Tuesday, November 13, 2018
  • Bay Buzz
  • From the staff of the Tampa Bay Times

Appellate court sides with Hillsborough Dems, blocks referendum on non-partisan offices

TAMPA – Party affiliation will remain a part of the elections for Hillsborough County's sheriff and other constitutional officers following an appeals court decision Wednesday that kills a move to let voters decide.

The 2nd District Court of Appeal affirmed a ruling by circuit court Judge Robert Foster, who found that switching to nonpartisan elections would be unconstitutional and instructed the Supervisor of Elections to keep a referendum off the Nov. 6 ballot.

The decision effectively sinks the referendum. It was adopted by the Hillsborough County Commission on a  5-2 vote, with Republican members approving of the measure and Democrats opposed.

The appellate court panel of three judges issued no opinion, letting stand the lower court decision and leaving county attorneys little option to file another appeal: The deadline to finalize ballot language is Thursday.

The vote in June by the County Commission prompted the Hillsborough County Democratic Executive Committee to sue the county and the Supervisor of Elections.

The Democrats argued that the move to strip candidates of Democrat or Republican affiliation would result in less voter engagement and amounted to voter suppression.

It also cited a legal precedent in a case out of Orange County where appellate judges sided with the sheriff, tax collector and property appraiser in a lawsuit to restore their party affiliation so they could run as Democrats. The case has been accepted by the Florida Supreme Court.

"We're thrilled," said attorney Ryan Barack, who represented the Hillsborough Democratic Executive Committee. "We're glad the court recognized that voter suppression efforts were unconstitutional."

Rob Brazel, chief assistant county attorney, said the county will not appeal the case further since the Supreme Court will be taking up the issue anyway.

The high court is unlikely to decide the case until early 2019. By then, a new Hillsborough County Commission will be in place since four seats are up for election Nov. 6.

"It would be up to a future board to decide if they want to put it back on the next go around," Brazel said.

Ione Townsend, Hillsborough Democratic Party chairwoman, welcomed the appellate court's decision.

The measure would have moved the election of constitutional offices to the primary election, when turnout typically falls short of general election turnout by 100,000 voters. The result would have been fewer people voting, Townsend said.

"It's mind boggling to me why the county kept pursuing this," she said.

Republicans who backed the plan said it would increase participation since it would mean no-party and minor-party voters could cast a ballot for the offices in the primary elections. Currently, the primary election in those races is open only to voters registered as Republican or Democrat.

Republican Commissioner Al Higginbotham, who proposed the change, said there are no plans to revive it. But he disputes that it was motivated by politics.

"It's frustrating for me that this became a partisan issue," Higginbotham said. "I looked at this as a practical move. "I had the best of intentions when I made the proposal."

Contact Christopher O'Donnell at [email protected] or (813) 226-3446. Follow @codonnell_Times.

Comments
William March: Could a late arrival in Tampa mayor’s race upset the apple cart?

William March: Could a late arrival in Tampa mayor’s race upset the apple cart?

Speculation centers on businessman Mike Griffin or former state Rep. Ed Narain possibly entering the race for Tampa mayor.
Updated: 5 hours ago
Is he doing a post-election two-step? Ed Turanchik  on the transportation tax, then and now

Is he doing a post-election two-step? Ed Turanchik on the transportation tax, then and now

Before the vote, Ed Turanchik was highly critical of the one-penny sales tax increase to fund transportation improvements that passed overwhelmingly on Tuesday.The former Hillsborough County Commissioner and current Tampa mayoral candidate was the on...
Published: 11/08/18
Updated: 11/09/18
Hillsborough now firmly blue

Hillsborough now firmly blue

A growing urban and suburban population has shifted Hillsborough's politics, pundits say.
Published: 11/07/18
The people’s choice?  Tampa’s Riverwalk

The people’s choice? Tampa’s Riverwalk

It's been the riparian apple of Mayor Bob Buckhorn's eye, so perhaps it's fitting , as the term-limited mayor counts down his final months in office, that Tampa's Riverwalk gets some national love.The American Planning Association awarded the linear ...
Published: 11/07/18
Los Angeles mayor hails Hillsborough transit vote on ‘Jimmy Kimmel Live!’

Los Angeles mayor hails Hillsborough transit vote on ‘Jimmy Kimmel Live!’

Eric Garcetti tells the ABC-TV host that the citizen-driven, voter-approved, penny on dollar sales tax for transportation is one of the midterm election's most exciting results.
Published: 11/07/18
Hillsborough voters approve sales tax hikes for transportation, schools improvements

Hillsborough voters approve sales tax hikes for transportation, schools improvements

The 30-year transportation measure will add a penny on the dollar to the sales tax and raise about $276 million per year. Voters were equally enthusiastic about a 10-year, half-cent sales tax for Hillsborough County Schools.
Published: 11/07/18
Hillsborough Commission District 5 election results: Mariella Smith unseats Victor Crist

Hillsborough Commission District 5 election results: Mariella Smith unseats Victor Crist

Democrats now control a majority on the Hillsborough County Commission for the first time since 2004.
Published: 11/06/18
Updated: 11/07/18
Florida House District 65 results: Incumbent Chris Sprowls defeats first-timer Sally Laufer

Florida House District 65 results: Incumbent Chris Sprowls defeats first-timer Sally Laufer

Sprowls, a north Pinellas Republican, won his third term in office. He remains on track become Speaker of the Florida House for the 2021-22 legislative session.
Published: 11/06/18
Updated: 11/07/18
Tampa Bay Judicial Races: Fuson, Allen, Gutman win in Hillsborough, Ellis wins Pinellas-Pasco

Tampa Bay Judicial Races: Fuson, Allen, Gutman win in Hillsborough, Ellis wins Pinellas-Pasco

Clear victors emerge in all four Tampa Bay judicial races
Published: 11/06/18
Democrats taking control of Hillsborough commission for first time since 2004

Democrats taking control of Hillsborough commission for first time since 2004

The most-watched races were for two countywide seats where Democrats Mariella Smith was on her way to oust Republican incumbent Victor Crist in District 5 and Kimberly Overman looked nearly certain to best Todd Marks in District 7.
Published: 11/06/18