1. Business

Florida Attorney General sues Marlin Financial over loan practices

The Florida Attorney General is suing Marlin Financial, an online auto loan company. Pictured is its office in downtown Miami in December 2017. | [MALENA CAROLLO | Times (2017)]
The Florida Attorney General is suing Marlin Financial, an online auto loan company. Pictured is its office in downtown Miami in December 2017. | [MALENA CAROLLO | Times (2017)]
Published Dec. 5, 2018

Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi's office is suing online auto lender Marlin Financial for what it says are unfair and deceptive trade practices.

In a civil lawsuit filed in Hillsborough County in late November, the state's legal arm alleged that an add-on the lender said was optional "was in fact a mandatory feature of loans made to consumers." That add-on, known as a "debt cancellation product," was marketed to customers as an insurance-like product that would wipe out a customer's remaining debt if their car was totaled. Instead it dramatically increased the cost of the loans.

Marlin's debt cancellation product was the focus of a September Tampa Bay Times investigation into the company. It found that Marlin saddled consumers with significantly more debt than they expected, charged interest rates above state limits and failed to give some customers access to items in cars that were repossessed when they couldn't keep up with their payments. For Marlin customers whose contracts the Times reviewed, the debt cancellation cost 125 percent of their loan on average.

Following Times inquiries, the Attorney General's Office launched an investigation into Marlin. Representatives for the Miami-based lender did not return a request for comment early Wednesday afternoon.

The attorney general considers the debt cancellation product mandatory, the lawsuit says, because of the conditions a customer had to meet to decline it and still take out a loan. A customer would need to have pre-paid, full comprehensive and collision auto insurance with a deductible of no more than $250 for the lender to agree to waive debt cancellation.

"Borrowers found such insurance coverage either impossible or virtually impossible to purchase," the lawsuit says.

Because the product is a condition of taking out a loan with Marlin, the company should have included the fee for it in its calculation of the loan's interest rate, which Marlin did not, the lawsuit says. Marlin also charged interest on the debt cancellation "as if it were part of the financing agreement."

This led to some customers' cars being improperly repossessed and later sold, the lawsuit says, as customers defaulted when they could not make their high payments.

The attorney general is asking for a $10,000 penalty for every unfair and deceptive trade practices act, $15,000 for instances that affected senior citizens.

"It should be noted that generally enforcement actions pursued by our office do not affect a consumer's right to pursue legal remedies," said Whitney Ray, director of communications for the state Attorney General's Office, in a statement Wednesday.

In a temporary injunction signed by Marlin's president, Jeremy Tolan, and the Attorney General's Office, Marlin agreed not to offer debt cancellation on any new, refinanced or renewed loans. It also cannot collect debt cancellation charges on outstanding loans, including ones that customers have already defaulted on, unless those collections are put into an escrow account from which Marlin cannot make any withdrawals.

Marlin also is prohibited from charging its customers interest on the debt cancellation and from repossessing or selling any repossessed vehicle where the customer defaulted because of the rates charged that included the debt cancellation cost.

As part of the injunction, Marlin is required to provide the attorney general with information about the debt cancellation charged on loans from 2014 to the present. For all loans the company issued that are currently in good standing, Marlin is required to modify the payments to exclude any debt cancellation charges.

Marlin must consult with the attorney general, the injunction says, about what to do with any vehicles it has that were repossessed because of the inclusion of the debt cancellation in the loan.

The company stopped taking new loans in late September following the investigation. U.S. Rep. Charlie Crist called for the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau to investigate Marlin following the Times' investigation. In a letter, acting director of the bureau, Mick Mulvaney, said the federal consumer watchdog was "evaluating actions we might take in response."

"I applaud the state for taking action, sending a strong signal that if you abuse consumers you will not get away with it," Crist said in a statement about the lawsuit. "I hope to see the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau join the state in holding these bad actors accountable."

Contact Malena Carollo at or (727) 892-2249. Follow @malenacarollo.


  1. Muhammad Abdur-Rahim points out the location of what he believed to be a former African American cemetery next to the parking lot of FrankCrum Staffing, 100 S Missouri Ave. in Clearwater. Now, it appears the cemetery may have been on an adjacent lot where the building stands. [JAMES BORCHUCK  |  Times]
    Archaeologists were scanning a vacant lot for bodies until an old city record pointed them to an adjacent property.
  2. Construction continues on the new Wiregrass Ranch Sports Campus of Pasco County located in Wesley Chapel. The center will feature a 98,000 square foot sports center with eight bio-cushioned hardwood courts that can be utilized for basketball, volleyball, mixed martial arts, gymnastics, wrestling, soccer, futsal, cheerleading and dance. [OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times]
    The $44 million facility is expected to hold its first tournament in September
  3.  [Getty Images]
    While credit scores will fall for millions, millions more will see their scores rise.
  4. Lucky's Market ahead of its St. Petersburg grand opening just two years ago. [Times (2018)]
    Only one Florida Lucky’s Market will remain a Lucky’s. The future of the Tampa Bay locations is still unclear.
  5. Internet crimes are on the rise in Florida. [AP Photo]
    Also: Why were the SunTrust Financial Centre lights purple? And the cost of owning an electric car.
  6. AdventHealth's central Pasco emergency room at t 16625 State Road 54 is shown here. The hospital chain recently purchased 18 acres on State Road 52 at the northern entrance of the Mirada development west of Dade City. [MICHELE MILLER  |  Times]
    The hospital chain pays $4.5 million to buy 18 acres from a Metro Development Group affiliate.
  7. [Getty Images] [Getty Images]
    It would probably be good to ask his thoughts, the advice columnist writes.
  8. Renderings by Arquitectonica of the proposed Red Apple Group condo project in St. Petersburg. Courtesy of Arquitectonica [Courtesy of Arquitectonica]
    $300 million. 45 stories. A little closer to existence.
  9. A group of East Lake residents has erected signs protesting a 44-home development proposed by Tarpon Springs developer Pioneer Homes. Tarpon Springs commissioners recently voted to annex the site into the city. [Courtesy of Marc Washburn]
    The action targets a plan to build 44 homes on land between Keystone Road and Highland Avenue, double what was allowed in the East Lake District.
  10. People gather around an auctioneer at the liquidation sale following local bike store Flying Fish Bikes closing [Romy Ellenbogen]
    The liquidation sale was packed with people hoping to get discounted bike gear.