1. Arts & Entertainment

Once shot and buried alive, Phoebe grows into gentle companion

Phoebe leads owner Mike DeWitt, 54, up a hill this month in Lower Hillsborough Wilderness Preserve. About a year ago, DeWitt adopted the dog that had been shot twice in the head and buried up to her neck. “This dog is a miracle,” he said.
Published Dec. 27, 2013


On a quiet Wednesday night a little more than a year ago, Mike DeWitt turned on the evening news and saw a picture of a pit bull buried up to her neck.

She had been shot twice and left to die. Trapped.

It flipped a switch.

"It was instant. It was profound," DeWitt said. "I get that."

DeWitt had been trapped once, too. Two years before, he had held his wife in his arms as she died from cancer. What followed was a very dark time that he knows he would not have survived without the help of a close friend who wouldn't leave his side.

"I was going to be sure that dog was going to spend the rest of her days in a life that was filled with love and attention and all the things that dogs need to be happy, healthy dogs."

He had questions: Would a dog that abused be dangerous? Would she be trainable? Would the people who shot her be dangerous? But he didn't bother with the answers.

The next morning before work DeWitt, 54, sat in a business suit on the floor of Hillsborough County Animal Services. Phoebe crawled into his lap, emaciated, flea bitten, a belly full of worms, two bullet holes in her head. She had a medical file an inch thick.

And a new daddy.

It was another month before Phoebe was well enough for DeWitt and his new wife to take her home to Carrollwood. The first thing Phoebe did was turn a pair of his boat shoes into sandals. Then she crawled up on the coffee table and started chewing. She had never had any rules, but she was a pleaser.

"This dog is a miracle, and she came through it so beautifully," DeWitt said. "We have a routine life, which dogs like, and we're consistent with what we do. That's healthy for her."

She surprised DeWitt with just how good and gentle a dog she is after experiencing so much abuse. The DeWitts gave her a middle name: Gandhi.

"The beginning of her life was so horrible, and her response is to love everybody? How can she be that trusting after everything she's been through?" DeWitt said.

Phoebe was 30 pounds when she was rescued. Now she is a solid, healthy 55. A few bullet hole scars on her forehead where her fur won't grow are the only remaining traces of what happened, but she may never completely heal.

"She still has some bad dreams. She still will cry in her sleep. It's loud. It's not just a whimper, but a cry. It sounds like anguish, but she responds, usually to me, saying 'It's okay, It's okay,' " said Gerry DeWitt, 56.

Hillsborough sheriff's officials say they have identified the people who buried Phoebe in that yard in Clair-Mel, but they don't have enough evidence yet to charge them.

"That guy is going to do something worse one day. That is going to happen to a person before this is all over with, because you have to be a complete sociopath with no conscience or remorse to do that," DeWitt said.

Sundays are the best day of the week. DeWitt takes Phoebe, and another pit bull named Angel that he rescued years ago in the Green Swamp, to Lower Hillsborough Wilderness Preserve. He lets the dogs loose, throws their leashes over his neck and they hike together for hours. Usually they don't see a single person all morning.

"You have to be the change you want to see in the world. When people are in need, you help them. There's this great cycle that happens in the world, of goodness, when everybody just does their little piece," says DeWitt, who now works as director of Patient Relations at Moffitt Cancer Center in Tampa.

Phoebe smells something and races away from DeWitt's side, bounding toward a hill filled with knee-high grass. DeWitt smiles and picks up the pace to see what she's getting into. Blades of grass tickle her face as she runs, tongue flopping wildly, tail wagging furiously. Free.

Times researcher Natalie Watson contributed to this story. John Pendygraft can be reached at or (727)893-8247.


  1. Work continues on the Museum of the American Arts and Crafts Movement, seen here in August 2019. The museum was scheduled to open in December, but now the date has been pushed back again to early spring of 2020.
    The Museum of the American Arts and Crafts Movement was originally slated to open in 2017. That has changed many times.
  2. Yesterday• Arts & Entertainment
    Thrill St. Pete's 2018 version of its zombie dance to Michael Jackson's "Thriller" took place at the Museum of Fine Arts, St. Petersburg. There's a "Thriller" mob planned there and at Ferg's this week. MARTHA ASENCIO RHINE  |  Tampa Bay Times
    The last weekend before Halloween has some big costume contests and a Thriller mob scene, plus lots of trick-or-treating this weekend.
  3. The Sunshine Skyway Bridge is seen with lights Sunday, Oct. 20, 2019 in St. Petersburg. The Florida Department of Transportation installed about 1,800 colored LED light fixtures on the Sunshine Skyway bridge. BRANDON MEYER  |  Times
    Engineers will spend the coming weeks perfecting the displays, which include holiday themes.
  4. Post Malone performs during the Firefly Music Festival in June at the Woodlands in Dover, Del. OWEN SWEENEY  |  Invision/AP
    Rapper Post Malone and comedian Carlos Mencia perform in Tampa, while the four-day Cooters Crab Fest kicks off in Clearwater Beach.
  5. Barterhouse, which will debut in Tampa this month, has modeled its relaxed-meets-refined speakeasy atmosphere after 1920s-’50s Ybor City. Courtesy of Barterhouse
    Look forward to approachable, elevated dishes and bold drinks served in a speakeasy setting.
  6. Washington Nationals' Trea Turner, right, steals second with Houston Astros' Carlos Correa covering during the first inning of Game 1 of the baseball World Series Tuesday, Oct. 22, 2019, in Houston. (AP Photo/Matt Slocum) MATT SLOCUM  |  AP
    It’s part of Taco Bell’s, “Steal a base, Steal a Taco” promotion.
  7. The Tampa Bay Lightning will face the Nashville Predators at Amalie Arena in Tampa on Saturday. DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Classic cars on both sides of Tampa Bay and the Lightning host the Predators.
  8. On Sunday, the Festival of Jewish Books & Conversations will feature "Have I Got a Cartoon for You!" author Bob Mankoff. Moment Books
    The Gulf Coast chapter of the Authors Guild will also present a free workshop at South Pasadena City Hall.
  9. The Hillsborough County Fair, shown here in 2012, will continue in Dover with the popular demolition derby on Sunday. Times (2012)
    Big Halloween parties, the second weekend of the Hillsborough County Fair, a rodeo and the return of the SPIFFS folk fair.
  10. Chefs Ricardo Castro, left, and Rosana Rivera in Kitchen Stadium for their episode of "Beat Bobby Flay." STEPHEN DAVIS PHILLIPS  |  Food Network
    Here’s when, and where, to tune in.