1. Gradebook

Florida, school districts still battling over 2017 charter school law

Much of the court debate centers on whether the state has authority to create ‘Schools of Hope’ charters.
Florida appellate judges Timothy Osterhaus, Joseph Lewis Jr. and M. Kemmerly Thomas hear arguments June 11, 2019, over the merits of a 2017 law creating a new type of charter school. [Florida 1st District Court of Appeal live stream]
Published Jun. 11

Two years after its adoption, Florida’s controversial law establishing the ‘Schools of Hope’ charter school program remains a point of contention.

On Tuesday, lawyers for 10 school districts including Pinellas County argued in court that the statute — commonly referred to as HB 7069 — is unconstitutional and should be tossed out. Lawmakers overstepped their bounds, they contended, by granting powers of creating and overseeing new schools to the state, while the Florida constitution reserves that role for local school boards.

They referred specifically to the 1968 section that authorizes school boards to "operate, control and supervise all free public schools within the school district and determine the rate of school district taxes within the limits prescribed herein. "

With HB 7069, attorney Steven Brannock argued, the state sets itself up to approve a set of charter schools outside the district control, and to direct the spending of some local tax revenue without school board consideration.

Related coverage: Broward sues over massive education bill as other Florida counties consider joining in

The state can pass a statute, and set forth rules and standards that local districts must meet, Brannock told the three-judge panel of the First District Court of Appeal. “What you don’t do is say, 'Forget it, we’re going to go ahead and make the decisions for you. ... That’s what is unconstitutional.”

Lawyers for the state rejected the districts’ position. They pointed to a 1998 revision to the constitution that makes it a “paramount duty of the state to make adequate provision for the education of all children residing within its borders.”

That suggests the state has the explicit authority to do what is necessary within the public school system to create opportunities such as ‘Schools of Hope,’ argued attorney Rocco Testani.

Testani stressed that school boards continue to have control over several aspects of the charter school model, including the ability to approve contracts and terminate a ‘School of Hope’ for its failure to meet set standards.

“The idea that they’re cut out is simply not true,” he said, stressing that this law differs from one that had given the state direct authority to establish a charter schools.

The Florida Supreme Court threw out that law creating a Schools of Excellence Commission.

The appellate judges on Tuesday asked a few questions about the merits of this case, in which Leon County judge John Cooper had ruled for the state a year ago. But their primary focus centered on whether school districts had standing to bring the case in the first place.

They repeatedly asked all presenting lawyers about precedents that dealt with constitutional officers challenging laws that might affect their duties. Judge M. Kemmerly Thomas pointedly asked at one point which, if any, of the districts’ six complaints would survive if standing were not granted.

Brannock contended the case law was clear, that constitutional officers “have the right to complain about the impact on their duties of an unconstitutional statute.” Testani countered that a recent ruling from Escambia County that the officials cannot challenge the laws that affect their duties.

He went further to assert that in this case, no roles had been impeded.

“What these boards are saying is, they want to be left alone,” Testani said.

The judges did not comment or make any ruling.

Related coverage: Leon County judge rules against school districts’ challenge of HB 7069


  1. Pasco County schools assistant superintendent for operations Betsy Kuhn oversees the district's campus security initiatives. JEFFREY SOLOCHEK  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Schools identified these needs after a thorough review of their campuses.
  2. Hernando County School District
    The Hernando County School District’s overall premiums will go up about 10 percent. Unless it’s renegotiated later, the entire increase falls to employees.
  3. A Florida black bear (not this one) was found at a Marion County school and removed. CARLTON WARD JR  |  Carlton Ward Jr
    A roundup of stories from around the state.
  4. Adjunct faculty at St. Petersburg College voted to unionize Tuesday, joining thousands of other adjuncts across Florida who are fighting for better working conditions and pay. [Times]
    The employees are the seventh group in Florida to join Service Employees International Union in recent yeas as it pushes for investment in the state’s higher education institutions.
  5. The University of South Florida ranked ahead of UCF, FIU and FAU in the U.S. News & World Report's Global University Rankings. [USF handout]
    The University of Florida finished 105th, while USF came in at 310. Harvard led the world.
  6. Workers begin construction in 2010 on what would become Winding Waters K-8. That was the last new public school built in Hernando County, which faces capacity strains as officials ask for impact fee increases to keep up with growth. HERNANDO TODAY PHOTO BY HAYLEY M  |  Hernando Today
    The district first would add classrooms at three existing schools, but could need four new schools by 2039.
  7. Rep. Bruce Antone, D-Orlando, says the Legislative Black Caucus will prioritize both public education and school choice during the 2020 Florida session. The caucus held a news conference on Oct. 22, 2019. The Florida Channel
    The caucus announced its 2020 goals for justice, housing and other key issues, as well, with members saying they will stick together to pursue them.
  8. Pre-season baseball practice at Wesley Chapel High School. Lawmakers want to ensure student-athletes remain safe in the Florida heat as they participate in high school sports. DIRK SHADD  |  Times
    PreK-12 Innovation chairman Rep. Ralph Massullo expects legislation requiring some ‘simple things.’
  9. First-year Cox Elementary School teacher Kevin Knibbs, 33, of Dade City, answers questions about the components of time: hours, minutes, seconds, to his third-grade class on Monday, September 30, 2019, at the school in Date City. From left are students Angel Young, 8, Arlene Luna, 8, and Jahkia Gray, 8. DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    A roundup of stories from around the state.
  10. First-year Cox Elementary School teacher Kevin Knibbs, 33, of Dade City, walks with students Angel Young, 8, left, and Kaivion Williams, 9, right, while en route to his third-grade class on Sept. 30 at the school in Date City. Knibbs decided to become an educator after working as a school custodian. DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Kevin Knibbs never thought about working with students — until he started interacting with them.