Advertisement
  1. Business

Can Tampa Bay's housing void be filled by making it harder to sue banks, developers?

A view of the Ella affordable housing apartment complex in Tampa. (Times files)
Published Aug. 19

The Trump administration wants to make it much harder to sue for alleged discriminatory housing practices.

The controversial move sets up a classic capitalist argument. Which side you come down on likely depends on your confidence in free enterprise. It also could have a lasting effect — for better or worse — on affordable housing in the Tampa Bay area, which many observers say has reached crisis levels.

For years, banks, landlords, developers and others in the housing industry could wind up in court for unintentionally discriminating against minority groups. That is, they created policies that they did not think were discriminatory but turned out to be.

Plaintiffs attorneys didn't have to prove that an apartment owner purposefully refused to lease to African-Americans. They only had to show that the owner had a policy that led to discrimination, deliberately or not.

It's a potent legal tool, known as "disparate impact."

A new rule pushed by the Department of Housing and Urban Development lays out much more stringent standards for plaintiffs to prove their cases. The five-part test includes a requirement to show that statistical disparities were caused by specific policies, not by chance.

Liberal housing advocates contend that the changes amount to an insurmountable burden that will leave minorities vulnerable to discrimination. They've used the existing rule to overturn discriminatory zoning rules and to go after unfair insurance practices. The Justice Department has used the law to collect more than $500 million from companies accused of bias against minorities.

The advocates argue that lawsuits keep profit-driven companies honest. Those that step over the line know they face a legal slapping.

A particular worry centers on mathematical algorithms, which companies use for pricing, credit scores, marketing and insurance underwriting.

Algorithms "can have starkly discriminatory effects but can operate as a hidden box," the National Fair Housing Alliance said late last week. The "proposed rule could effectively immunize such covert discrimination."

MORE BUSINESS: Robots are coming for our jobs. Is Florida ready?

Banks, developers and insurance companies like (and pushed for) the new rule. Why wouldn't they? It means fewer lawsuits, many of which they call frivolous.

They also argue that the threat of getting dinged for inadvertent discrimination curtails innovation. It makes them less likely to experiment with new practices that could promote more affordable housing or lower the cost of insurance. Algorithms could help with those breakthroughs, if only they felt confident they wouldn't get sued for even trying.

Disparate impact "can have unintended consequences, such as causing financial institutions to shrink their operations rather than risk litigation, hurting the very groups it is intended to help," said American Bankers Association president and chief executive Frank Keating in a news release.

Housing and Urban Development Secretary Ben Carson said the rule change would increase "access to fair and affordable housing."

The rule cannot officially take effect until after a 60-day comment period. Could unshackling banks and insurance companies help fill Tampa Bay's affordable housing void? Or will it have the opposite effect?

We could be just a few months from finding out.

Contact Graham Brink at gbrink@tampabay.com. Follow @GrahamBrink.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. Neeld-Gordon Garden Center, open at this location since 1925, is closing on Sept. 28. MARTHA ASENCIO-RHINE  |  Times
    The development of Pinellas County and the arrival of the big box stores helped hasten the store’s demise.
  2. Tampa investor and owner of the Tampa Bay Lightning Jeff Vinik, right, speaks about his investments in the video game industry at the eSports Summit Wednesday in Tampa as Matt Samost, Vice President of New Ventures for Tampa Bay Sports and Entertainment looks on. LUIS SANTANA   |   TIMES  |  Tampa Bay Times
    A summit at USF brought together major players and explored the possibility of an esports arena.
  3. 7-Eleven Inc. is opening its first location in a Brandon mall. Pictured is a location in Port Richey in 2018. | [Times (2018) TYLISA JOHNSON | TIMES  |  TyLisa Johnson | Times
    It is the first of eight mall locations opening this year.
  4. Tampa has a pilot program underway to test scooters. Clearwater could soon have one of its own. But if it's limited to downtown, who will use it? CHRIS URSO  |   Times
    The city’s plan is coming into focus, but there will be limitations.
  5. Pages from a confidential whistleblower's report obtained by The Associated Press, along with two printed Facebook pages that were active on Tuesday, Sept. 17, 2019, are photographed in Washington. Facebook likes to say that its automated systems remove the vast majority of prohibited content glorifying the Islamic State group and al-Qaida before it’s reported. But a whistleblower’s complaint shows that Facebook itself has inadvertently produced dozens of pages in their names. (AP Photo/Jon Elswick) JON ELSWICK  |  AP
    A whistleblower’s complaint shows that the company has inadvertently provided the two extremist groups with a networking and recruitment tool.
  6. Pasco County community news TMCCARTY80  |  Tara McCarty
    Neighbors voice concerns about increased traffic, water quality and adhering to the county’s protections for northeast Pasco.
  7. This satellite image shows Hurricane Michael on Oct. 9, 2018, as it enters the Gulf of Mexico. It made landfall near Mexico Beach in the Panhandle as a Category 5 storm. [Photo courtesy of NOAA] NOAA
    Nearly a year after the storm, 18,000 claims are still open.
  8. Watermans Crossing apartments at 4515 N. Rome Avenue in Tampa. Westside Capital Group
    Jakub Hejl discovered the Tampa Bay area while studying at IMG Academy.
  9. The Tampa Bay Lightning has tapped Cigar City Brewing to bring its Jai Alai, Guayabera, and Florida Cracker beers to Amalie Arena as the team’s official craft beer partner. (Photo via Tampa Bay Lightning) Tampa Bay Lightning
    Cigar City also will move its popular annual Hunahpu’s Beer Festival to Amalie Arena starting next March.
  10. An administrative judge said a Pasco County ordinance allowing solar farms in agricultural districts did not violate the county's comprehensive land-use plan. Times
    An ordinance did not violate the county’s land-use plan that is supposed to protect rural Northeast Pasco, a judge said.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement