Advertisement
  1. Gradebook

Critics question value of foundation’s school choice survey

The FEA calls the report “poorly designed and flawed.”
A dozen protesters, including Tallahassee residents Colleen and Al Thorburn, far right, gathered outside Holy Comforter Episcopal School in Tallahassee to greet U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos on Tuesday, Aug. 29, 2017. DeVos spent two hours visiting classrooms at the private Christian school. Kristen M. Clark / Herald/Times
Published Feb. 25

A survey released Friday touting strong support of Florida’s school choice options from the Foundation for Excellence in Education — the state’s most prominent school choice proponent established by former Gov. Jeb Bush — has drawn heavy criticism from public school advocates and organizations, who contend the release is misleading at best.

The Florida Education Association, for one, deemed the survey “poorly designed and flawed,” suggesting it’s more an advocacy device than a true research instrument. The survey did emerge just as the Legislature prepares to begin session, with a series of proposals to expand vouchers and charter schools high on the Republican leadership agenda.

On the Gradebook’s Facebook page, several readers argued the survey deserved a more insightful analysis, to show that the 800-person sample skewed to older white males without children in the school system, and that the questions appeared to them to be designed to attain a certain outcome.

“Of course a pro choice group asking misleading questions is going to get the results it wants. Shouldn’t the headline be pro choice group gives survey that says people are pro choice? Or maybe this is nothing close to news,” blogger Chris Guerrieri chided, referring to our blog post.

What do they mean by calling the questions misleading?

Some pointed to the wording of this example, which yielded nearly 80 percent support: “Generally speaking, do you support giving parents the opportunity to choose where they send their child to school rather than assigning children to schools based on zip code?”

When researchers ask this question as a choice between school choice and investing in schools, they get the opposite result. The fact is, that the ‘opportunity to choose’ does not exist in a vacuum in the public debate,” FEA spokeswoman Sharon Nesvig said via email. “The authors of this survey know that and wrote this question to produce a result, rather than to learn where voters stand.”

A 2018 poll by an independent group focused on the question differently. It offered two statements relating to helping children in under-performing schools — invest in public schools or give parents more choice — and asked respondents to pick the one that represented their views. The majority in that poll selected investment, even when separated by party identity.

The FEA has been among the strongest critics of the Jeb Bush-era education model, and has sued the state several times over many aspects. It has, in turn, come under attack itself as an organization more interested in adults than in children, something it strongly rejects.

The foundation has stood by its findings, saying it demonstrates the Legislature and Gov. Ron DeSantis are headed in the right direction with plans to eliminate a waiting list for children to get scholarships to private schools.

“Access to opportunity matters, and parents know it,” CEO Patricia Levesque said in a released statement.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. Students and community activists marched in Tampa last year after the Feb. 14, 2018 shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland. The attack killed 17 people and gave rise to Florida’s school guardian law, which this year was changed to allow classroom teachers to be armed. Gov. Ron DeSantis signed the measure into law. [MONICA HERNDON   |   Times]
    Damien Kelly, the director of the Office of Safe Schools, told lawmakers that 11 districts have said they would like the option to arm instructional staff, but it wasn’t clear if all 11 had...
  2. Pasco High School's state grade for 2019 remains an "incomplete," with state officials finding not enough students were tested.
    A fourth has its request rejected, leaving it with an “incomplete” mark.
  3. The USF St. Petersburg Campus, Thursday, June 19, 2014.
    A roundup of stories from around the state.
  4. A view of the student center at the University of South Florida St. Petersburg, where opposition is mounting over a plan to consolidate USF's three campuses. Some state lawmakers are opposed to parts of it that would concentrate authority over academic decisions in Tampa. CHRIS URSO   |   TIMES  |
    They say the proposal by USF president Steve Currall conflicts with a new Florida law by giving too much authority to the Tampa campus.
  5. Wreckage left behind by Hurricane Michael. News Service of Florida
    Entire school systems are still recovering from long-standing damage and dealing with the disruptive aftermath of the storm.
  6. The National Merit Scholarship program has announced the names of semifinalists for scholarships to be offered in the spring.
    These students are among the top 1 percent of high school seniors in the nation.
  7. Florida schools increasingly are monitoring students' social media for potential threats.
    A roundup of stories from around the state.
  8. Sally Harris said she has more to accomplish and is mounting a return campaign for the Hillsborough County School Board. [Times | 2014]
    Three people have filed so far for the seat now held by Lynn Gray.
  9. The DeLucio family of Trinity toured the Mitchell High School campus and showed the visit on their YouTube channel, which has more than 1 million subscribers. Many parents, students and school officials were not amused. YouTube
    If approved, a new policy would take effect in early October.
  10. The Hillsborough County School Board holds a workshop in June 2019. Tampa Bay Times
    The chairwoman looks for ways to keep comments private, while the board asks for more input on key issues like its superintendent search.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement