1. Archive

Editorial: Homestead vote tests Florida Senate

House Speaker Richard Corcoran.
House Speaker Richard Corcoran.
Published Apr. 30, 2017

The Florida Senate traditionally has been where bad ideas are killed, common sense prevails and independent thinking rules. That reputation will be tested Monday when the Senate votes on a misguided proposal to increase the homestead exemption, one of House Speaker Richard Corcoran's top priorities. This is part of a secret deal between Corcoran and Senate President Joe Negron to resolve the state budget and other top issues, but it's a terrible trade-off, and senators should reject it rather than follow along like sheep.

Corcoran, R-Land O'Lakes, wants a constitutional amendment on the 2018 ballot that would increase the homestead exemption from $50,000 to $75,000. He hates taxes, distrusts local government and may run for governor. Envision Corcoran taking credit for the amendment that would be on the same ballot.

There is no clamor to increase the homestead exemption, and it would have a devastating impact on local governments. The version passed by the House would cost local governments more than $700 million in revenue the first year. That would mean a loss of $50 million to Hillsborough County, $45 million to Pinellas and $17 million to Pasco. Counties and cities could not raise taxes enough to make up the loss. The only alternative would be deep cuts to law enforcement, fire protection, parks and other services.

Increasing the homestead exemption also would exacerbate the unfairness of Florida's tax system. It would shift more of the overall burden from rural counties to urban counties, because the state would send millions in general tax dollars each year to 29 fiscally constrained counties to offset their losses from the higher property tax break. The overall tax burden also would be further shifted from homeowners to businesses and rental property owners, which don't get the homestead exemption. For business-friendly Republicans and Democrats who champion poor neighborhoods with lots of renters, it makes no sense to increase the homestead exemption.

Corcoran and Negron tied all of the big policy issues to the budget and cut their deal in secret. Negron, R-Stuart, sold his soul for a reservoir south of Lake Okeechobee to store polluted water that triggered devastating algae blooms in his district. In return, Corcoran got support for his wrong-headed priorities: cuts in tourism advertising that are too deep, $200 million for charter schools that aren't wanted or needed, and a Senate vote on the constitutional amendment for the homestead exemption.

It takes 24 votes in the 40-member Senate to put a constitutional amendment on the ballot, and there was plenty of private arm-twisting over the weekend. Tampa Bay senators will play a key role Monday in determining the outcome. Senate Appropriations Chairman Jack Latvala, R-Clearwater, is expected to vote against it. Sen. Tom Lee, R-Thonotosassa, is the shameless Senate sponsor and predicts voters in his district overwhelmingly would approve it. What voters don't know is the amendment would mean fewer police, parks, and sidewalks, and even worse traffic as east Pasco and Hillsborough continue to grow.

Sen. Darryl Rouson, D-St. Petersburg, is in the middle. His district covers parts of both St. Petersburg and Tampa. St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Kriseman, Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn, Hillsborough County Commissioner Les Miller, Pinellas County Commissioner Janet Long and others warn Rouson raising the homestead exemption would hurt their communities. Rouson sometimes favors transactional politics over principle. This time, he should not sell his vote for a few pet projects. The stakes are too high.

Monday's homestead exemption vote is a test for the Florida Senate. Either senators reaffirm their independence and defeat it, or they bow to the speaker of the Florida House.


  1. Incoming Hillsborough School Superintendent Addison Davis (center), School Board Chair Melissa Snively (right) and the other board members pose as Davis signs his contract with the district on Tuesday night. The board unanimously approved the contract beforehand.
  2. Daniel Lee Martin performs during a 1999 benefit concert at Coachman Park in Clearwater. Martin was found dead Friday at his New Port Richey home.
  3. Hillsborough County Commission chair Les Miller.
  4. Tampa International Airport,
  5. William Domingo Luciano, 67, was arrested on Feb. 7, after detectives said they discovered more than 100 images of child pornography inside his home, located at 15702 Charr Island Street in Ruskin, records show.
  6. Hillsborough County commissioners voted Wednesday to launch the county's own sterile needle and syringe exchange program, becoming one of the first in Florida to take advantage of the state Legislature's 2019 decision to reverse a ban on the programs.
  7. A minivan drove through the back wall of a Bealls at the Gateway Market Center shopping plaza in St. Petersburg on Saturday afternoon. The driver was killed.
  8. Crystle Galloway, 30, died at Tampa General Hospital in July.
  9. Hillsborough County Tax Collector Doug Belden (left) and Public Defender for the 13th Judicial Circuit Julianne Holt received the Tampa Tiger Bay Club's fourth annual Lifetime Achievement Award on Monday.
  10. Police are seen near the location where a dog was shot by police after attacking a police horse along the Gasparilla parade route Saturday, Jan. 25, 2020 in Tampa. (Courtesy of Laura Josephson)
  11. Check for the latest breaking news and updates.
  12. This poster was seen January 21 inside a Brandon pet shop owned by All About Puppies, one of two pet retail businesses in Hillsborough County that were granted an exception from county laws prohibiting commercial pet stores from selling animals that came from breeders.