Saturday, September 22, 2018

Florida Supreme Court strikes Amendment 8 from November ballot

TALLAHASSEE — The state Supreme Court charged into Florida's long-running battle over school choice Friday by removing a ballot measure that would have wrested control of charter schools from local districts and given it to the state.

Justices, in a narrowly divided 4-3 decision, upheld the decision by a lower court that Amendment 8, scheduled to appear on the Nov. 6 ballot, misled voters by not clearly stating its true purpose and never mentioning charter schools by name.

The Republican-controlled state government has generally been more receptive to charter schools than local school boards — and this proposal would have helped expand the amount of public dollars steered to privately-managed charter schools, critics of the ballot measure had argued.

The court's ruling is final, allowing elections supervisors across Florida to complete their Nov. 6 ballots almost immediately so that they are mailed to registered voter living overseas.

Plaintiff Patricia Brigham, president of the Florida League of Women Voters, celebrated the result.

"That is indeed fantastic news," Brigham said. "It is truly a victory for Floridians. The court saw right through what the [Constitution Revision Commission] was doing with that very vague language."

The League is a vocal critic of Florida's expansion of charter schools, which are paid for with taxpayer money but operated by private groups. Along with the Southern Poverty Law Center, the League challenged Amendment 8 by arguing the proposal's ballot title and summary hid the purpose of the measure: to fuel the expansion of charter schools by easing oversight.

Rather than mention "charter schools" in either its title or ballot summary, the measure states that its purpose "permits the state to operate, control, and supervise public schools not established by the school board."

"This decision upholds prior law guaranteeing that if voters are asked to make significant changes to the state's constitution, they are given fair notice of those changes so that they can make informed decisions at the ballot box," added Zoe Savitsky, deputy legal director for the Southern Poverty Law Center.

Erika Donalds, the measure's sponsor, criticized "activist judges" for the decision.

"The League of Women Voters and the Southern Poverty Law Center were so busy protecting a system — protecting power and control — that they lost sight of the children, and the families who desire and deserve great public school options," Donalds said in a released statement. "We know that choice, competition, and innovation are the avenues to continuous improvement for our education system. The education monopoly will not reform itself or welcome needed competition without policy changes."

Donalds, who is a school board member in Naples and is married to a Republican state lawmaker, pledged to continue fighting for more pathways to provide school choice to families.

Friday was a busy day for judicial decisions on some of Florida's many proposed constitutional amendments. The Supreme Court also ordered that three other amendments stay on the ballot after facing separate challenges. Additionally, the attorney general's office indicated on Friday it would appeal three other amendments struck from the ballot by a Leon County Circuit judge earlier this week.

READ MORE: Explaining 13 constitutional amendments on Florida's ballot

During Wednesday's oral arguments on Amendment 8, two justices — Charles Canady and Al Lawson — repeatedly suggested that the language before voters was clear in intent.

"I'm struggling to understand why they aren't going to get the main point here," Chief Justice Canady said at one point during questioning of Ron Meyer, the lawyer representing the League of Women Voters.

Four others on the court, who comprised the majority striking the amendment, signaled during questioning that they saw logic in the League's arguments.

If the objective is to let the voters know what they're voting on, Justice Jorge Labarga said to deputy solicitor general Daniel Bell, "Why not just come out and say it?"

Related coverage: Florida justices ask pointed questions during hearing on Amendment 8 

Amendment 8 also pitched to impose school board term limits and enshrine civics education in the constitution. During debate among Florida Constitution Revision Commission members, concerns arose that the public school authorizer section should stand separately from the others because it could dramatically alter public education in the state.

A majority on the commission decided to tie the three together under the education umbrella, suggesting it would help stave off voter fatigue at the end of an already lengthy ballot. Some commissioners stated that the term limits and civics items might even help the authorizer piece win approval.

Related coverage: Constitution Revision Commission advances bundled education proposal to November ballot 

"The Supreme Court has once again affirmed that a sponsor of a revision to the Constitution must be clear in explaining what it will do," Meyer said Friday. "Here, voters were being asked to make a major change in the structure of public education without being fairly informed of the breadth of this change.  We are obviously pleased with the outcome."

Comments
ICYMI: Florida education news in review, week of Sept. 16, 2018

ICYMI: Florida education news in review, week of Sept. 16, 2018

Florida’s race for governor is officially on, and the topic of education promises to be a key issue as the candidates seek support. The major party hopefuls focused on their policy priorities over the past week, and they differ is most every wa...
Published: 09/22/18
Two Pasco County schools see principal shift

Two Pasco County schools see principal shift

Plagued with low staff morale, Pasco Middle School on Friday got a new principal charged with improving the climate of the Dade City campus.Danielle "Dee Dee" Johnson, principal of Wesley Chapel High since early 2017, was appointed to ...
Published: 09/21/18
Time for Florida’s new student scholarships draws near

Time for Florida’s new student scholarships draws near

It's six weeks into the 2018-19 school year, and Florida's two newest scholarship programs to help struggling readers and bullied children are about to become reality.Florida lawmakers established the Reading Scholarship and the "Hope" Scholarsh...
Published: 09/21/18
Florida education news: Football, mental health, accountability and more

Florida education news: Football, mental health, accountability and more

CAMPAIGN TRAIL: Republican candidate for Florida governor Ron DeSantis offers more insights on his views about Common Core, testing, charter schools and civics education. He released his position paper on education earlier in the week. Several l...
Published: 09/21/18
Following the money: Referendum and AC materials

Following the money: Referendum and AC materials

We've been collecting documents to supplement our reporting about the upcoming Hillsborough sales tax referendum and thought we would share them here. This post will be updated.First: Facebook Live video of Superintendent Jeff Eakins' first town hall...
Published: 09/20/18
Updated: 09/21/18
Mental health provider that evaluated Nikolas Cruz picked to service charter schools

Mental health provider that evaluated Nikolas Cruz picked to service charter schools

Florida's largest charter school membership organization announced Wednesday that it is partnering with Parkland school shooter Nikolas Cruz's former mental health care provider to render services to schools.Broward County's Henderson Behavioral Heal...
Published: 09/20/18
Delayed Pasco charter school aims for Oct. 1 move to new site

Delayed Pasco charter school aims for Oct. 1 move to new site

Plato Academy Trinity has told parents and students it's targeting Oct. 1 to open its new building on Old County Road 54.It still has several permits to obtain if it wants to meet that latest deadline.The Pasco County charter school, serving about 25...
Published: 09/20/18
Gradebook podcast: DeSantis vs. Gillum and the future of Florida education policy

Gradebook podcast: DeSantis vs. Gillum and the future of Florida education policy

Florida's two major party candidates for governor have released their education platforms, and they couldn't have offered a more distinct choice.With the exception of wanting to expand career and technical education, and to pay teachers better, Repub...
Published: 09/20/18
Florida education news: Teacher pay, Red Tide, campaign contributions and more

Florida education news: Teacher pay, Red Tide, campaign contributions and more

TEACHER PAY: Pasco County teachers and staff continue to press for raises in the district's budget, getting only board promises to keep looking for funding. One School Board member urges his colleagues to make pay a top priority.RED TIDE: T...
Published: 09/20/18
Red Tide forces two Pinellas schools to move recess, physical education inside

Red Tide forces two Pinellas schools to move recess, physical education inside

Recess and physical education classes at two south Pinellas County schools were moved inside this week due to Red Tide, a toxic algae that continues to plague area beaches with throngs of dead fish and an unmistakable foul odor.Pr...
Published: 09/19/18