An assortment of variations of baklava, including saraigli, kataifi, flogera and traditional baklava, are available at Hellas Bakery in Tarpon Springs.

Tampa Bay’s 6 most iconic bakeries

These sweet spots boast everything from Greek baklava to Cuban bread to doughnuts.
An assortment of variations of baklava, including saraigli, kataifi, flogera and traditional baklava, are available at Hellas Bakery in Tarpon Springs. [ DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD | TImes ]
These sweet spots boast everything from Greek baklava to Cuban bread to doughnuts.
Published Jan. 30, 2020
Updated Feb. 2, 2020

Tampa Bay’s bakery scene is booming: We’ve now got pastry popups opening brick-and-mortar businesses, gluten-free bakers shaking up the dough game and top-notch sourdough loaves and baguettes coming from Ybor City’s Jamison B. Breadhouse Bakes. The area boasts a rich historic bakery tradition, one that’s strongly rooted in our immigrant past. From Greek baklava in Tarpon Springs to beloved Tampa Cuban bread manufacturers, here are six of the most iconic Tampa Bay bakeries.

Related: Tampa Bay's 25 most iconic restaurants

La Segunda Central Bakery

La Segunda Central Bakery has been around for more than 100 years.
La Segunda Central Bakery has been around for more than 100 years. [ Times (2015) ]

It can be daunting to be billed as the world’s largest producer of Cuban bread, but there is simply no place that does the tradition proud like Ybor’s trusty La Segunda. Opened in 1915, the family-run bakery is now four generations in the making, still churning out tens of thousands of the signature crusty loaves imprinted with palmetto fronds. The flagship Ybor location doesn’t have seating, but that hasn’t stopped crowds from queuing up daily for their cafe con leches and flaky guava and cheese turnovers.

2512 N 15th St., Ybor City; (813) 248-1531; lasegundabakery.com

Wright’s Gourmet House

Wright's Gourmet House in Tampa is the place to go for custom cakes.
Wright's Gourmet House in Tampa is the place to go for custom cakes. [ Times (2013) ]

Husband and wife Pete and Marjorie Wright opened what was then just a 500-square-foot coffee and dessert spot back in 1963. Since then, the popular bakery, deli and catering operation on S Dale Mabry Highway has gone through several expansions and renovations, including tripling the seating and creating a more efficient deli counter queue, which has helped speed up operations. The bakery offers signature “bucket bread” (round and quartered) sandwiches, including the Beef Martini, loaded with rare slices of tender roast beef, tangy mushrooms, crispy bacon and a schmear of garlic and herb butter. And if you’ve celebrated a birthday in the Tampa Bay area, you have probably encountered a Wright’s cake. The bakery is a go-to spot for house-made, three-layer round and sheet cakes, offered in more than a dozen flavors.

1200 S Dale Mabry Highway, Tampa; (813) 253-3838; wrightsgourmet.com

Alessi

Alessi has everything from specialty cakes to pastries.
Alessi has everything from specialty cakes to pastries. [ Times (2012) ]

The large seafoam green sign beckons from blocks away, but not as strongly as the rows of tiered cakes and confections displayed in the window of this iconic West Tampa bakery. Italian immigrant Nicolo Alessi launched the operation in 1912 and the business is still family-owned, four generations later. It’s the place to go for specialty cakes, European-style confections (think Italian tea cookies and tiramisu) and all manner of pastries, like the sweet and flaky sfogiatelle and cronuts. And if you haven’t tried the creme brulee bread pudding yet, well, I highly recommend getting around to that very soon.

2909 W Cypress St., Tampa; (813) 879-4544; alessibakery.com

Mazzaro’s Italian Market

Various freshly baked breads are offered at Mazzaro's Italian Market.
Various freshly baked breads are offered at Mazzaro's Italian Market. [ SCOTT KEELER | Tampa Bay Times ]

Opened in 1993, Mazzaro’s stocks fine European food products and gourmet goodies as far as the eye can see, in a yawning warehouselike space in St. Petersburg. While it can be easy to get stuck ogling the goods in the sprawling wine and cheese room, or at the always busy sandwich counter, the bakery shouldn’t be skipped. Stocked with Italian-style breads like ciabatta, semolina and focaccia, and sweet treats like eclairs, cannoli cakes and pignoli cookies, there are plenty of yeasty treats to love.

