1. Archive

Judge to let blast survivors watch trial

Bowing to the wishes of Congress, a judge reversed himself Tuesday and allowed survivors and relatives to watch the Oklahoma City bombing trial even if they plan to testify in the penalty phase.

U.S. District Judge Richard Matsch had barred survivors and victims' relatives who want to testify at a possible death-penalty sentencing hearing or provide statements about the bombing's impact on their lives.

In his reversal, Matsch said it is clear under a law signed Thursday by President Clinton that Congress intended those victims to be allowed to attend the trial of Timothy McVeigh, which begins Monday.

"I'm elated," said Delores Watson, whose grandson, P. J. Allen, was severely injured in the blast. "The more I know about the trial helps me with the healing process."

Later Tuesday, McVeigh's lawyers continued to pursue a trial delay, this time telling a federal appeals court that prosecutors have refused to hand over crucial evidence.

"Our patience is exhausted," said attorney Stephen Jones, citing numerous government documents about right-wing groups, previous plots against the government and the possibility of foreign involvement in the bombing.

Prosecutors would not comment but Matsch has denied many similar requests, saying it's not the duty of the government to provide Jones with a defense.

In his ruling Tuesday, Matsch said any further debate on the issue would delay the trial. The judge also said he could protect McVeigh's rights by allowing victims to be questioned outside the jury's presence.

Prosecutors already have chosen the victim-impact witnesses they intend to call if there is a sentencing phase to the trial. Their number is believed to be between one and two dozen.

Matsch said his ruling also extends to those victims and relatives who want to watch the trial on closed-circuit television in Oklahoma City. The historic closed-circuit provision also was passed by Congress last year.

"It's a great deal for the victims. . . . It's really a load off those people's backs," said Roy Sells, who had given up the opportunity to testify so he could watch pretrial hearings.

His wife, Lee, was among the 168 people killed April 19, 1995, when a truck bomb ripped through the Oklahoma City federal building. More than 500 others were injured.

Matsch had barred the victim-witnesses from his courtroom last June out of fear their testimony might be tainted by watching the trial. An appeal failed, so victims' relatives turned to Congress.

The Senate and House passed the bill last week, and Clinton's signature effectively overturned Matsch's ruling.