christie Prades (as Gloria) and Nancy Ticotin (as Gloria Fajardo). Photo by Matthew Murphy
  3. Hip-hop artist looks to deliver music, monologues with one-woman show


    Tampa hip-hop artist and actress Dynasty takes her career into a new direction Saturday at Stageworks Theatre with her first one-woman show: A Star in Life's Clothing : Life. Love. Language. Lyrics.

    Hip-hop artist and actress Dynasty will present a one-woman show Saturday (Oct. 28) at Stageworks Theatre. Photo courtesy of @JoeyClayStudio.
  4. With volunteers as its heartbeat, annual Hillsborough County Fair grows larger


    DOVER — There's nothing else in the Tampa Bay community quite like the Hillsborough County Fair.

    Retired Tampa police officer Larry Henderson of Seffner sharpens a hewing ax used for squaring wood in the Hometown Hillsborough historical area of the fair. Beside him is a small sampling of the more than 7,000 tools he’s collected over the years.
  5. Mandarin Hide celebrates 7 years serving craft cocktails in St. Petersburg

    Bars & Spirits


    With its mascot, a mounted buffalo head named Manny, decked out in streamers and a shiny party hat, the Mandarin Hide celebrated seven years of serving cocktails on Central Avenue last Thursday night.

    Mandarin Hide’s mascot, a buffalo head named Manny, donned streamers and a shiny party hat as the bar celebrated seven years of serving cocktails last week.