Sunday, November 18, 2018
  • Bay Buzz
  • From the staff of the Tampa Bay Times

Hillsborough Democrats aim to kill ballot measure on non-partisan constitutional offices

The Hillsborough County Democratic Party has filed a lawsuit seeking to prevent a referendum that would make the county's constitutional offices non-partisan positions.

The county Democrats charge the measure is "self-serving politics" and a voter suppression attempt by the Republican majority on the Board of County Commissioners, in the words of county Democratic Chairwoman Ione Townsend.

The lawsuit filed in Hillsborough Circuit Court names county elections Supervisor Craig Latimer – a Democrat – as defendant. The suit seeks to keep him from putting the measure on the November election ballot, Townsend said.

But the real target is the five-member Republican majority on the seven-member board of commissioners. The vote to place the measure on the ballot was 5-2, divided along party lines.

Currently the county's five constitutional officers run as Democrats or Republicans. They are the sheriff, elections supervisor, property appraiser, tax collector and clerk of court.

If presented to voters and approved Nov. 6, the measure would change the offices to non-partisan like the school board and judgeships.

Democrats contend in the lawsuit that the measure amounts to voter suppression, calling it an attempt to maintain GOP political control in Hillsborough even as the county's voter base grows more Democratic.

As evidence of this, Townsend pointed to the commissioners' decision to change other offices but not their own to non-partisan positions.

Constitutional officers are elected in presidential election years when Democratic voter turnout is higher than during so-called mid-term elections. Four of the seven commission seats, on the other hand, come up for election during those mid-term elections with their diminished Democratic turnout.

Democrats hold three of the constitutional offices. In addition, Democrat Andrew Warren ousted incumbent Republican Mark Ober as state attorney in the 2016 election.

Townsend said the measure amounts to voter suppression because non-partisan elections in the county typically draw 100,000 to 130,000 fewer voters than partisan elections.

"It's an attempt to guarantee that GOP continues to control a majority by having partisan elections in mid-terms," she said.

Clearwater lawyer Ryan Barack, who represents the Democratic Party in the lawsuit, said case law in Florida has established that the process in the state Constitution for electing county constitutional officers doesn't allow for non-partisan elections.

He said the referendum measure would also violate the county charter.

But Republicans said the elections for the officers should be non-partisan because their jobs are.

"These offices really should be non-partisan in nature, said Commissioner Stacy White. "They're about law enforcement in the county, taxation, about the elections supervisor leading a process for fair and neutral elections. Partisan politics should not enter into play."

White said non-partisan races tend to be further down the ballot and draw less advance attention, which could explain why they attract fewer voters.

Commissioner Victor Crist called the lawsuit "an extremely warped spin."

"It looks to me like the Democratic Party of Hillsborough County is not being very democratic here," Crist said. "Let the people decide."

Those in favor of the measure also argued that it would actually increase voter participation by allowing no-party and minor-party voters to vote in primary elections for the offices. These voters cannot cast ballots in partisan primary elections.

But when the commissioners debated the measure, representatives of both parties opposed it.

Comments
‘Tip of the Iceberg’: Tampa corporate support for Rays? So far, it’s $16 million

‘Tip of the Iceberg’: Tampa corporate support for Rays? So far, it’s $16 million

Tampa Bay Rays 2020 co-founder Ron Christaldi put some details Friday behind his confidence that the Tampa Bay Rays will get a new home in Ybor City — $16 million of them.That's the amount of new corporate support pledged for a ball park north ...
Published: 11/16/18
Regional climate change coalition has one holdout: Pasco County

Regional climate change coalition has one holdout: Pasco County

County Commissioner Jack Mariano, who sits on the Regional Planning Council, did not bring the proposal to the County Commission because he doesn't want the words climate change used.
Published: 11/16/18
Tampa’s Grand Central Station and High Line? Harry Cohen is thinking big on transportation

Tampa’s Grand Central Station and High Line? Harry Cohen is thinking big on transportation

  Tampa City Council member Harry Cohen, an eight-year veteran of City Council, is known for his attention to detail on even the smallest zoning matter. But in his run to replace term-limited Mayor Bob Buckhorn, Cohen is leaving the small-ball appr...
Published: 11/15/18
Updated: 11/16/18
Clearwater Vice Mayor Doreen Caudell resigns at council meeting

Clearwater Vice Mayor Doreen Caudell resigns at council meeting

Caudell said she needs to spend more time on her business, then walked out of the meeting. City Attorney Pam Akin said the resignation won't be official until it's in writing.
Published: 11/15/18
Rules of the Sidewalk? Tampa grapples with the rented scooter craze

Rules of the Sidewalk? Tampa grapples with the rented scooter craze

Tampa city officials are sifting through applications for a pilot scooter program. Residents could be scooting through the streets by February.
Published: 11/15/18
Buckhorn names Arthenia Joyner to transit committee

Buckhorn names Arthenia Joyner to transit committee

The former Democratic state senator is the first person named to the 13-member transit surtax oversight committee.
Published: 11/15/18
Clearwater strong mayor fight is over but rift on City Council remains an open wound

Clearwater strong mayor fight is over but rift on City Council remains an open wound

Hoyt Hamilton asks for apology from Doreen Caudell for her words in Letter to the Editor. She apologizes but claims she was misquoted in her own letter.
Published: 11/14/18
William March: Could a late arrival in Tampa mayor’s race upset the apple cart?

William March: Could a late arrival in Tampa mayor’s race upset the apple cart?

Speculation centers on businessman Mike Griffin or former state Rep. Ed Narain possibly entering the race for Tampa mayor.
Published: 11/13/18
Is he doing a post-election two-step? Ed Turanchik  on the transportation tax, then and now

Is he doing a post-election two-step? Ed Turanchik on the transportation tax, then and now

Before the vote, Ed Turanchik was highly critical of the one-penny sales tax increase to fund transportation improvements that passed overwhelmingly on Tuesday.The former Hillsborough County Commissioner and current Tampa mayoral candidate was the on...
Published: 11/08/18
Updated: 11/09/18
Hillsborough now firmly blue

Hillsborough now firmly blue

A growing urban and suburban population has shifted Hillsborough's politics, pundits say.
Published: 11/07/18