2909 22nd Ave. N, St. Petersburg; (727) 321-2400; mazzarosmarket.com

Hellas

Loaves of tsoureki (Greek Easter) sweet breads are displayed at Hellas Bakery in Tarpon Springs.
Loaves of tsoureki (Greek Easter) sweet breads are displayed at Hellas Bakery in Tarpon Springs. [ DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD | Tampa Bay Times ]

Since 1970, this restaurant, wholesaler and retail bakery has been an anchor in the Tarpon Springs Greek community. It’s the place to go for sesame-studded koulouri, spinach-filled spanakopita and tsoureki (traditional Greek Easter bread). For the sweet tooths out there, don’t skip the honey-laced baklava, melomakarona (spiced honey cookies) and cream-filled napoleons.

785 Dodecanese Blvd., Tarpon Springs; (727) 943-2400; hellasbakery.com

Pane Rustica

In the two decades since Kevin and Karyn Kruszewski opened this South Tampa bakery, a lot has changed: The business has moved, expanded and blossomed into a lively restaurant that’s seemingly packed at all times of the day. At nighttime, you can still belly up to the bar over a cucumber gimlet and an excellent burger, but the business’ original focus hasn’t waned: It’s still among the most reliable sources of artisanal breads and pastries. Cultivated with wild yeasts and poolish starters, the breads include chewy focaccia dotted with olive oil pockmarks, crusty French loaves and sourdough boules. Sweet quickbreads and pastries like scones, muffins, strudels and almond croissants are also hard to pass up.

3225 S MacDill Ave., Tampa; (813) 902-8828; panerusticabakery.com

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. Salmon With Creamy Mustard Sauce makes for a quick dinner with a French-inspired sauce, an easy and elegant dinner if you are abstaining from meat during the Lenten season.
  2. SCOTT KEELER   |   Times
Fisherman Al Henrichon, Millbury Mass., tries his luck on a jetty at Sunset Beach, Treasure Island, 3/12/18, as storm clouds roll in form the Gulf. Henrichon who is visiting the area on vacation said he caught some sea trout and a few sharks.
  3. A rack of ribs from Joe's Kansas City Bar-B-Que.
  4. People walk along food booths at the Florida State Fair on Feb. 13, 2020 in Tampa. The fair had a strong run last year with 455,851 visiting over two weeks. The fair will now be held April 22-May 2, with masks required and indoor spaces reworked to allow for social distancing.
  5. Murray Beairsto's house on 18th Avenue Northeast decorated for Halloween in 2004. The typically large swaths of visitors in the Old Northeast neighborhood of St. Petersburg usually brings joy to the neighborhood, but the idea of crowds this year is making some residents rethink the tradition.
  6. A St. Petersburg food server in the early days of the coronavirus. How will things change with the governor's latest order?
  7. LUIS SANTANA   |   Times
Mel Lohn, owner of Mel's Hotdogs poses in front of his iconic restaurant on Busch Blvd. in Tampa.
  8. Jul. 9, 2020• Life & Culture
    The new St. Petersburg Pier and its $92 million dollar Pier District opened to the public on July 6 to the public.
  9. Stunt performers put on a show Friday at Nik Wallenda's Daredevil Rally. It is the creation of high wire star and Sarasota resident Nik Wallenda. The socially distant drive-in stunt show's opening night was held at Nathan Benderson Park on Friday in Sarasota. I runs through June 21.
  10. Universal Orlando's two theme parks are still closed but the CityWalk shopping and restaurants district will open on Thursday with limited hours. Guests will be required to wear masks and have temperatures checked at the entrance.
  11. Dee Dee and her baby, born in January of 2018 at ZooTampa at Lowry Park will be on display again starting June 1, according to a plan the zoo has submitted to Hillsborough County.
  12. Tampa's Adventure Island, across the street from Busch Gardens, will debut Solar Vortex to the public on March 14.
  13. Expect to see lots of traditional Mardi Gras masks like this during the annual Mardi Gras parade in downtown Dunedin on Feb. 22.
  14. Plant City's Fancy Farms off County Line Road will host its annual U-pick event on Feb. 22.
  15. Jan. 30, 2020• Iconic Restaurants
    Rye toast, bacon, tomatoes, potatoes and fresh fruit at the Frog Pond restaurant.
  16. The original Hooters, at 2800 Gulf to Bay Blvd. in Clearwater.
  17. Jan. 30, 2020• Iconic Restaurants
    An assortment of variations of baklava, including saraigli, kataifi, flogera and traditional baklava, are available at Hellas Bakery in Tarpon Springs.
  18. Jan. 30, 2020• Iconic Restaurants
    Casa Tina in Dunedin serves up Mexican cuisine.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement