Make us your home page
Instagram

Review: Plodding adaptation of 'The Great Gatsby' is a shadow of the real thing

The leading roles are cast wisely, but without immediate conflicts or the novelist guiding the story, actors are left to make up the difference.

Courtesy of Stageworks Theatre

The leading roles are cast wisely, but without immediate conflicts or the novelist guiding the story, actors are left to make up the difference.

TAMPA — Like any other adaptation of a great novel, getting The Great Gatsby to the stage requires ambition and steel nerves.

Stageworks Theatre, which has never shied away from daunting tasks, has picked up the mantle with Simon Levy's adaptation of the F. Scott Fitzgerald classic. Levy, a Los Angeles playwright and director, was a finalist for a PEN Literary Award for the play, which opened in Seattle in 2006.

By definition, a stage version can only hope to reflect the original. It cannot supplant anything. Stageworks has produced a serious show that spares no effort. Director Noelle Monroe cast the leading roles wisely and mastered artful transitions that unfold like dance sequences, as one scene blends into the next.

It's a little slow at times, particularly toward the end of the first act. Without any immediate conflicts to resolve or the comfort of the novelist guiding the story along, actors are left to make up the difference.

Some take on that impossible task in inspiring ways. Dahlia Legault, who has appeared on AMC's The Walking Dead, does so as Jordan Baker, a charmingly jaded socialite and the love interest of Nick Carraway. Lauren Buglioli plays Daisy, Nick's vulnerable cousin and eternal flame of his neighbor, the enigmatic Jay Gatsby, with nuance and depth.

As in the book, the story is narrated by Carraway, an aspiring businessman who has taken his nonjudgmental Midwestern sensibilities to New York City in the Jazz Age. Nathan Jokela provides an even tempered presence as Nick, who also connects segments of the play with soliloquies from the novel. Serving up Fitzgerald's exquisite phrasing reminds the audience of why the work is considered a masterpiece, and also how any attempt to replace it inevitably falls short.

Which brings us back to this show. Levy's adaptation is the first to be given exclusive rights by the Fitzgerald estate, and is the only stage version allowed to be produced in the United States and Canada. One wonders if this permission came about because of the playwright's faithfulness to the text.

But successful adaptations often come by taking risks, interpreting the original in some dramatically different way. Being true to a novel that soared with descriptive passages — while only introducing that unfiltered voice in narrative snippets — makes a theater's job harder. The math doesn't work out.

Aspects of this production also seem incongruous. Jamie Jones plays Tom Buchanan, Daisy's abusive husband and the story's major engine of conflict, with all of the requisite snobbery and short-tempered sense of entitlement. Still, the menace in certain scenes seems more stated than felt. For example, a fight scene between Tom and Gatsby makes one wonder whether anybody involved with this production has ever seen a real fight, let alone been in one.

Still, R. James Faurote makes for a smooth Gatsby, whose extravagance intrigues and later somewhat repels. Overall, the script stringently pares down the plot, which could either reflect discipline or indifference, not unlike a comic book abridgment. Gatsby devotees might be curious to check out the show, understanding it's a pale shadow of the work that inspired it.

Contact Andrew Meacham at [email protected] or (727) 892-2248. Follow @torch437.

. If you go

The Great Gatsby

Runs 8 p.m. Fridays, 3 and 8 p.m. Saturdays and 3 p.m. Sundays through Dec. 18 at Stageworks Theatre, 1120 E Kennedy Blvd., Tampa. $30. (813) 374-2416. stageworkstheatre.org.

Review: Plodding adaptation of 'The Great Gatsby' is a shadow of the real thing 12/06/16 [Last modified: Thursday, December 8, 2016 4:44pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Gourmet food fight between top chefs raises $200,000

    News

    ST. PETERSBURG — The chefs came armed with their secret ingredients — pork rinds, truffle butter, pork bellies.

    (From left to right) Chefs Ryan Mitchell, Michael Buttacavoli, Ted Dorsey and Matthew Brennan compete during Tampa Bay Food Fight at The Coliseum in St. Petersburg on Tuesday. The event features chefs from the Tampa Bay area and benefitted Metropolitan Ministries. EVE EDELHEIT   |   Times
  2. Channing Tatum drops out of Weinstein Co. movie about sex abuse

    Movies

    LOS ANGELES — Channing Tatum is no longer developing a film with the Weinstein Co. that dealt with a boy dealing with the aftermath of sexual abuse.

    Channing Tatum at the premiere of "Comrade Detective" in Los Angeles. Tatum is no longer developing a film with the Weinstein Company about a boy dealing with the aftermath of sexual abuse. (Associated Press)
  3. Plan your weekend: Clearwater Jazz Holiday, Faith Hill and Tim McGraw, MarineQuest, Florida Orchestra pops in the park, rodeo

    Events

    Plan your weekend

    Concerts

    Music weekend: Clearwater Jazz Holiday, Faith Hill and Tim McGraw and Bruno Mars all in one weekend? We have a playlist of a weekend coming up. Thursday brings Bruno's sold-out 24K Magic World Tour to Amalie Arena. The next day brings the country power …

    Bill Clark and Danelle Dasouqi admire the chalk art on the side walk during the final day of the three day Chalk Art Festival in Clearwater Beach. JIM REED/STAFF
  4. Ticket window: Harry Potter movie concert, Andrea Bocelli, Ed Sheeran, Iliza Shlesinger, Alan Parsons Project on sale this week

    Music & Concerts

    Tickets for the following events go on sale this week:

    British singer Ed Sheeran performs during the Italian State RAI TV program "Che Tempo che Fa", in Milan, Italy on March 12, 2017, 
AP Photo/Antonio Calanni
  5. 13 things to do in Tampa Bay on Oct. 19

    Events

    Bruno Mars: Get your Uptown Funk on at the Grammy-winning pop star's 24K Magic World Tour. 8 p.m., Amalie Arena, 401 Channelside Drive, Tampa. $41.25-$131.25. (813) 301-2500.

    LOS ANGELES, CA - JUNE 25:  Bruno Mars performs onstage at 2017 BET Awards at Microsoft Theater on June 25, 2017 in Los Angeles, California.  (Photo by Paras Griffin/Getty Images for BET)