1. Environment

Government shutdown could stall climate change study and planning, thrusting researchers into 'political game'

For more than a month, Tampa Bay area climate change researchers have seen federal funding for new projects freeze up while key government employees are forced to stay at home.
Dr. Yasin Elshorbany, Assistant Professor, Chemistry, Environmental Sustainability, and Climate Change, poses in his office at the University of South Florida St. Petersburg on Wednesday. Elshorbany is set to submit a climate change research proposal to the National Science Foundation for funding, but the government shutdown has put that on hold. (SCOTT KEELER | Times
Published Jan. 23

Yasin Elshorbany builds models for a living. He studies large, complex forces and tries to understand how they shape our lives.

Normally, the parameters of Elshorbany's experiments at the University of South Florida St. Petersburg are elemental and quantifiable: x much gas will have y effect on z. A proposal by Elshorbany to research the economic impact of permafrost thaw in the Arctic could have implications for the national discussion around climate change.

But some 33 days into a partial federal government shutdown, his research is at the mercy of a much different force: politics.

Elshorbany's proposal has been put on hold by the longest government shutdown in American history. His study is just one example of how local climate change researchers are feeling the pinch. Federal grant money that would normally go to new scientific studies is frozen, and many government workers in the space are furloughed.

RELATED: Four ways you didn't know the government shutdown is affecting Florida

"It's a political game. That's what they want. They want to (put) pressure on the other party so they can start to negotiate. But the reality is affecting the entire team, and years of planning and research," said Elshorbany, an assistant chemistry professor.

Elshorbany has until Feb. 14 to apply for federal funding for his project, which could fetch hundreds of thousands of dollars in grant money. The ambitious proposal would require the help of researchers in multiple states to plug Arctic environmental data into existing economic models. Elshorbany believes there's a good chance he will win the funding.

After months of work, the proposal is nearly ready for submission to the National Science Foundation, Elshorbany said. But before he can submit it, the professor needs to hear back from a few government employees — who are legally forbidden from communicating with him during the shutdown.

The Feb. 14 deadline will almost certainly be pushed back, Elshorbany said. Still, he worries the project could be delayed indefinitely by the shutdown, preventing him and his colleagues from studying a threat that poses a present and future problem.

When permafrost melts, it releases planet-warming carbon into the atmosphere, creating a feedback loop of melting and warming, Elshorbany said.

"The melting of glaciers into the water will increase the sea level rise," Elshorbany said. "But where? Not in the arctic. Most apparently in the eastern U.S."

Climate change, by nature, is a slow-moving threat. It's impossible to know the practical effect of a delay in one academic study. But preparing for a phenomenon that could change so many lives takes a significant amount of planning. And planning, local officials say, relies on science.

Sean Sullivan, executive director of the Tampa Bay Regional Planning Council, said his group has seen hundreds of thousands of federal dollars frozen by the shutdown. For the council, which is charged with coordinating intergovernmental responses to major problems like climate change, that's no small thing, Sullivan said.

One $210,000 grant that the Tampa Bay Regional Planning Council can't access during the shutdown would fund a program that helps the region set a detailed hurricane preparation plan, Sullivan said. Another would help local researchers model and plan for sea level rise.

The planning council also works closely with researchers at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration to study the local effects of climate change, Sullivan said. Those employees will miss their second paycheck to the shutdown on Friday.

"We're in much better shape when we have our federal partners at the table," Sullivan said.

Heidi Stiller, one of those employees, sits on the Tampa Bay Climate Science Advisory Panel, which works closely with the planning council. Her group is working on updating sea level rise projections for the region.

She's at home, unpaid.

"I certainly hope the shutdown ends soon and I can go back to being in that group," Stiller said.

Not all climate change planning efforts are straining under the weight of the shutdown. The federal government isn't all that involved with climate change planning in the cities of St. Petersburg and Tampa, for example, officials in those cities said.

Bob McDonaugh, Tampa's administrator of economic opportunity, noted that major planning takes time.

"You're talking about something that's decades in progress, not something that's going to change in one month, two months," McDonaugh said.

But the longer the shutdown persists, said Stiller, the more difficult planning for climate change becomes.

And without proper planning, scientists say, everyone will feel the effects of climate change.

"We are all living in one earth, one system," Elshorbany said.

Times senior news researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report. Contact Kirby Wilson at or 727-893-8793. Follow @kirbywtweets.


  1. Motorists head north of Key Largo on U.S. 1, in anticipation of Hurricane Irma on Sept. 6, 2017.  Keys officials announced a mandatory evacuation Wednesday for visitors, with residents being told to leave the next day. [Associated Press]
    Elevating less than 3 miles of Old State Road 4A by 2025 could cost $75 million.
  2. Cooling canals, with Turkey Point nuclear power plant in the background. Miami Herald
    The Nuclear Regulatory Commission on Thursday announced that it had signed off on Florida Power and Light’s latest application for a 20-year extension.
  3. Tampa Mayor Jane Castor has made climate change a priority in Tampa. On Friday, she joined a national mayoral group dedicated to tackling the issue. DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Tampa’s mayor joins St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Kriseman with high-profile post on the climate crisis.
  4. Previous competitions did not round up a lot of the invasive snakes
  5. Workers repair a broken pressurized sewer line along 62nd Avenue N. JAY CONNER  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Private sewer pipes have always been the responsibility of property owners. Now if city officials notice a problem, they can force a homeowner to make repairs.
  6. An aerial view of the Apalachicola River near the Florida Panhandle town of Wewahitchka. Although the state has spent millions of dollars trying to protect the river from pollution, it is now planning to issue permit allowing a company to drill for oil near the river. Photo is by Rick Zelznak for Apalachicola Riverkeeper. BY RICK ZELZNAK  |  Rick Zelznak for Apalachicola Riverkeeper
    State on the verge of allowing drilling in both the Everglades and Apalachicola basin.
  7. Hurricane Dorian left homes in ruin in the Bahamas. FERNANDO LLANO  |  AP
    The season’s strongest storm, Hurricane Dorian, had Florida in sight but turned north before making landfall. The storm decimated the Bahamas.
  8. Two rare reddish egrets on Florida's Gulf Coast. Jim Bennight
    This is one of North America’s rarest bird species.
  9. As if on a post card, palm trees are reflected in glass panels at the Dali Museum Friday in St. Petersburg. CHRIS URSO  |  Times
    Florida’s signature trees do little to mitigate against carbon and intensifying heat.
  10. This is a king tide at the Key Largo Kampground & Marina in Key Largo. (Photo by Nancy Snyder) NANCY SNYDER  |  Photo by Nancy Snyder
    Monroe County is asking for $150 million to raise roads, elevate homes and even move critical buildings to higher ground.