Advertisement
  1. Gradebook

State lawyers file response in education funding lawsuit before Florida’s Supreme Court

The case was first filed in 2009.
Florida Supreme Court building
Florida Supreme Court building
Published Jul. 20, 2018
Updated Jul. 20, 2018

After lagging for months, the lawsuit challenging Florida's education funding system gained traction again this week, with lawyers submitting arguments urging the state Supreme Court to kill the case rather than send it back to a lower court for further review.

In December, an appellate court upheld the trial court in stating that the parent complaint could not be judged objectively. It found the language in Article IX of the state constitution requiring a "high quality" and "efficient" system to be "political aspirations," and not measurable criteria.

The Supreme Court agreed to consider the issue in April.

Related: Parents ask Florida Supreme Court to send school funding suit back to trial court

Senior deputy solicitor general Rachel Nordby wrote for the state that each of the appellate court's findings against the complaint would be reason enough for the Supreme Court to deny the request for rehearing.

Nordby wrote that Florida offers many educational opportunities for children, and that students' academic achievement has improved over time. It has done so, she contended, with one of the most efficient education systems in the country.

"[E]ven if the First District's justiciability or separation-of-powers reasoning were somehow incorrect, its decision should be approved for other reasons supported by the record," she wrote. "The circuit court correctly found that Plaintiffs proved no causal connection between any alleged lack of school resources and student performance. The weight of the evidence actually showed the absence of such a connection, regardless of the burden of proof."

She offered several arguments regarding why the case is not proper to be heard in court, as well, including that the courts cannot usurp the Legislature's exclusive authority to fund public education.

Read the state's full briefing here.

Ari Bargil of the Institute for Justice filed a response on behalf of six intervenor-parents in the case. The parents use the McKay Scholarship or Florida Tax Credit Scholarship programs, and do not want to see the model transformed by this case.

Bargil argued the constitutionality of the McKay and FTC programs are not proper before the court, and that the petitioners should be barred from making such arguments.

He further questioned the standing of the plaintiffs from bringing these complaints, suggesting they have endured no special injury.

"[A]ccepting Petitioners' theory that tax credits are the equivalent of a direct appropriation of public funds would have ramifications far beyond this case," Bargil wrote.

"The FTC Program is not the only 'tax expenditure' that excludes revenue from the State Treasury. If Petitioners are correct that any money excluded from the treasury could be used to fund public schools, then any exclusion, exemption, deduction, or credit that reduces a taxpayer's tax liability is unconstitutional because—under Petitioners' logic—it diverts money away from public education in violation of Article IX, section 1(a). Pet'rs' Initial Br. 48 (arguing tax credits divert monies that 'would otherwise have been available to fund public schools'). Petitioners' theory would, if accepted by this Court, thus jeopardize the State's entire tax scheme. This Court should avoid this absurd result by rejecting—consistent with the unanimous legal precedent on this issue—the notion that tax credits are the equivalent of  public funds."

Read Bargil's complete argument here.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

  1. Tampa Bay Tech, still missing star sophomore Janiah Barker, falters in the region final Friday, but if healthy should make another deep playoff run next season.
  2. After its 3-1 victory over Westminster Academy of Fort Lauderdale on Friday, the Shorecrest girls soccer team  will be playing in the program's first state final next week in Deland.
  3. Land O' Lakes may have fallen one game short of a state final, but, as coach Jen Craven says: “We have some good kids coming from the local middle school. Looking forward, I don’t see any reason why you won’t see us in the show next year."
  4. Monte Kiffin, shown here talking to safety John Lynch during a preseason game against the Jaguars on Aug. 16, 2002, this season will be the 14th inductee into the Bucs Ring of Honor.
  5. Carrollwood Day's Weeyah McGill, seen here during last year's state tournament, was dominant Friday against Seffner Christian.
  6. Plant senior Honor Culpepper, seen here earlier this season, scores a game-high 20 points in Friday's Class 7A region final victory.
  7. Surveillance footage shows thieves breaking into the Trulieve medical marijuana dispensary on U.S. 19, according to Clearwater police. The break in happened less than an hour after a similar burglary at a store on Clearwater Beach.
  8. Coach Karrmayne King hugs Keswick Christian player Marissa McCauley after the Crusaders soundly defeat Hernando Christian to advance to state.
  9. Tanner Donald Hackman, 22, of Clearwater, faces charges of vehicular homicide and leaving the scene of a crash involving death, according to the Florida Highway Patrol. This photo was taken after a 2018 arrest.
  10. President Donald Trump speaks during a campaign rally, Friday, Feb. 21, 2020, in Las Vegas.
  11. USF athletic director Michael Kelly (left) and first-year football coach Jeff Scott have confirmed the Bulls' spring football game will remain on campus. [JOEY KNIGHT | TAMPA BAY TIMES]
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement