1. Books

Review: Kate Atkinson layers stories of World War II in 'Life After Life'

Published Apr. 19, 2013

We all wonder at some time or another how our lives might have been different if we could go back and change one day, one moment. In Kate Atkinson's new novel, Ursula Todd gets to find out — over and over again.

I've loved all of Atkinson's novels, from Behind the Scenes at the Museum (1995) to Started Early, Took My Dog (2010). But Life After Life is flat-out magnificent, a virtuoso performance that had me slowing down in the last chapters because I didn't want it to end — then speeding back up because I had to know what would happen. And when I was done, I wanted to start all over again. (On Tuesday, it was one of six novels shortlisted for Britain's prestigious Women's Prize.)

The premise of Life After Life is less reincarnation, in which souls move on to new bodies and lives, than Groundhog Day — except that Ursula lives her whole life over, not just a day. And her awareness of that process is incomplete, slow growing, often dismissed as moments of deja vu or fragments of dream. Yet with each go-round, the most subtle changes have surprising consequences.

Why does her life keep repeating? Atkinson tantalizes us with the book's first chapter, a page and a half long and set in 1930. A 20-year-old Ursula enters a Munich cafe and is welcomed as a friend by a charismatic man surrounded by a fawning entourage. She eats some pastry, then draws a revolver from her bag.

" 'Fuhrer,' she said, breaking the spell. 'Fur Sie.'

"Around the table guns were jerked from holsters and pointed at her. One breath. One shot.

"Ursula pulled the trigger.

"Darkness fell."

That darkness will fall over and over again. In the next, even briefer chapter, the first of eleven titled "Snow" to cue us that her life is beginning again, Ursula dies before she draws her first breath. Her mother, Sylvie, is at the family's country home during a snowstorm when she goes into labor. Her husband is away, neither the midwife nor the doctor can get there, and Sylvie's only help, a 14-year-old maid, is useless when Ursula is born with the umbilical cord wrapped around her neck.

But a page later, in the second "Snow," the doctor gets there in time to deliver a "bonny, bouncing baby girl." Born in 1910, Ursula will be the middle child of five brought up by "beautiful, clever and somewhat contrary" Sylvie and her husband, Hugh. He is a banker as well as an affectionate father, so growing up at Fox Corner is something of an idyll, even when Hugh goes off to fight in the Great War.

Even so, Ursula dies — she drowns, she falls off a roof, she dies of Spanish influenza (twice), all before even making it to adulthood. But as Atkinson brings her through those cycles, she is bringing to life for us Ursula's world, England between the wars and then, in the book's expansive heart, during World War II.

That war, of course, brings plenty of other opportunities for Ursula to die. But Life After Life is the farthest thing from a morbid book — it is a rich, poignant, heartbreaking and hilarious celebration of living.

Atkinson has always created memorable, believable characters, and Life After Life teems with them. Ursula is, in every version of herself, engaging — smart, practical, quietly brave, self-effacing but independent. The Todd family is especially vivid, including Sylvie and Hugh, Hugh's wild sister Izzie and Ursula's siblings: obnoxious Maurice, reliably supportive Pamela, rambunctious Jimmy and — everyone's most beloved — bright and tenderhearted Teddy. Like Ursula's, their fates shift as their lives, too, are relived, but the cores of their characters remain intact.

The Todds are just part of a much larger cast, which expands with each version of Ursula's life. In one spin of the wheel, she visits Eva Braun and Adolf Hitler at Berghof, their vacation home in the Alps; in other lives, she works in London during the Blitz with a troop of stalwart volunteers who, when the bombs fall, rescue the injured from the rubble, comfort the dying and retrieve the dead. Those London chapters, brimming with horror and heroism, are simply breathtaking.

Another of Atkinson's trademarks is the multilayered, complex plot full of startling twists. Life After Life is a turbo-charged version of that, but I don't want to portray it as a dry puzzle book that requires the reader to make notes and connect every dot, or an esoteric exercise in fictional technique.

Life After Life has often stunningly beautiful prose, wry humor and heart-wrenching emotion, deeply human characters and enduring mysteries, and, above all, brilliant storytelling that will propel you through every one of Ursula's lives. Don't let your current life go by without reading it.

Colette Bancroft can be reached at or (727) 893-8435.


  1. University of South Florida professor Jay Hopler. Courtesy of Jay Hopler
    Plus, Diane Dewey will sign her memoir at St. Petersburg bookstore Haslam’s.
  2. Jill Ciment. Courtesy of Arnold Mesches
    The story of jurors on a Florida murder trial takes some wicked twists.
  3. Author Susan Isaacs' new novel is "Takes One to Know One." Linda Nutter
    ‘Takes One to Know One’ follows an ex-FBI agent uncovering hidden identity and crime in an upscale suburb.
  4. Florida Literary Legend Craig Pittman at work on the Ichetucknee River in 1999. Times (1999)
    His five books about the state and award-winning environmental reporting for the Times earned him the title.
  5. The 27th annual Tampa Bay Times Festival of Reading is coming up on Nov. 9 at the University of South Florida's St. Petersburg campus. Times (2017)
    Roy Peter Clark is also set to offer a workshop at Oxford Exchange in Tampa.
  6. Edie Windsor walks at the 46th annual NYC Pride March in 2016. Windsor was the Grand Marshal of the 2013 parade, just after the Supreme Court ruled in her favor and struck down the anti-gay Defense of Marriage Act. Her case set the stage for Obergefell v. Hodges in which the Supreme Court made marriage equality legal nationwide. A KATZ  |  a katz  |  Shutterstock
    It’s a pleasure to hear from the late lesbian trailblazer, whose landmark case set the stage for marriage equality nationwide. | Book review
  7. Graham Kropp, 9 and his father Steve Kropp, both of Seminole, shop for Star Wars items at the Clearwater Target, 2747 Gulf To Bay Blvd, Friday, October 4, 2019 in the Disney Store section. Friday was the release of this year's Force Friday Star Wars products. Target sales associate Kat McCauley, right, offers them some Star Wars themed cup cakes.  SCOTT KEELER  |   Times
    The “shop-in-shop” location is one of only 25 in the country and two in the state of Florida.
  8. Kristen Hare, author of 100 Things to Do in Tampa Bay Before You Die. Courtesy of Kristen Hare
    The author of ‘100 Things to Do in Tampa Bay Before You Die’ is reading Rick Riordan’s Magnus Chase series.
  9. Author Beth Macy Josh Meltzer
    This deeply researched history of the opioid crisis tells its human stories, too.
  10. The cover of "The Immigrant Cookbook," which podcaster and food journalist Janet Keeler will talk about at the Cathedral Church of St. Peter next week. Interlink Pub Group
    On the other side of the bay, John Cinchett is also scheduled to sign ‘Vintage Tampa Signs and Scenes.'